News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Practical Common Lisp (2005) by gigamonkey on Saturday December 03, 2016 @05:24PM (#13097795)
I plan to. Some day.
Re:Practical Common Lisp (2005) by chris_wot on Saturday December 03, 2016 @08:26PM (#13098317)
Dear God man, please do! I'm into the start of chapter 3 and have suddenly discovered that in fact lisp is not obscure or hard or anything like I was told years ago in high school.

I mean, my introduction to lisp was something to do with concat but it was so divorced from reality that I literally found an early book on C programming and semi-self taught myself it, then found a book called C Pointers and Dynamic Memory Management that literally changed my life.

I have a feeling if I'd read this book I'd have actually done something awesome by now. Frankly, this book might allow me to do something that I've been itching to do for months now.

I can't really express my appreciation enough... but I'll try right now: thank you! A million times over, thank you!

Edit: so Arc - is that like a Webserver based on lisp?

Re:Practical Common Lisp (2005) by cageface on Sunday December 04, 2016 @12:36AM (#13098915)
Lisp is a fantastic language and well worth learning.

But these days I pick a language with strong static types every time if I have the choice. I know you can use them with Lisp too to some extent but it's not the same as a language built from the ground up around types.

Re:Practical Common Lisp (2005) by gigamonkey on Tuesday December 06, 2016 @04:57PM (#13118683)
Totally. I had been thinking about writing a Haskell book but it seems that space is maybe well covered lately.
Re:Practical Common Lisp (2005) by KingMob on Saturday December 03, 2016 @08:48PM (#13098387)
Arc was Paul Graham's take on a modern Lisp. There are some cool essays on it, but I don't think the software itself ever moved much past alpha stage.
Re:Practical Common Lisp (2005) by brudgers on Saturday December 03, 2016 @08:54PM (#13098411)
It's the language in which Hacker News is implemented and currently developed.
Re:Practical Common Lisp (2005) by krapp on Saturday December 03, 2016 @09:15PM (#13098466)
Doesn't HN use a proprietary fork of Arc?

I've never been entirely certain what the relationship is between YCombinator and the Arc community, if any, but one experimental and partially black-boxed forum doesn't signal a mature language, just one adequate to a particular task.

What else have people done in Arc?

Re:Practical Common Lisp (2005) by Immortalin on Saturday December 03, 2016 @09:42PM (#13098551)
Arc has served as material for a lot of speculative blogposts and helped create buzz for the lisp community.
Re:Practical Common Lisp (2005) by brudgers on Saturday December 03, 2016 @09:46PM (#13098560)
Being a Lisp, I'm not exactly sure what would constitute a proprietary fork. Furthering my uncertainty is that it [Anarki] is built on Racket and that kinda makes it hard to say one implementation is forked from another.

Anyway, I didn't intend to claim that Arc was a mature language.

Re:Practical Common Lisp (2005) by chris_wot on Saturday December 03, 2016 @08:50PM (#13098395)
Yeah, I just did a quick bit of reading. Ironically, I think I might be groking lisp because it appears ldap filters are lisp expressions, which I've used quite a few times at work...
Re:Practical Common Lisp (2005) by agumonkey on Sunday December 04, 2016 @03:54AM (#13099325)
Hi fellow monkey lisper (or senpai should I say).

What topic are you into these days ? Or maybe you were planning for a sequel to PCL ? in both case really eager to see the resulting book(s).

Re:Practical Common Lisp (2005) by gigamonkey on Sunday December 04, 2016 @02:24PM (#13101310)
Well, these days I'm working at Twitter on our abuse problem. So that keeps me pretty busy. I did write another book, Coders at Work, a book of interviews with notable programmers.

I kind of suspect that if I write another book (as I hope to) that I'll continue along the trajectory from pure technical (PCL) to semi-technical (Coders) to something that might reach an even more general audience.

