Why there will never be a model of a cell
http://robertfortner.posterous.com/bard
Even as computing power and data increase exponentially, systems biologists now say an in silico model of the cell isn't possible
http://robertfortner.posterous.com/bard
Even as computing power and data increase exponentially, systems biologists now say an in silico model of the cell isn't possible
http://robertfortner.posterous.com/bill-gates-imprimatur-on-science-and-the-21st
Space exploration, genetic engineering and cancer are out as research priorities. Malaria and global health are in. Because of Bill Gates, the 21st century will look very different from 20th century visions of the scientific and technological future.
It's not happening in space (although hypersonics seem to be getting more real). It's not happening in AI or speech recognition/understanding. It's not happening in medicine.
So the net empirical situation looks like the opposite of what Kurzweil says. Only IT and Moore's Law are going totally nuts. One can conjecture about why, but I think that's conjecture and there aren't deep fundamental principles about scientific and technological progress, at least that we've found so far.
I was very surprised to find that recognition accuracy stopped getting better a long time ago. I do poke fun, but I also think Kurzweil (as I said in the piece) very reasonably believed that Moore's Law would get us a long way to AI. And surprisingly, it hasn't.
I like to think I don't have a stake in the argument and just let what's actual decide whether or not we're going to get to computer understanding of language and/or AI.
That's the real surprise. It's not a question of computing power.
Speaker-specific characteristics, e.g. accent, by contrast are much harder for recognizers.
http://robertfortner.posterous.com/the-unrecognized-death-of-speech-recognition
Speech recognition seems good on a cell phone but accuracy for conversational speech flatlined in 2001--and no one noticed. Computer understanding of language was supposed to lead to artificial intelligence. Now we have need AI to get computers to understand language. Catch 22. We just haven't recognized it yet. (Sorry, Ray Kurzweil.)