News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Marketing automation is getting out-of-hand by Terretta on Friday December 09, 2016 @05:13PM (#13142318)
It's not "getting" out of hand. This exact mass personalized campaign style has been around since before the Internet.

I managed IT at a printing press where we used letterpress printing on cotton rag paper to "type" "personal" letters to lists of a million people. We "signed" the letters in different ink. We paid extra for first class stamps instead of postage meter.

And, we would send up to five letters in a series each referring to the one before, and by the last letter, we printed yellow highlighter over key sell phrases and 'wrote' in the margins with different colored ink to say this is the stuff that really matters to you.

These campaigns were deadly effective.

Re:Marketing automation is getting out-of-hand by jaxn on Friday December 09, 2016 @09:40PM (#13143691)
I ran for public office earlier this year and did this kind of thing.

I used MyScriptFont to create 10 different fonts of my handwriting using a sharpie. Then I wrote a script that would randomize each letter. We used this to create "hand addressed" envelopes that looked like I had written them with a felt tip pen. Two could go to the same address and you couldn't tell it wasn't hand written. We also did a series of letters and they were very effective. Every time we dropped one, my phone would ring from people calling me because they received my letter and wanted to talk about it.

This article isn't about marketing automation, it is about lazy marketing automation.

Re:Marketing automation is getting out-of-hand by comex on Friday December 09, 2016 @09:58PM (#13143744)
At the risk of excessive bluntness, isn't that pretty dishonest? You deceived voters into thinking they were individually important enough to you to spend your limited time personally handwriting a letter to them, while in fact the letters were mass produced and didn't reflect any individualized attention.
Re:Marketing automation is getting out-of-hand by iamdave on Saturday December 10, 2016 @02:52AM (#13144630)
Show me a campaign law that was broken doing this and I'll consider it a valid point. As it is, a candidate who does this to get my attention is probably a candidate I will likely pay attention to. If their message ends up sucking and I dont like their policies, I throw it in the trash and move on with my life.

End of the day, politics is a numbers game and moralizing over the typeface of a letter that at worst ends up in the junk heap is the last thing worth even an iota of energy getting comparatively upset about.

If someone feels so strongly about slick typeface maneuvers to get voters opening an envelope, I'd encourage that person to run for office themselves and make outlawing that sort of activity a campaign promise and let us know how it goes.

Re:Marketing automation is getting out-of-hand by pbadenski on Saturday December 10, 2016 @05:34AM (#13145032)
Overall I found your response rather cynical. Implying law being broken is required for a previous comment to be a valid point is harsh. There's campaign law and there's ethics. Just because some behaviour was never codified into law doesn't make it right.

Having said that, I think the ethics of this political strategy depends on the intentions. If a politician has true respect for the people, wants to give personal touch, and just doesn't have enough time to handwrite the letters - that's okay in my view. If a politician is purely looking for means of influence - that in my opinion is "not okay".

Re:Marketing automation is getting out-of-hand by jaxn on Saturday December 10, 2016 @09:44AM (#13145827)
If they never read your letter, then the contents of it don't matter.

The "handwriting hack" is all about getting people to open the letter and read it. I didn't get phone calls from constituents because of the handwriting, the phone calls were because of the content.

Re:Marketing automation is getting out-of-hand by iamdave on Saturday December 10, 2016 @03:36PM (#13147761)
Overall I found your response rather cynical. Implying law being broken is required for a previous comment to be a valid point is harsh.

The comment is valid, I don't think your premise is valid because I don't think the lines were sufficiently drawn to either a prescriptive or descriptive concept established in law. I also think the "ethical" premise is invalid equally.

I'm allowed to think premises are invalid and speak up on them; as of yet there hasn't been a convincing enough argument towards the 'ickiness' of using handwritten typefaces in a letter to possible voters to convince me otherwise.

If you're going to sit there and call that cynical, fine. That's on you, but I still think both premises are broken.

Re:Marketing automation is getting out-of-hand by dingaling on Saturday December 10, 2016 @05:24AM (#13144999)
It's not about what's legal or illegal. It's about what is right and moral and indicative of character.

