News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ex-Adobe Engineers on Thoughts on Flash by BudVVeezer on Friday April 30, 2010 @03:25PM (#1309143)
"A simple 'Hello World' app created in Flash and compiled to work on the iPhone is substantially larger in file size, and it would take up 3.6 MB when it should be no larger than 400K when made with Xcode..."

Am I the only one that finds both scenarios to be ridiculous? 400k or 3.6MB doesn't matter -- both are stupidly large just to put up hello world...

Re:Ex-Adobe Engineers on Thoughts on Flash by Qz on Friday April 30, 2010 @04:17PM (#1309298)
Making Hello World apps is an edge case for commerical software development frameworks. They're not optimized for it and there is no reason for them to be.
Re:Ex-Adobe Engineers on Thoughts on Flash by wtallis on Friday April 30, 2010 @08:36PM (#1309860)
When your framework is made to build apps that may be downloaded over the air on the nation's least reliable cellular network, you should at least try not to include the kitchen sink with every app. Waiting for the app to download is the user's first impression after clicking "buy".

Hello World is not just an edge case - it's a lower bound. There are plenty of non-trivial apps that can be implemented in under the ~3MB overhead for Flash. Once multitasking arrives, this kind of overhead will be even more important, because small single-purpose utilities will be more useful. Also, if the overhead is 3MB on-disk, the in-memory overhead is likely to be even bigger, and it's not likely that it could be shared between several Flash utilities running simultaneously.