Re:Set in Your Ways: Perl 6’s Setty and Baggy Types
by throwanem on Wednesday December 07, 2016 @06:41PM
(#13127250)
Yeah, I cottoned to that eventually - it's short(er)-hand for Perl 5's qw() construct. I guess Set is a method (coercer!) of...lists? List-shaped things? Sets seem list-shaped, although indexing doesn't work by any syntax I could find, and certainly not by any that an @ sigil should suggest. Can I call Set on a set? Does it do something weird if I do? And if I'm going to deal with this kind of high weirdness, why not just bite the bullet and go with Haskell or even Urbit? This just feels like it's trying to out-Ruby Ruby, and Ruby is Ruby enough already.
The OP had some snark to offer on the subject of "Texas" operators, and the documentation lists them by their Unicode glyphs. That they work I get. But I think it's reasonable to gather a sense of second-class citizenship from their presentation.
Re:Set in Your Ways: Perl 6’s Setty and Baggy Types
by kbp on Wednesday December 07, 2016 @09:36PM
(#13127989)
What "high weirdness"? Sets in most languages that have them do not support indexing, because they're usually understood to be unordered. Aside from that, there is a method to convert a list to a set. What are you confused about?
Re:Set in Your Ways: Perl 6’s Setty and Baggy Types
by hsitz on Wednesday December 07, 2016 @10:07PM
(#13128126)
Yes, in mathematics sets are by definition unordered, so it would be strange to have a language that supported indexing of a set.
Re:Set in Your Ways: Perl 6’s Setty and Baggy Types
by ab5tract on Thursday December 08, 2016 @06:15AM
(#13129645)
It's fun to answer questions that could be easily answered with a single invocation, but here goes: coercing a set ($set.Set) is a no-op.
my $set-of-sets = set $set;
The above will create a new set with $set as its only member.
I think you are mistaking `<a b c d>` with a `Set`. `< >` is a shorthand for "give me a `List` of these words" (or in this case, characters). `<a b c d>.Set` would coerce you a `Set` from that list. The set operators coerce by default, so you can pass it a list of words without requiring you to coerce it yourself beforehand.