Re:Power Poser: When big ideas go bad
by etrautmann on Tuesday December 06, 2016 @04:26PM
(#13118474)
It's not a terrible hypothesis. The fact that it doesn't replicate doesn't make it a bad idea to have had in the first place - only one that didn't stand up to (further) investigation.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Power Poser: When big ideas go bad
by Bartweiss on Tuesday December 13, 2016 @12:16PM
(#13168468)
It was a reasonable idea and worth testing, but I think we should start the criticism a step earlier than replication. There were a lot of issues with the original study, both methodological failures (testing saliva after giving rewards) and academic ones (the admitted p-hacking).
This was a worthwhile experiment that would never have reached initial publication if held to existing best practices.