I am completely mystified by your reply.
This is exactly what they did and what the data shows. 50% of kids today make more than their parents, vs 90% of kids 60 years ago made more than their parents.
I feel like we're missing each other points though...
"50% of people today make more than their parents"
"50% of people today make more than people a generation ago made."
If yes, do you see how the difference might be relevant to whether people today have it easier or harder than people in the previous generation?
2) Others are pointing out that the message of the graph is not the absolute percentage, but the trend line. The graph purports to show that the chance of greater earnings of (30-year-old maybe parents) vs (their own definitely parents at age 30) has decreased relatively linearly from 90% to 50% over the last 50 years. This could be explained by a demographic change in who has children over the same time frame, but it's not absurd to assume that the dynamics have remained constant even though the differences between the groups are unknown.
3) I'd be wondering more about how they accounted for inflation, since the manner in which this is done would drastically effect the results. I think the question essentially boils down to "at a given decile of earnings, does the average person today have a better life than the average person 30 years ago?" I don't know how one could answer this rigorously.
"50% of people today make more than their parents."
"90% of people 60 years ago made more than their parents."
If yes, what is the problem that you have with this study again?
For example it doesn't mention birth control once.
Economic pressures can affect the decision to have children. Especially once birth control became widespread.
I think this is not necessarily so. However...
I've seen a number of persons who have children and who believe your statement (or similar statements, e.g., "Having kids makes you more responsible", etc.) to be true.
And so they promote/hire a younger person who has chosen to pursue a family path rather than a more qualified person with a superior skill set.
I can't read the article, as it's behind a paywall. Does the article say that? If not, where does that claim come from?
Further, not all of the children's parents were younger than 30 when they had their child. Being childfree at 30 does not mean childfree at 40.
The question is also not "whether things have gotten harder for the average person". The article clearly states:
"Economists and sociologists from Stanford, Harvard and the University of California set out to measure the strength of what they define as the American Dream[1], and found the dream was fading. They identified the income of 30-year-olds starting in 1970, using tax and census data, and compared it with the earnings of their parents when they were about the same age."
The question is the viability of an American dream based on opportunity for children exceeding that of their parents.
From the article:
“My parents thought that one thing about America is that their kids could do better than they were able to do,” said Raj Chetty, a prominent Stanford University economist who emigrated from India at age 9 and is part of the research team. “That was important in my parents’ decision to come here.”
ADDED LATER. A careful study or newspaper article on the question of whether people have it harder or easier than they did 30 years ago or 45 years ago would try to avoid comparing populations that a reasonable person would expect to differ for reason other than things in the country getting harder or easier. Whether or not my sentence above containing the phrase "are healthier, smarter and wealthier" is true, clearly one might reasonably expect systemic differences between people who have children or will go on to have children and people who do not.
Even if the "nonparent" group were on average more intelligent than the "parent" group, that would also be a reason to avoid omitting the "nonparents" from the older cohort in the study.
The fact that the OP does not even try to avoid those systemic differences suggests that either the author is not sufficiently skilled at statistics to be writing about what he or she is writing about or someone is trying to argue for some conclusion he or she is attached to, e.g., "it is awful how hard things have gotten in this country for the average person" or the article author is making the headline more dramatic than the situation actually is in order to get more clicks.