So he starts his political career with a clever font hack, a little fib to his potential voters. Apparently not worth an iota of concern. So what's the next fib? Perhaps a broken election promise that he never intended to keep, just playing the numbers game? And so it may continue.

We always complain about our politicians looking after their own interests first. If we just shrug when they start their career like this, treating the electorate as a group to be tricked and fooled into action, is it any wonder?

Re:Marketing automation is getting out-of-hand by clarkmoody on Saturday December 10, 2016 @03:28PM (#13147731)
Have you ever gotten a political party "survey." You get this large packet, very expensive feeling, with a "serial number" on it so it looks custom for you. You go through the survey questions, and they are all right down the middle of how you feel about the country. "Yeah! I want us to ____!" You get hyped up knowing that the party will really deliver (this time).

And then you get to the end and it's got a donation form to give to the party, so that they can do everything you filled out in the survey. Probably very effective for many party members who don't think about it deeply.

Now, does that sort of campaign marketing material present a moral problem? I think it's just good marketing.

We could make a broader point about how all marketing wants you to envision yourself with [product / experience / political leader] and how that will make your life better. Is it all lies? Mostly. Is it immoral? Nah, it's just marketing :-)

Re:Marketing automation is getting out-of-hand by jaxn on Saturday December 10, 2016 @09:41AM (#13145815)
I encourage you to run for office some day.
Re:Marketing automation is getting out-of-hand by tripzilch on Sunday December 11, 2016 @04:09PM (#13153237)
You're conflating legal rights with moral rights.
Re:Marketing automation is getting out-of-hand by logicallee on Saturday December 10, 2016 @12:28AM (#13144204)
Jaxn, don't pay attention to this guy.

Thanks for telling us about what you did campaigning as a politician, and keep it coming.

The truth we learn is worth a lot more than ad hominem moraliziing.

Re:Marketing automation is getting out-of-hand by jaxn on Saturday December 10, 2016 @09:36AM (#13145788)
Maybe at some pedantic level you can argue it is deceitful.

It is common practice to use handwriting fonts to increase the response rate of mail. It is easy to discern that they are fonts. I just made it much harder to discern.

Re:Marketing automation is getting out-of-hand by hypertexthero on Friday December 09, 2016 @06:43PM (#13142894)
I recently received one of these letters (a 'happy holidays' postcard) from Chewy.com with postage stamps on the envelope, written and signed with what looked like real color marker pens, and my respect for the company immediately dropped.

I can see how it probably works with many people, but it doesn't change the fact that it is at best deceitful, at worse a lie.

Re:Marketing automation is getting out-of-hand by paulddraper on Friday December 09, 2016 @07:08PM (#13143022)
Advertising is always "deceitful". That guy didn't get ripped using stretchy band, no one is that happy when drinking Pepsi, and a new phone won't change your worldview.
Re:Marketing automation is getting out-of-hand by techsupporter on Friday December 09, 2016 @08:36PM (#13143488)
> Advertising is always "deceitful".

I think that the difference, at least to me, is that none of those examples are trying to be a personalized message. Imitating a hand-signed card that imitates "caring" says "we wanted you to have the same emotional reaction as if we did put in the effort but without us having to actually put in the effort." It's automating feelings and that rubs me the wrong way.

Ah well, just another step along the path of automating everything to the point where robots read the mail, respond to the mail, send the mass-mail, decide what to deal with and what to discard, then dealing with the discarded remnants.

Re:Marketing automation is getting out-of-hand by SerLava on Friday December 09, 2016 @10:16PM (#13143816)
Not really though. Plenty of ads just tell you a thing exists.
Re:Marketing automation is getting out-of-hand by ygtthyhgf on Friday December 09, 2016 @07:50PM (#13143252)
I for one can attest that there are times when I'm feeling down and some large drinks from a pepsi does make me happy. I get a high from it. I believe it is the gas bubbles that give you that rush.
Re:Marketing automation is getting out-of-hand by inimino on Saturday December 10, 2016 @01:18AM (#13144347)
Not the sugar and caffeine? You can switch to seltzer then.
Re:Marketing automation is getting out-of-hand by SixSigma on Friday December 09, 2016 @08:31PM (#13143465)
Maybe they signed it using one of these ?

http://axidraw.com/

Re:Marketing automation is getting out-of-hand by btown on Friday December 09, 2016 @08:57PM (#13143553)
No need when you can pay cents a letter for someone to sign all day...

https://www.google.com/search?q=handwritten+letters+online&i...

