News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Windows 10 in-place upgrades are a severe security risk by devoply on Monday November 28, 2016 @10:27PM (#13060533)
Come join Linux my friends. My fedora hat wearing greybeards wait for you. Only operating system left that gives semblance of privacy and security.

And to those who think I am derailing... http://news.softpedia.com/news/microsoft-wants-all-linux-dev...

Re:Windows 10 in-place upgrades are a severe security risk by danieldk on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @02:52AM (#13061547)
Only operating system left that gives semblance of privacy and security.

You mean the operating system where with the default display server any application can read keystrokes, read mouse events, and make screen grabs of any other application? The operating system where no apps are sandboxed by default? The operating system where once you find a local root exploit, which are not rare, you can embed a root kit deep in the operating system?

Sorry for the harsh comment, but Linux is hardly the pinnacle of security. (Perhaps with rare exceptions like Qubes or RHEL with SELinux on servers.)

Re:Windows 10 in-place upgrades are a severe security risk by devoply on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @03:27AM (#13061680)
> can read keystrokes, read mouse events, and make screen grabs of any other applic

As compared to Windows in which an app can't do that?

> The operating system where no apps are sandboxed by default?

As compared to Windows or Mac where apps are sandboxed by default?

> The operating system where once you find a local root exploit, which are not rare, you can embed a root kit deep in the operating system?

As a desktop user, not sure how this applies. Windows has rootkits as does Mac.

However, every time I boot my computer my computer doesn't call home. I am also not worried about government agencies having unfettered access to my machine as a default setting. With Windows I don't know that. When I install Mac I give them my e-mail address and thereby my identity just to install the operating system. They also have my credit card number. When a Mac calls home they have my IP. So anything I do online can be traced by to my identity as a default setting through Apple... a company not located in my country.

As I said a semblance of security and privacy. Better than no semblance which at this point is the case with Windows and Mac. I know it's not real security, but best that no money can buy at this time.

I also have Windows. It's for playing old games... Surprising they still work after 15 years.

Re:Windows 10 in-place upgrades are a severe security risk by CJefferson on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @04:34AM (#13061924)
> As compared to Windows in which an app can't do that (read keystrokes of other apps)

Yes, Apps can't do that.

> As compared to Windows or Mac where apps are sandboxed by default?

Yes, apps from both the windows and mac App Stores are sandboxed.

I'm not sure what your point is. I'm not saying Windows is perfect at all, but the GUI security is better. If nothing else, consider the classic ctrl+alt+delete, which no app can catch. On Linux there is no way to be sure the 'login' you are seeing isn't a program someone has installed to capture logins. On Windows I know the login is genuine if I press ctrl+alt+delete.

Re:Windows 10 in-place upgrades are a severe security risk by tokenizerrr on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @07:12AM (#13062552)
> Yes, Apps can't do that.

I have AutoHotKey and ShareX. The first reads keystrokes from anywhere, and the second takes screenshots from anywhere and anything.

It's pretty clear that Windows applications most definitely can do that.

Re:Windows 10 in-place upgrades are a severe security risk by pjc50 on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @07:37AM (#13062653)
The parent comment is (slightly obtusely) talking about "UWP Apps", which are installed from the store and have mobile-style "sandboxing". Normal Win32 applications can of course use SetWindowsHookEx() and the DirectDraw screen functions to take over your screen.
Re:Windows 10 in-place upgrades are a severe security risk by josteink on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @07:55AM (#13062722)
> The parent comment is (slightly obtusely) talking about "UWP Apps", which are installed from the store and have mobile-style "sandboxing".

And if he is, that's an absolutely academical points as 99% of all Windows-users runs zero applications from the store.

Nothing like an imaginary straw-man argument on the internet, eh? :)

Re:Windows 10 in-place upgrades are a severe security risk by kalleboo on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @10:00AM (#13063383)
> As I said a semblance of security and privacy

Unless you happened to install Ubuntu, which used to send all your local file searches to the cloud to find Amazon deals

Re:Windows 10 in-place upgrades are a severe security risk by devoply on Wednesday November 30, 2016 @03:39PM (#13074490)
True. Though we knew about it immediately and could apt-get remove that stuff quite easily too.
Re:Windows 10 in-place upgrades are a severe security risk by chris_wot on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @10:19AM (#13063513)
And does not any more?
Re:Windows 10 in-place upgrades are a severe security risk by devoply on Wednesday November 30, 2016 @03:38PM (#13074480)
no.
Re:Windows 10 in-place upgrades are a severe security risk by danieldk on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @05:30AM (#13062175)
As compared to Windows in which an app can't do that?

