News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why I Believe Scratch Is the Future of Programming by onion2k on Thursday December 08, 2016 @05:19AM (#13129473)
People who will code will code even if you don't push them to.

The booming industry of coding boot camps shows that there are a large number of people who want to code but didn't have the opportunity or knowledge to learn until they were old enough and wealthy enough to pay for private tuition. I would argue that is strong evidence that your assertion is wrong - it's a reasonable assumption there are a number of people who are capable of coding and who want to code but can't afford private lessons and therefore won't ever become a coder.

Lowering the barrier to starting, to the point where it's as simple as running an app without any cost (beyond access to a computer), is a very good thing that greatly benefits a huge number of people.

Re:Why I Believe Scratch Is the Future of Programming by mrob on Thursday December 08, 2016 @05:36AM (#13129532)
I suspect the majority of those coding boot camp customers do not want to code, but want money, and see coding as an easy way to get it.
Re:Why I Believe Scratch Is the Future of Programming by jholman on Thursday December 08, 2016 @08:31AM (#13130133)
Why do you suspect that?

Having talked with over 200 of them, I'd suggest that just like people in most career training programs, there's something about the job (as they imagine it) that attracts them relative to other jobs. "Huh, that looks like a good job, and I suspect I can do it, maybe I should invest some time and money into finding out!"

I don't think anyone thinks it's a get-rich-quick plan; no one expects it to be easy. And if they do think that, they revise their estimates on the first day of bootcamp. But many of them DO suspect that as a career, coding pays well relative to the amount of work it is, and has good growth prospects. I too believe that, so I'm sympathetic to their perspective, although I doubt it's the BEST career in those aspects (I hear trades are really quite lucrative). The degree of "passion" for various particular aspects of the career is variable (e.g. desire to do the act of coding, e.g. desire to produce software, e.g. desire to work in startups, e.g. desire to make mad bank, e.g. desire to have flexible working conditions, e.g. desire to get paid to do math). Few of them have had wildly successful careers in other domains (I believe that between 1% and 3% of my sample were already making six figures in another career), so the majority are hoping that this will be their successful career.

In summary, it is true that all of them expect that learning to code might be somewhat economically productive, but your phrasing is condescending and nasty. Don't be nasty.

Disclaimer: I have a vested interest in bootcamps being at least somewhat successful.

Re:Why I Believe Scratch Is the Future of Programming by onion2k on Thursday December 08, 2016 @06:13AM (#13129636)
You have no evidence for that, and it's a pretty horrible thing to say about the people who take those courses.
Re:Why I Believe Scratch Is the Future of Programming by mrob on Thursday December 08, 2016 @08:55AM (#13130246)
What's horrible about that? People doing things for the money is the driving force behind capitalism, the best economic system yet invented. It improves everybody's quality of life. I have no objection to people going to coding boot camps because they think it will help them make money, and I hope they succeed.

But I don't think coding boot camps are evidence for great love for coding for its own sake. People who really want to code will find some way to do it no matter what. They don't need paid tuition.

Re:Why I Believe Scratch Is the Future of Programming by onion2k on Thursday December 08, 2016 @11:05AM (#13131192)
People wanting money is fine. It was the assertion that they "see coding as an easy way to get it" that's too harsh. In my experience people who have been through coding bootcamps are very aware that they're learning something hard and that they'll need to put in a lot of effort, and that they're starting a new career where they'll be a junior in their first role unless they're very lucky.
Re:Why I Believe Scratch Is the Future of Programming by dwaltrip on Thursday December 08, 2016 @09:02PM (#13136101)
Seriously? Paying to learn a skill is a sign of impure motives? That seems like a very unfair assumption. Not everyone can learn on their own in their spare time.
Re:Why I Believe Scratch Is the Future of Programming by throwaway29911 on Thursday December 08, 2016 @05:36AM (#13129535)
What do you mean by "opportunity"? If they have 3 months to go to a camp, surely they could as well learn at home for those 3 months.

It's the certificate and contacts they're after (and pay dearly for).

