Re:Rest in Peas: The Unrecognized Death of Speech Recognition
by tjpick on Sunday May 02, 2010 @11:18PM
(#1313862)
I have conflicting anecdotes:
1. it's used heavily and successfully in medical dictation situations, ie medical professionals dictating case notes.
2. I was so excited about speech control in OSX, and I tried it, and it was shit because I had to speak with a terrible impression of an American accent to get it to do anything.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Rest in Peas: The Unrecognized Death of Speech Recognition
by robertfortner on Sunday May 02, 2010 @11:20PM
(#1313865)
I'd say they aren't really conflicting. Commercial speech recognition really started in the medical field. Accuracy is much higher with a controlled vocabulary.
Speaker-specific characteristics, e.g. accent, by contrast are much harder for recognizers.
Re:Rest in Peas: The Unrecognized Death of Speech Recognition
by cwinters on Sunday May 02, 2010 @11:45PM
(#1313908)
Medical dictation is a success for recognition, but it's important to remember that no such system can function by itself. Instead, they're often advertised as making the human transcriptionist's job easier -- reducing the number and type of fixes a human has to make when correcting the dictation results.
Re:Rest in Peas: The Unrecognized Death of Speech Recognition
by kowen on Monday May 03, 2010 @02:40AM
(#1314191)
I paid my way through college doing medical transcription. Throughout my time there, the hospital was experimenting with speech recognition, but the success rate was very low, and the doctors spent a lot of time going over and correcting the output. I believe they finally ditched the voice recognition software (though I do not know for sure).
I'm guessing that the reason the experiment failed at this hospital is that the language was non-English. In addition, most of the doctors were foreign, speaking with wildly differing accents. Also, many of the doctors would mix two languages when dictating, in addition to the usual Latin terms.
Basically, it was easier to just pay some humans to parse it.
Re:Rest in Peas: The Unrecognized Death of Speech Recognition
by tjpick on Monday May 03, 2010 @02:56AM
(#1314223)
the ones where it is successful invest quite a bit into training the software and the doctors use macros heavily.
Re:Rest in Peas: The Unrecognized Death of Speech Recognition
by jessriedel on Monday May 03, 2010 @04:39AM
(#1314346)
My anecdotal evidence from a surgeon in the family is that the medical dictation is still very bad. His practice of 4 doctors spent a bunch of money on Dragon, fought with it for a month, and then went back to old-fashioned human dictation.
Re:Rest in Peas: The Unrecognized Death of Speech Recognition
by tjpick on Monday May 03, 2010 @02:59PM
(#1315700)
from what I remember, you might be right that Dragon is not that great, PowerScribe is the one I remember being more popular -- I was doing RIS (Radiology Information System) work at the time about a year ago.