This kind of dismissal of a no-doubt nuanced opinion on a scientific issue based on "what you found in five minutes on the internet" brings literally nothing to the conversation.
The reason that droughts don't appear to be getting worse overall is that the rain is moving from one place to another. So some places that used to get more water are now getting less, and places that used to get less water are now getting more. But this is still a problem because it's very hard to move agricultural infrastructure to chase the rain.
Among many other possible explanations.
Look, you wanted to show the author wrong, for whatever reasons, and you went looking for something and went with the first thing you found.
Now, rather than admitting there was nothing there, you really want to argue about the causes of wildfires? Your point was not a good one. Just admit it.
Like what?
> you wanted to show the author wrong
No, absolutely not. I would like nothing better than for the author to be right, and for climate change to not be causing any serious problems. But I'm pretty sure that there is actually a lot of evidence that climate change is causing serious problems. The only reason I'm harping on this one dataset is, as I said, I'm on a slow internet connection and so I can't do any comprehensive research at the moment. I'm going the best I can with what I've got.
> No, absolutely not. I would like nothing better than for the author to be right
I think we are basically done here, but I just want to point out this rhetorical trick.
You demonstrate motivated reasoning pretty clearly throughout this thread, which is why I called out that you started with your conclusion and then looked for facts and arguments to fit (debate-team style). When I point that out here, you dodge with "I would like nothing better than for the author to be right", which neatly deflects the point.
My criticism is not that you would prefer the author is wrong, but that you clearly started from a conclusion that he is wrong. That is why it didn't really matter to you what particular evidence you had, you just went with it. So pointing out that you would prefer if the author was right (misrepresentation aside) sounds like you are addressing my criticism, without actually doing so.
I started with a strong Bayesian prior that he is wrong, yes. But it is important to not to lose sight of what is actually in dispute here. We are not arguing about whether climate change is actually increasing extreme weather events, we are arguing over whether the evidence for this is "scant". To dispute that claim, it suffices to show that evidence exists. Which it does:
http://www.cgd.ucar.edu/cas/adai/papers/Dai-drought_WIRES201...
You read the article, concluded the author was wrong, and posted anecdotes and a link about wildfires.
After it was pointed out that the author said nothing about wildfires, you suggested that wildfires are caused by droughts, while admitting that the rain is moving around. Why not admit that your point about wildfires was simply off the mark?
After I pointed out that wildfires can be caused by other things than droughts, you asked for me to name them, while admitting elsewhere that the wildfire issue is complicated. Why not simply admit that obviously there are many causes of wildfires?
After I pointed out that you misrepresented what the author said as "not causing any serious problems" then you switched to whether or not the evidence is scant. Why not just admit that you misstated the author's position?
After admitting that "scant" means something more like "insufficient" rather than "nonexistent", you are now saying that to dispute the claim requires only that some evidence exists. Why not simply admit that the issue is more complicated than it seemed to you at first glance and that you may have jumped the gun?
> But it is important to not to lose sight of what is actually in dispute here.
Indeed.
Note that I am not responding at all to the drought data you found. I am simply pointing out the unreasonable way you are arguing.
OK: my comment about wildfires was off the mark.
> Why not just admit that you misstated the author's position?
OK: I misstated the author's position (initially)
> Why not simply admit that the issue is more complicated than it seemed to you at first glance and that you may have jumped the gun?
OK: I may have jumped the gun.
> Note that I am not responding at all to the drought data you found.
Ah.
> Like what?
Now you are just being deliberately obtuse. You already responed to my comment where I provide an alternative explanation of changes in fire policy, and you agknowledge that "the situation with respect to fire is very complicated".
> I would like nothing better than for the author to be right, and for climate change to not be causing any serious problems.
The author never made such a claim, going so far as to state: "I believe climate change is real and that human emissions of greenhouse gases risk justifying action, including a carbon tax."
Sorry, I'm juggling a lot of threads here.
> The author never made such a claim
The author claimed that there is "scant evidence" that climate change is causing extreme weather events, including drought. Being a resident of California, which is in the middle of its worst drought in history, that claim seems improbable to me. (Note carefully: the claim that I find highly improbable is not that climate change is not causing extreme weather events, but that there is "scant evidence" that climate change is causing extreme weather events.)
I first tried looking up actual drought data, but it's all hiding behind high-bandwidth visualizations which I cannot currently access. So I went with what I could find.
[UPDATE:] Found this:
http://www.cgd.ucar.edu/cas/adai/papers/Dai-drought_WIRES201...