Re:Why I Believe Scratch Is the Future of Programming by onion2k on Thursday December 08, 2016 @06:06AM (#13129611)
What do you mean by "opportunity"?

If you were unfortunate enough to attend a school that didn't have any sort of computing classes, after school groups, etc, or you lived somewhere rural that didn't have those programmes outside of school then you would have had no access to a mentor who can guide you.

If they have 3 months to go to a camp, surely they could as well learn at home for those 3 months.

In order to learn on your own you need some knowledge to start with. If you sit down in front of a computer with zero knowledge of a subject then you don't even know what to put in to Google, and if you start with a search like "how to code" you have no way to assess whether the websites you find are actually useful or a waste of time.

Languages like Scratch can teach someone to code when they have no external input. They might teach "bad" ideas, but those can be unlearned and replaced with better concepts later. Most of us learned by starting with something like BASIC and have gone on to learn better techniques. There's no reason why someone learning today has to start with a "good" language like Python.

Heck, I started with Visual Basic 6. That's was far worse than Scratch as far as teaching bad practices go.

Re:Why I Believe Scratch Is the Future of Programming by StavrosK on Thursday December 08, 2016 @06:21AM (#13129662)
> If you were unfortunate enough to attend a school that didn't have any sort of computing classes, after school groups, etc, or you lived somewhere rural that didn't have those programmes outside of school then you would have had no access to a mentor who can guide you.

I grew up in a small Greek village at a time when very few people knew what a computer was. My first exposure to programming was finding a CD with all sorts of things in it, including Visual Basic 4. I had no internet, so literally the only thing I had to go on was the VB language reference (the reference, as in, this function does that), and a two-page tutorial on making a temperature converter.

I taught myself programming using just that reference and tutorial, and nothing else. I don't believe courses are necessary if you want to learn programming.

Re:Why I Believe Scratch Is the Future of Programming by onion2k on Thursday December 08, 2016 @06:33AM (#13129696)
I don't believe courses are necessary if you want to learn programming.

You're wrong. There are lots of developers who are self-taught, and just like you they didn't need a course. That's awesome. Similarly though there are lots of other developers who aren't self-taught, and for whom the process of how to think about code didn't "click" with them until they were taught the basics. Those developers needed a course.

People aren't all the same, so what works for one person won't necessarily work for another, and given the number of developers society will need in the future we will have to afford opportunities to every type of learner.

Re:Why I Believe Scratch Is the Future of Programming by berntb on Thursday December 08, 2016 @06:36AM (#13129705)
>> given the number of developers society will need in the future

It really is 1999 all over again. :-( :-)

Re:Why I Believe Scratch Is the Future of Programming by dwaltrip on Thursday December 08, 2016 @09:06PM (#13136115)
Be careful when projecting your experiences onto others.

I would be very surprised if you honestly can't conceive of people who would struggle immensely to teach themselves the way you did. Or even if they could succeed in doing so, that it might take too long or be too financially risky.

I personally know plenty of people like that. Some of them are very intelligent as well.

Re:Why I Believe Scratch Is the Future of Programming by StavrosK on Friday December 09, 2016 @06:16AM (#13138071)
People are reading more into my comment than what I said. The GP said you can't learn to program without a mentor or access to resources, and I suggested that you can, to which he both agreed and disagreed.
Re:Why I Believe Scratch Is the Future of Programming by throwanem on Thursday December 08, 2016 @06:06AM (#13129609)
> What do you mean by "opportunity"?

The opportunity of access to extensive mentorship and a solid curriculum. Those things make a good boot camp a more efficient way to learn than doing it entirely on your own, not least because you don't have to discover all the blind alleys and mistakes for yourself. (Like I did! But I started at age six. An adult looking to learn a trade skill has not the luxury of a whole lifetime to spend doing so.)

Re:Why I Believe Scratch Is the Future of Programming by berntb on Thursday December 08, 2016 @05:36AM (#13129533)
Right now it is the same as in the Millennium bubble -- programming is a simple way to get a well paid job.

But sure, some of the people jumping on the train then and now are lifers.