and
"Our intent is not to criticise medical intervention," he said. "But it's had an evolutionary effect."
The article said everything you said, and more, in what way did it "not get science right"?
But she did not answer the main question that was asked: why the human pelvis has not grown wider over the years? She said that there were two opposing forces, one for larger babies (they have more chance of survival), and the other was natural selection preventing them getting too large (by killing them both in childbirth).
Maybe I'm missing something, but neither of those answer the question of why the pelvis has not got larger.
All I can assume is that it is (a) an evolutionary trend of men to be attracted to younger and potentially, on average, slimmer and more healthy or fertile women, and (b) cultural, since there is evidence that in historic times and possibly also in less technologically advanced societies, larger hips are considered desirable (which makes total sense in a society with no access to modern medicine).
I'm sure some anthropologists will beat me up for these terrible generalisations, but in general, on average, it seems these forces may have an impact on pelvis size over generations?
3 of your 5 paragraphs are a single sentence.
Nobody has to die to voluntarily select this out of the population. The Jewish community has been on the forefront of this for a long time. On the border of eugenics I guess, but self selecting against genes that will cause suffering or death.
There are plenty of other instances where our advancements have likely influenced our evolution. For one, the ease at which we can today travel between continents means that there's far more breeding between different races than we've ever had in human history. Should that be stopped? We also don't run/walk nearly as much as we used to thanks to harnessing hydrocarbons...should we continue to try to select for the long-distance running abilities that helped our ancestors kill animals for food during persistence hunting? And I'm betting that certain people are genetically more predisposed to catching measles, polio or any of the other diseases for which we've developed effective vaccines...would we want to make sure that those genes don't get passed on?
In short...why optimize for a world that doesn't exist? Unless you subscribe to a belief in a post-apocalyptic future where modern technology regresses and mankind is forced to live in a more primitive state, there's really no need for us to actively do anything...the magic of evolution is that it just happens naturally. Now, evolution can be an uncaring bitch to individuals, so there's plenty of reason why an individual would want to screen their offspring for certain genetic traits, but at the societal level, it's just swimming against a really strong current.
We should optimize for a world that works, instead of one we believe we'll be able to fix forever, and constantly requires purposeful effort to work. Would you like to carry your Fix The Generalized Imbalance Pills (FTGIMP, f-gimp how we call it, as in: "Hold on love, the trekking has been fun, but know I gotta take the f----gimp") when you decide to go for a bike ride? Or will you tell me "but how many people do you know that go on bike rides for more than 10 minutes?". How many people travel the world on a shoestring? Should they stop doing that?
Would you like to go to space? How large should the infirmary be? With all these things that "we know how to do" and will be required to do, if we don't get a better vessel.
I agree the world has changed. But this vessel is still better when it is self sufficient to the max. Instead of long distance running, we will need low maintenance living. Requiring vaccines, failing joints, birth complications will not help. The resources are limited. It helps no one, in the long run, to make living more complex.
It needs significantly more resources (time, labor, medication) and therefore should negatively affect host's fitness but in most developed countries it does not. NOW we optimize for a world that does not exist.
In the normal course of evolution women with narrower pelvis die a painful death while delivering a baby (or the baby dies). Thus the genes that give women a narrower pelvis do not get passed on.
We can not let these women die this horrible death. This is a good outcome.