So I think it is fair to say that the evidence that climate change is causing increased severity of drought may be debatable, but it is not scant.
... which is not even remotely what the author said. We are in "Did you read the article?" territory here.
> I'm going the best I can with what I've got.
What that means is that you've picked your conclusion, you scrounged some premises, and constructed an argument to fit.
It seems you're approaching this in a high school debate-team, rhetorical, "but what about" style and not actually honestly looking for facts.
The author said that there was "scant evidence" that climate change is causing extreme climate events. That is what I dispute. I believe the evidence is not scant. In fact, I'm pretty sure the evidence is quite plentiful, but I cannot demonstrate that at the moment because of resource constraints (very low bandwidth internet).
But you could go look up the drought data and prove me wrong, at least about that. (But then we would still have to talk about the author's very misleading claim about hurricanes: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13099156)
[UPDATE:] Found some accessible drought data:
http://www.cgd.ucar.edu/cas/adai/papers/Dai-drought_WIRES201...
>>> The increase in wildfires can be largely attributed
>>> to the increase in droughts in some areas.
>
>> Among many other possible explanations.
>
> Like what?
Drought certainly plays a role, but I think a changing strategy of fire suppression will make it difficult to prove causation from the statistics. A gigantic confounding factor is that the approach to handling forest fires changed dramatically in the timeframe you refer to, with a shift from "put it out immediately" to "let it burn", then a backlash leading to somewhere in the middle:Until around 1970, federal land managers remained obsessed with controlling large fires. But during the 1960s, scientific research increasingly demonstrated the positive role fire played in forest ecology. This led in the early 1970s to a radical change in Forest Service policy—to let fires burn when and where appropriate.
From this the "let-burn" policy evolved, though it suffered a setback in the wake of the 1988 Yellowstone fires. Since around 1990, fire suppression efforts and policy have had to take into account exurban sprawl in what is called the wildland-urban interface.
http://www.foresthistory.org/ASPNET/Policy/Fire/Suppression/...
Of course this doesn't mean that drought has not caused more fires, but it's going to make "total acres burned per year" very hard to use as evidence. Pielke has written about fire in other places:
"Influence of Location, Population, and Climate on Building Damage and Fatalities due to Australian Bushfire: 1925–2009"
http://sciencepolicy.colorado.edu/admin/publication_files/20...
I only skimmed it quickly, but it seems to claim that once you've normalize for development, the severity of bush fires in Australia has not changed significantly over the century. Given the difficulty of separating policy from climate, I'm not sure I'd ever take it as firm proof, but it probably gives more insight into Pielke's thought process.
Like what?
Increased rainfall generally correlates to more thunderstorms and thereby more lightning-induced wildfires, for just one example.It's as ridiculous to cite an increase in forest fire severity and frequency as proof of ACC as it is to cite a few particularly bad snowstorms to deny it. Deniers will legitimately cry foul when you use the same bogus rhetorical tools that you forbid to your opponents.
We can't be sure from this data, but there is a very plausible causal model that leads from drought to fires. It just seems highly plausible that drought over woodland would result in more fires. But I don't have access to that data at the moment. Anecdotally I can tell you with high confidence that the Gatlinburg fire, and most of the recent mega-fires in California, as well as the one up in Canada that made the papers a while back, were all associated with not just drought, but historic drought. That might just be a coincidence, but until someone actually runs the numbers you can't assume that.
In any case, it is pretty clear that something has changed. Do you have a better theory to offer?
You don't just jump into a debate about someone's scientific integrity with unrelated web links and speculation that you just pulled out of your ass, and then back out with "well we can't be sure, what do you think?"
Instead of leveling ad hominem attacks at me, why don't you go look up the drought data?
The claim that evidence is scant or not would need to take into account all the evidence on the effects of climate change on current weather events. You could cherry-pick tons of evidence to support either position, if that's your thing.
If you wanted to shed some light on the topic of the article, it would be more interesting to see what the author's background is and follow up some of the claims about why he was fired by 538, whether he is being unfairly attacked in the media, etc.
Remember that this article isn't primarily about the science, it's about the journalism. The only reason we are talking about wildfires is because you brought it up, which was really quite a stretch.
It is hard to mount one's best arguments when one is operating under tight resource constraints and time pressures. HN threads get stale very quickly.
> You could cherry-pick tons of evidence to support either position, if that's your thing.