Windows provides UI isolation between privilege levels:

https://msdn.microsoft.com/en-us/library/bb625963.aspx

As compared to Windows or Mac where apps are sandboxed by default?

As the sibling commenter mentions. Mac App Store applications are required to be sandboxed:

https://developer.apple.com/library/content/documentation/Se...

The same applies for Windows Store apps.

Windows has rootkits as does Mac.

Mac has system integrity protection (SIP). Even as root, you cannot replace system files (unless you disable SIP):

https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT204899

So, in contrast to default Linux distributions, a root kit cannot replace system files (a common trick that root kits apply is to replace system files to preserve itself during reboots and to hide the root kit, e.g. by hiding it from 'ps' output).

Moreover, macOS only loads signed kernel extensions, so it is not possible for a root kit to inject itself as a loadable kernel module. I think the same is true for Windows, but I am not familiar enough with Windows.

I am also not worried about government agencies having unfettered access to my machine as a default setting.

You are throwing two things one one heap now: (1) having a backdoor and (2) sending out usage data.

If you believe that there is a difference between Linux, macOS, or Windows when it comes to (1), this is utterly naive. Linux distributions have a large number of package maintainers and upstream projects. You cannot be certain that none of these ten thousands of people is compromised and inserts a subtle backdoor. And even if you are certain about this, it's likely that government actors have a collection of exploitable remote and local exploits.

When it comes to sending out data, such as usage data, use an app firewall. E.g. with a program like Little Snitch, it is easy to configure which program can contact what server in the outside world.

Ps. Linux has the potential to be very secure. A lot of the technology is there (e.g. Wayland and SELinux). The problem is that the Linux community is too conservative and/or believes in the myth that Linux is already secure.

Re:Windows 10 in-place upgrades are a severe security risk by Accacin on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @10:19AM (#13063524)
Sorry, but how many people actually use the Mac and Windows app stores?
Re:Windows 10 in-place upgrades are a severe security risk by danieldk on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @01:30PM (#13065057)
I think that you are underestimating the use of the Mac App store. Many applications are only available in the app store, just to give some examples of popular Mac Apps: Pixelmator, Affinity Designer, OneDrive, Pages, Numbers, Keynote, iMovie, Garage Band, Tweetbot, and Airmail. Then there are many Apps that can be purchased both through the Mac App Store or from the vendor, such as Omni{Graffle,Focus,Outliner}, Fantastical, 1Password, Photoshop Elements.

The majority of apps that I install come from the App Store.

Moreover, some vendors also sandbox non-app store apps. E.g. Chrome tabs, Photos, or Safari tabs.

Re:Windows 10 in-place upgrades are a severe security risk by bitmapbrother on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @03:10AM (#13061623)
No, he means the OS that runs the Internet, powers the majority of enterprise systems and inside nearly all of the of embedded and IOT devices.
Re:Windows 10 in-place upgrades are a severe security risk by mavhc on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @03:18AM (#13061649)
Should probably keep quiet about the IoT part.
Re:Windows 10 in-place upgrades are a severe security risk by danieldk on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @05:15AM (#13062104)
And Windows runs on the vast majority of desktops, so what is your point?
Re:Windows 10 in-place upgrades are a severe security risk by cmdrfred on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @08:38AM (#13062932)
Who will have a desktop in 10 years? (Besides developers)
Re:Windows 10 in-place upgrades are a severe security risk by pshc on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @09:54AM (#13063343)
Most professionals?
Re:Windows 10 in-place upgrades are a severe security risk by cmdrfred on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @10:44AM (#13063699)
Why not laptops with docking stations? That's what I see more and more recently.
Re:Windows 10 in-place upgrades are a severe security risk by Grishnakh on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @11:13AM (#13063924)
That's the same thing. There is no OS I'm aware of that has separate versions for "laptops" and "desktops"; a laptop IS a "desktop" these days, as opposed to a "mobile device" running a mobile OS (Android/iOS).
Re:Windows 10 in-place upgrades are a severe security risk by mavhc on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @01:08PM (#13064854)
13 year old kids around here all call desktops laptops anyway
Re:Windows 10 in-place upgrades are a severe security risk by sdegutis on Monday November 28, 2016 @10:42PM (#13060606)
In all seriousness, why is Fedora the mosts worthy Linux out of them all, in terms of privacy and security? I thought those two were kind of an inherent staple of all Linux distros? In the past I've used Debian Stable with AwesomeWM (the inspiration for Mjolnir) and it felt pretty secure?
Re:Windows 10 in-place upgrades are a severe security risk by sjellis on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @08:25AM (#13062862)
I've only been following Fedora development from a distance, and haven't had time to look at Fedora 25 yet. From memory, there's a bunch of things:

* Fedora and Ubuntu are more aggressive about compiling security features into the packaged binaries, whilst Debian considers package build flags to be the decision of individual maintainers, so coverage is more piece-meal.

* Fedora ships SELinux enabled. I believe that current versions of Android is the only popular non-Red Hat Linux-based system that does that. The common compliant about RH's SELinux implementation is that it is so restrictive about system integrity that it blocks actual system administrators from doing routine tasks unless they remember to change the appropriate SELinux policy settings first.

* Fedora 25 now uses a Wayland implementation for managing graphics by default, rather than X, so that the security issues of X don't apply.

* Fedora 24+ includes Flatpak, so that there is a system for sandboxed applications. Fedora 25 provides the UI integration for non-technical users to run Flatpak packages (once developers build them).

* The RPM/DNF package management system is more stringent about checking downloaded packages than APT.

Re:Windows 10 in-place upgrades are a severe security risk by devoply on Monday November 28, 2016 @10:49PM (#13060629)
I meant the hat not the distro. I use Ubuntu, I am happy with it. Before that used Debian and Slackware. Was happy with those too. Used it for 15 years. Can't complain. I don't feel my computing has been hurt by using Linux. And over time it seems as it's the only sane choice.
Re:Windows 10 in-place upgrades are a severe security risk by 3131s on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @12:48AM (#13061134)
I misread your post too, but now it's clear on a reread that you meant the hat!

I am also a proud and happy Linux user going on about 10 years now, and what's great is that I know all the knowledge I've acquired will still be relevant many decades into the future -- not sure the same can be said of Windows or MacOS.

Re:Windows 10 in-place upgrades are a severe security risk by Sylos on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @09:22AM (#13063153)
It did have a comparatively low number of security vulnerabilities in 2015.

I also often see it brought up that Fedora uses SELinux by default.

Re:Windows 10 in-place upgrades are a severe security risk by type0 on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @12:00AM (#13060946)
Fedora 25 is best ever, you should try it. Now that then replaced X with Wayland it should become be ever more secure.
Re:Windows 10 in-place upgrades are a severe security risk by na85 on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @12:27AM (#13061047)
Does Fedora still recommend wipe->reinstall from scratch as the default upgrade path?
Re:Windows 10 in-place upgrades are a severe security risk by embik on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @01:55AM (#13061377)
I'm not sure what they recommend, but the in-place upgrade path for Fedora works really really well.
Re:Windows 10 in-place upgrades are a severe security risk by mentat2737 on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @03:01AM (#13061584)
Nope, Gnome Software can upgrade systems now.
Re:Windows 10 in-place upgrades are a severe security risk by c3534l on Tuesday November 29, 2016 @12:42AM (#13061106)
If you're going to recommend a Linux for security, I would have assumed it'd be Tails. For maximum greybeard, I'd go with Gentoo. But this is hacker news, I don't think your average user here is just hearing about Linux from this thread.
Re:Windows 10 in-place upgrades are a severe security risk by DiabloD3 on Monday November 28, 2016 @10:58PM (#13060665)
I think you meant Debian.
Re:Windows 10 in-place upgrades are a severe security risk by Aloha on Monday November 28, 2016 @11:25PM (#13060777)
All unix graybeards wear fedoras, you're issued one once your beard is four inches or longer, everyone knows that. ;-)
Re:Windows 10 in-place upgrades are a severe security risk by renownedmedia on Monday November 28, 2016 @10:30PM (#13060548)
Fedora is too young for Greybeards.
Re:Windows 10 in-place upgrades are a severe security risk by leoc on Monday November 28, 2016 @11:11PM (#13060715)
And there's no active VAX port of Fedora anyway.