Re:Practical Common Lisp (2005) by smnplk on Saturday December 03, 2016 @06:05PM (#13097924)
Maybe a Clojure version with similar approach ?
Re:Practical Common Lisp (2005) by tsm on Saturday December 03, 2016 @06:26PM (#13097993)
How useful would that really be? PCL has Peter's take on Lisp, and the Joy of Clojure occupies a similar niche if you just want to learn specifically-Clojure.

At one point he mentioned writing a book to the effect of Statistics for Programmers, which sounds intriguing to me. AFAIK it hasn't happened yet, though.

Re:Practical Common Lisp (2005) by nextos on Saturday December 03, 2016 @07:23PM (#13098167)
> Statistics for Programmers

Why intriguing? The most general family of distributions can only be expressed with a programming language, so there are certainly many connections between both fields.

Incidentally, that's one of my major complaints about Lisp these days. Lisp-Stat started dying in the early 2000s and completely faded away long ago. I read PCL when it was published a decade ago and I fondly remember how enthusiastic I became about Lisp.

I have used Clojure extensively, but the ecosystem for doing math and statistics is quite reduced. The same applies to CL and Scheme. I wish I could use one Lisp for most tasks.

Re:Practical Common Lisp (2005) by JadeNB on Sunday December 04, 2016 @11:03AM (#13100349)
> > At one point he mentioned writing a book to the effect of Statistics for Programmers, which sounds intriguing to me.

> Why intriguing? The most general family of distributions can only be expressed with a programming language, so there are certainly many connections between both fields.

That seems to be an argument for why it is intriguing. Were you perhaps arguing that it wasn't surprising?

Re:Practical Common Lisp (2005) by disgruntledphd2 on Sunday December 04, 2016 @05:49AM (#13099535)
R is about as close as it gets (it is quite lispy underneath all the C-like syntax).
Re:Practical Common Lisp (2005) by pjmlp on Sunday December 04, 2016 @10:30AM (#13100240)
Julia and Wolfram as well.
Re:Practical Common Lisp (2005) by smnplk on Saturday December 03, 2016 @09:49PM (#13098564)
I was thinking about something completely new. I know one can easily (more or less) follow along PCL and do the solutions in Clojure. I just think that Clojure space needs a book like this, with emphasis on practical. I like the practical section in PCL book at the end, where author builds useful little apps and guides you through the thought process. I know about Joy Of Clojure, great book, but it doesn't contain enough toy projects. I think the goal of the book is to help you start thinking functionaly.
Re:Practical Common Lisp (2005) by zintinio5 on Saturday December 03, 2016 @10:24PM (#13098639)
I'm working on a book covering parallel and concurrent programming in Clojure, with the style of building abstractions before actually using them. On the topic of Joy of Clojure, as far as I could tell, the book is not meant to be an introduction to the language, rather meant to be read once already familiar. It's helped me internalize concepts I'd picked up through usage.
Re:Practical Common Lisp (2005) by smnplk on Monday December 05, 2016 @01:14AM (#13103700)
Sounds interesting. Where do you plan to release your book ?
Re:Practical Common Lisp (2005) by kbp on Saturday December 03, 2016 @09:57PM (#13098582)
> I know one can easily (more or less) follow along PCL and do the solutions in Clojure.

Maybe for the first chapter or two, certainly not most of the book. They're very fundamentally different languages.

Re:Practical Common Lisp (2005) by zodmaner on Sunday December 04, 2016 @03:02AM (#13099234)
Maybe you could warm up by releasing a new, updated edition of Practical Common Lisp? ;)
Re:Practical Common Lisp (2005) by agumonkey on Sunday December 04, 2016 @03:52AM (#13099323)
Practical Uncommon Lisp
Re:Practical Common Lisp (2005) by svetlyak40wt on Sunday December 04, 2016 @07:25AM (#13099744)
Or Practical NonLisp, or Nonpractical Common Lisp.
Re:Practical Common Lisp (2005) by agumonkey on Sunday December 04, 2016 @08:36AM (#13099928)
These imply either inconsistency or impracticality of Lisp, quite an offense ;)