Heh, this whole disagreement may actually be a mistake on my part about the meaning of the word "scant." I thought "scant" meant "rare or non-existent" but it doesn't, it means "barely sufficient or adequate." So I was about to say that if there's tons of evidence to be cherry-picked then it cannot be scant. But I suppose it could be.
In any case, I did finally manage to find some drought data:
http://www.cgd.ucar.edu/cas/adai/papers/Dai-drought_WIRES201...
That's a review with 137 references, so the evidence doesn't look "scant" to me. But I suppose a reasonable person might disagree.
Here is the original article[1] and a rebuttal[2], both on 538. Doesn't read like wild-eyed denialism to me.
[1]: http://fivethirtyeight.com/features/disasters-cost-more-than...
[2]: http://fivethirtyeight.com/features/mit-climate-scientist-re...
Ah, another rhetorical ping-flood attack, forcing the recipient to do the research necessary to dispute a vague positive claim.
Normally I would agree with this, but there are extenuating circumstances here. I'm not fobbing the research off on you out of laziness, I'm doing it because drought data is voluminous, summaries turn out to be very hard to find, and I'm on an extremely slow internet connection.
But I did finally find this:
http://www.cgd.ucar.edu/cas/adai/papers/Dai-drought_WIRES201...
> to dispute a vague positive claim
My claim is not vague. It is very specific: the evidence that climate change is increasing extreme weather events is not "scant".
That's not how this sort of debate works. Not when you're demanding trillions of dollars' worth of global economic rewiring.
The basis on which I say this (aside from having done a lot of reading on the philosophy of science): I used to be a scientist working for NASA. I was not a planetary scientist, I was a computer scientist, but I was doing research (in AI), writing grant proposals, etc. My productivity was measured in peer-reviewed publications. So I have some first-hand insight into how the process works, how it is supposed to work, and how these two things often differ.
The key point here is that you and I should be able to openly debate acres burned vs total number of fires without me trying to track you down and get you fired, or you having me banned from HN.
If what you care about is how many trees there are (and that's what I care about) then the number of acres burned is clearly the metric that matters.
The trend has been a transition from a lot of little fires to a few huge ones. One of the reasons that the number of fires has dropped is that by the time the mega-fires are brought under control there is nothing left to burn.
> The key point here is that you and I should be able to openly debate acres burned vs total number of fires without me trying to track you down and get you fired, or you having me banned from HN.
That is certainly true. But there is nothing wrong with firing an academic for doing sloppy and possibly politically motivated research. I don't know if that's what this was, but I do have some actual data that indicates that it could be the case. And this data is not obscure nor was it particularly hard for me to find, so it seems likely that when I have the bandwidth to do a more thorough search I might find more evidence that this guy's research was in fact sloppy and politically motivated.
The fact that he published this piece in the WSJ, whose biases are well known, is another indication that this is not a clear-cut case of political correctness run amok. It could be, but it's far from a slam-dunk.
[UPDATE:] More evidence of bias: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13099156
Or, without little fires, flammable undergrowth accumulates that makes the fires that do occur even larger. Unlike most natural disasters, humans are very active in directly manipulating fires. This makes it difficult to attribute changes to fire statistics to underlying environmental changes, or fire control practices.
If you can't see why "the first thing I found may not be holding up well to criticism, but since it only took me five minutes to find, there obviously must be a lot more out there" is a bad argument, then you're just rationalizing.
However, I think it is telling that so far not a single participant in this conversation has (AFAICT) even tried to get to the actual drought data to see if there is anything there. Somewhere out there, one of you has to be on a high-bandwidth connection, so you could go get the data and settle this, where I currently cannot. That would seem to me to be a more constructive (to say nothing of definitive) way to address this than to accuse me of confirmation bias and rationalizing.
[UPDATE:] Found some drought data:
http://www.cgd.ucar.edu/cas/adai/papers/Dai-drought_WIRES201...
http://www.cgd.ucar.edu/cas/adai/papers/Dai-drought_WIRES201...
So I think it's fair to say that while the evidence may be debatable, it is not "scant".
Try telling that to the residents of California or Gatlinburg, TN.
OK, anecdotes do not constitute data. So here's some data:
https://www.nifc.gov/fireInfo/fireInfo_stats_totalFires.html
Look at the number of acres burned, which is the metric that matters. The upward trend over the past few decades is unmistakable even without fancy statistical tests. And that's just what I was able to find in five minutes on a ridiculously slow internet connection.
It's hard to tell the difference between "there is scant evidence" and "there wasn't any evidence where I happened to look for it."
[UPDATE:] Here is some evidence that the author is being deliberately deceptive: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13099156