For all I know the iPad may do that so it can shut down memory chips and save the power of refreshing them. Just because it doesn't do exactly what you wand doesn't mean it's handled badly - it still does what it does gracefully and without errors or slowdowns.
It does after all not claim to be able to hold pages open indefinitely; and you could have saved them to some ereader app for future Reading.
Misuse ipad -> doesn't do what you want, is hardly a 'dirty secret'
What position, that I used to hold, am I backing away from?
As you were countering the support being given for the thesis, I took it that you were attacking the article's thesis (thus defending Jobs' characterization). But then your comment moved the goal for what constituted "best" so far that it functionally proved the thesis of the article. I apologize that I was overly eager to point this oddness out and did so badly.
Overall I'm a fan of the iPad, it just falls short in this area.