Unless this is the case, having 3-D Secure only benefits merchants as the liability will now be shifted from the merchant to the cardholder (e.g. the cardholder is now liable for fraud) while the (stolen) card can still be used for a non 3-D Secure payments.
I rarely use my CC online. Asking me for my 3-D Secure password means asking me to log into my bank and use a physical second factor to set a new password.
Likewise, requiring 3-D Secure on my credit card makes me much more likely to pick a different payment method since I don't feel like doing the above. (Or rather, I might not even be carrying the phone/token needed for it.)
Seems like someone has figured this out. I haven't seen a 3-D Secure prompt in a while.
There's also no reason for me to like it: Without 3-D Secure, fraud is a minor hassle and I'll get my money back. With it, the bank may try to put the responsibility on me, even though I can't distinguish a real 3-D Secure page from a phishing page because they're all IFRAMEd per their official recommendations.
There's just not much incentive to support it. You have to make it optional, otherwise your conversion rate drops like a rock. And, if you make it optional, only a very tiny amount of customers ever use it...and the ones that do are VERY unlikely to be fraudulent users. Thus, the shift in liability isn't really an incentive.
The only way it would work would be to make it 100% mandatory. The checkout path would be harder on customers, but they couldn't choose to go to a competitor's site that didn't require it.
My company uses Ravelin for this - we feed them lots of data, they do some kind of machine learning, and they feed us back a recommendation.
Depending on what recommendation we receive, we either let the transaction through without 3DS, block it completely, or only allow it with 3DS.
Most that I've used are fixed passwords (and they ask you for the character at certain positions) while others will ask you for personal information that is rather easy to obtain.
This is at least my experience. From the handful of cards I've used from different banks, only 1 used to send me a code via SMS.
(this was in the UK)
3-D Secure flow is separate from the normal authorization flow and require the merchant (or payment gateway) to set it up. The merchant (or the gateway) is required to build or purchase an MPI from an approved vendors to make it work.
Unfortunately, some (most) websites don't support 3-D Secure. I remember that almost all Turkish e-commerce sites I shopped supported it but almost none of the American sites supported it.
[1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/3-D_Secure