Completely agree with your point. One nit:
> If Coke becomes generic for Cola, then they can lose their right to enforce their copyright.
That should say 'trademark' rather than 'copyright'. Copyright and patents don't become less enforceable if they are selectively enforced. The same is not true for trademarks.
Corrected, thanks! They occupy a similar place in my mind, and while I purposefully and deliberately made an effort to use the correct one initially, I accidentally regressed later...
I grew up in one of those regions and was flabbergasted when, at the age of 8 or so, I moved to Seattle and asked for a coke and they gave me a Coke without asking what kind of coke I wanted (Dr. Pepper of course). I then proceeded to protest to a very confused clerk that I wanted a Dr. Pepper coke, not a Coke coke.
Re:DoomRL Open Source Release
by discordianfish on Thursday December 08, 2016 @05:18AM
(#13129471)
Good point.. Wondering though if it is really necessary. I'd argue such 'homage' supports the brand identity. It's not like some random shooter uses the name Doom in which I would understand the argument.
what can coke even do if the restaurant brings you a generic cola? seems like the wrong level at which to be fighting this battle.
You know, I decided to look this up, and I'm not having luck from Google getting info on Coca Cola sending people to check on restaurants. I believe I heard it as an anecdote from a fairly reliable (not not directly related) source, so I believed it, but I admit I have little to back it up at this point. So, I'm note sure if it really happens, much less what they would hope to accomplish specifically if they do do that.
xerox and escalator are good examples, too.
Related to the first, a dramatic (and hilarious) reinactment of actual deposition transcripts.
1: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Generic_trademark