Re:The web sucks. Browsers need to innovate
by einarvollset on Thursday April 29, 2010 @02:54PM
(#1305555)
Ah yes, the new more powerful standard. Agreed by Google, Microsoft, Apple, Oracle, etc, etc, etc, etc.
Standards are for lowest common denominator and almost by design are never, ever simple enough - see e.g. SOAP vs REST, XML vs JSON (Dave Winer be damned).
Re:The web sucks. Browsers need to innovate
by RyanMcGreal on Thursday April 29, 2010 @03:36PM
(#1305710)
I'm not sure what your point is. REST [1] has beaten SOAP as the de facto API standard, and JSON has beaten XML as the de facto standard for portable data structure.
[1] Notwithstanding: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1304244
Re:The web sucks. Browsers need to innovate
by kree10 on Thursday April 29, 2010 @05:03PM
(#1306041)
I think the point is the "winners" have something in common and this is no accident.
XML and SOAP came out of "let's invent new formats and protocols"-type standardization, while REST and JSON were products of (essentially) one guy looking at a simple, existing, well-known concept (HTTP and js object literals, respectively) and putting a new frame around it.
Re:The web sucks. Browsers need to innovate
by RyanMcGreal on Friday April 30, 2010 @08:13AM
(#1307908)
I understand what you're saying and broadly agree with you; though I'd point out that Roy Fielding, the guy who articulated REST, was one of the principal authors of the HTTP specification.
This seems like the worst possible outcome:
> Why do all browsers have to support the same standards? This only limits their innovation, and limits web developers.
Shouldn't the solution instead be a new, more powerful standard? (Ignoring how pie-in-the-sky this is.) As in, not band-aids like AJAX and Flash, but a from-the-ground-up standard? After all, 99% of iPad apps have the same basic capabilities; there's no reason you couldn't have a standard which replaces HTML which could fully cover those apps. Then, if you have a need for a really specialized service, you can create a dedicated app.