Re:Marketing automation is getting out-of-hand by chrisan on Friday December 09, 2016 @09:22PM (#13143634)
> we printed yellow highlighter over key sell phrases and 'wrote' in the margins with different colored ink to say this is the stuff that really matters to you

I received a "next level" type of spam like this. It was all of the above, but they also had a "hand written" Post-It/sticky note calling out the pricing on top of the ad.

It was like some friend received some typical throw away marketing in the mail, highlighted and stickied a couple sections and wrote me a personal note telling me how much I would enjoy this deal, then folded it all up and mailed it to me.

Re:Marketing automation is getting out-of-hand by harpiaharpyja on Friday December 09, 2016 @11:18PM (#13143992)
This makes me think about the importance of being able to separate the content of a message from the presentation. I wonder how much better off we'd be if everyone was just able to do that (or if we just took for granted that other people were sufficiently discerning). The throw away marketing is still just throw away marketing no matter how much highlighter there is on it, unless it actually happened to be relevant in the first place. In which case what point was there to the attempt at persuasion?
Re:Marketing automation is getting out-of-hand by bmh100 on Saturday December 10, 2016 @08:51AM (#13145634)
In the act of perceiving a message, it is impossible to separate the factual content from the presentation. At that moment, subconscious effects have already taken hold. Even conscious thought struggles to counteract that. The only really effective means is to have a prior, well-defined decision process to prevent yourself from rationalizing a subconscious decision. Even if the wording was completely objective and factual, I could still persuade by selecting which information to include, the ordering of facts, the phrasing, and even which particular, yet still objective, words I chose. In any message, influencing the recipient's perception of content through its presentation is actually unavoidable. Hence, the attempt at persuasion. Your perception of relevance could very well be subconsciously influenced from slightly "slightly irrelevant" to "relevant" by such small changes. Each marginal shift leading from a "no" to a "yes" would show up as small but relatively large changes in response rate. An increase from 0.5% to 0.75% would represent a 50% improvement in campaign performance.
Re:Marketing automation is getting out-of-hand by drumdance on Friday December 09, 2016 @07:40PM (#13143201)
The difference is scale. These days it's orders of magnitude cheaper to do that, so now we get orders of magnitude more offers.

I get tons of "personal" emails from sales reps trying to set up a short meeting with me to discuss my hiring needs.

Re:Marketing automation is getting out-of-hand by Swizec on Friday December 09, 2016 @05:54PM (#13142591)
Sounds like drip campaigns on steroids. Know any tips for how to learn more about this? I've found drip campaigns very converty, but I'm still a total newb.
Re:Marketing automation is getting out-of-hand by chinathrow on Friday December 09, 2016 @05:57PM (#13142609)
Drip campaigns sound like spam to me. That is, from an european perspective.
Re:Marketing automation is getting out-of-hand by devoply on Friday December 09, 2016 @07:15PM (#13143058)
Not really spam. The person you are e-mailing is using your product. So it's about connecting with that person and helping them use your product to such an extent that they stick around and pay for your product. It would be great if you could give your personal attention to each and every customer, but you can't.
Re:Marketing automation is getting out-of-hand by tomc1985 on Friday December 09, 2016 @09:23PM (#13143639)
It's way too easy to sign up for 10 different services and receive 10 different "personalized" e-mails, when you just wanted to be left alone and check things out. Most of the time if money is going to change hands I want a simple transaction, without additional humans sticking their grubby hands in and complicating things. High-touch sales does that.
Re:Marketing automation is getting out-of-hand by imron on Saturday December 10, 2016 @02:41AM (#13144596)
The problem exists because for every one of you (or me) there are ten others who convert better with the sticky drip campaigns.
Re:Marketing automation is getting out-of-hand by davidivadavid on Saturday December 10, 2016 @05:22AM (#13144993)
Drip campaigns generally happen after someone opts in somewhere. Not spam by any definition, european or not.