The article wasn't suggesting a three step process (1 enter username+password, 2 validate email 3 enter username+password), it was suggesting a two step process (1 validate email 2 enter username+password).
These two desirable features, email verification and minimal friction are not incompatible. It is possible to allow a user to login right away and verify email in parallel. It could also be possible to ask the user to double check the email if the email validation failed. It could also be possible to force a delayed email validation.
The later might be required for user who porvided a fake address when just testing the service or want to make sure they wont be spammed by the site owner. A reminder with a "don't show me again" check box would address these cases and everybody would be happy.
Re:Rethinking email confirmation
by laurent123456 on Thursday December 08, 2016 @04:20AM
(#13129287)
> For example after registering an account a user can be immediately logged in with a banner displayed at the top until their account has been validated via email
That still wouldn't solve the problem the author proposes to solve. If you accidentally entered someone else email, that someone might click on the link and you'll never see the banner.
A possible solution: if you click the "verify email" link you are brought to a verification-form where you need to enter your password.
Re:Rethinking email confirmation
by ProbabilityMoon on Thursday December 08, 2016 @05:10AM
(#13129440)
This is literally presented in the article. (ಠ_ಠ)
Re:Rethinking email confirmation
by bryanrasmussen on Thursday December 08, 2016 @03:22AM
(#13129100)
Minimal friction is especially desirable in startups that are trying to grow their user base that provide some sort of service that is not tightly bound to identity, but it is not always the most desirable measure.
The problem this idea proposes to solve is an edge case, and there are better solutions. For example after registering an account a user can be immediately logged in with a banner displayed at the top until their account has been validated via email, with the option to change their email address if they entered it incorrectly on registration. There's no additional friction, and the minority of users who do make a mistake with their email are covered.