As far as alternatives to UBI go, a lot of people have the hope that automation (indirectly) will create new jobs, and society will ultimately adjust to fill those jobs. I don't know if this will always happen. Many people aren't going to buy any pastry or ask for gardeners if only a handful of them can afford these things to begin with.
I think so, too.
But I also think the new jobs would be better if they weren't created because of fear, but because people wanted to do them.
There is a litany of reasons why. Mostly on the "I agree in principal but..." basis. Here are three.
1. The Big Bang.
A change as drastic as UBI should be introduced gradually. Fucking up on this scale would have enormous repercussions. For instance: one could gradually lower the age of retirement until everyone is retired (or you could lower taxes, or discount healthcare... you get the idea).
If these are untenable propositions, then UBI definitely is.
2. Poison In The Well.
If the government is the arbiter of UBI funds, then it gains a type of power it currently does not possess. If there exists criteria for taking UBI away from an individual or group, then the government has the ability to 'tone police' (like China's social credit system) in a way which has more in common with authoritarian dictatorships than a Western style state. Having the autonomy of providing your own food, shelter and other resources enables you to have political independence even if everybody doesn't like you. Not so under UBI. Your economic state is hitched such that only the wealthy now have the right to political opinions. Moral panics should not be able to affect funding.
The left and right shall tear UBI apart like a rag doll and it could even become the fulcrum through which a civil war begins. If people feel a threat to their source of food exists you'd have an Arab Spring situation.
3. The Parasite Traveller.
There is a contradiction between UBI and having open borders. You must have very close to closed borders to citizens of poorer countries or UBI states which are less wealthy.
You have to choose between values. There is no state on this planet capable of UBI for all.
I mean, what are the alternatives?
You can prohibit automation per law, so that everyone can stay in their jobs. This will probably fail because not every country will pass such laws.
You can try to teach the people new stuff that can't be automated easily.
But does a clerk want to become a pastry chef or gardener (some of the harder to automate jobs it seems)?
Or teach them "higher" education in the hopes they can create their own automations and make money with it, but how much of these clerks are good enough to get through universtiy decades after they left school.