News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:An expert’s view on unusually warm Arctic temperatures by anigbrowl on Saturday November 26, 2016 @10:40PM (#13047557)
The worst case scenario is we see innocent people needlessly die due to the actions of other people

There's a good case to be made that we're in that situation right now. Look at all the migrants fleeing the Syrian civil war (a conflict arguably driven by climate change as crops failed repeatedly in that area). The flow of said migrants has already resulted in a good deal of avoidable death and political conflict, and that's set to rise with the President of Turkey threatening to use flows of desperate people as a political weapon.

I don't have a problem with the science, but the doomsday or "Mad Max" alarmist scenarios are not based in science

A nuclear exchange would put us in Mad Max territory pretty quickly if you ask me. It's one of a number of unlikely but far from impossible scenarios that we should consider.

Re:An expert’s view on unusually warm Arctic temperatures by Udik on Sunday November 27, 2016 @03:55AM (#13048380)
Oh yes. The Syrian conflict is due to climate change.

NOT to the political instability in the area caused by USA military interventions, that caused the societal destruction of Iraq and Libya and the rise of ISIS;

NOT to the fact that the CIA armed and trained rebels to topple the local government;

NOT to the American obsession that "Assad must go";

NOT to the fact that Israel favours weak neighbours, in order to have an upper hand in regional economics and conflicts (see for example Golan Heights);

NOT to the fact that Saudi Arabia and Turkey would like to replace the Shiite government with a Sunni one and win a proxy war against Iran.

No, it's becauz climate change. A strange one that follows borders very closely, since Israel seems to be doing absolutely fine.

Re:An expert’s view on unusually warm Arctic temperatures by Smaug123 on Sunday November 27, 2016 @05:26AM (#13048573)
The closest anyone above came to saying the Syrian conflict was due to climate change was "a conflict arguably driven by climate change as crops failed repeatedly in that area". Note the word "arguably" and the words "driven by" rather than "caused by"; the poster acknowledges that it is at most a contributing factor.
Re:An expert’s view on unusually warm Arctic temperatures by Udik on Sunday November 27, 2016 @10:44AM (#13049690)
So I'll say that that comment was arguably driven by dangerous ignorance, are you fine with that? In fact, it has to be true, since I just argued it.
Re:An expert’s view on unusually warm Arctic temperatures by DanBC on Sunday November 27, 2016 @11:03AM (#13049797)
Most people agree that climate change has made the situation in Syria worse, but don't claim that climate change is the cause.

http://www.irinnews.org/news/2010/03/25/why-water-shortages

> Poor planning and management, wasteful irrigation systems, intensive wheat and cotton farming and a rapidly growing population are straining water resources in Syria in a year which has seen unprecedented internal displacement as a result of drought in eastern and northeastern parts of the country.

> “Population [estimated at 24 million in 2009] growth, urbanization and increased economic activity have contributed to the water crisis, as have climate change and mismanagement of the water sector,” said a local expert, who preferred anonymity.

http://www.irinnews.org/feature/2009/09/02/drought-driving-f...

> Blamed on a combination of climate change, man-made desertification and lack of irrigation, up to 60 percent of Syria's land and 1.3 million people (of a population of 22 million) are affected, according to the UN. Just over 800,000 people have lost their entire livelihood, according to the UN and IFRC.

[...]

> Aid agencies say a sustainable long-term plan for the affected areas is needed. "We need to do studies to identify a disaster risk reduction strategy on how to overcome climate change and have better farming practices," said Awad.

http://www.irinnews.org/analysis/2015/10/20

> Most studies currently describe climate change as a “threat multiplier” rather than a direct cause, just one of a host of interconnected factors – like poverty, exclusion of ethnic groups, government mismanagement, political instability and societal breakdown – that drive conflict.

Re:An expert’s view on unusually warm Arctic temperatures by Udik on Sunday November 27, 2016 @12:42PM (#13050296)
It is incredibly easy to throw in "climate change" at the end of any list of factors to explain this or that event. Indeed, who is ever going to dispute it? Climate change is, by its very nature, everywhere- so everywhere it can be used as an explanation of something.

The links you provide follow this rule, listing many good reasons for the Syrian water scarcity (and not for the Syrian conflict)- such as dramatic population increase (83% increase in 23 years), land and water resources mismanagement, bad economic measures, wasteful agricultural practices- and throwing in climate change in the end, just to be safe.

Anyway, this is a 2015 article by Mike Hulme debunking the link between climate change and Syrian war: https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2015/nov/29/climat...

In general, one could question how much sense does it make to even cite a far and dubious cause like climate change when more obvious causes are perfectly evident. My favourite example was a WHO report which calculated the future global health impact of climate change as an additional 250000 deaths per year. A huge number. And the method to get it was the following: given the current total number of deaths due to diarrohea, malaria and undernutrition (about 7 million deaths yearly- all of which in developing countries, therefore due to poverty and perfectly preventable), multiplying them by 3.5% (the projected impact of climate change on these issues) and voila... an excellent case for spending some 44 trillion dollars to switch from fossil fuels to clean energy. Or not?

Re:An expert’s view on unusually warm Arctic temperatures by wallace_f on Sunday November 27, 2016 @06:07PM (#13052177)
You're arguing with people who have a religious view towards climate change. That poster, Smaug123, just came close to justifying the use of nuclear weapons in the other thread to the grandparent comment, don't take them seriously.
Re:An expert’s view on unusually warm Arctic temperatures by anigbrowl on Sunday November 27, 2016 @06:53PM (#13052394)
No he didn't. If you think that then you have serious reading comprehension problems.
Re:An expert’s view on unusually warm Arctic temperatures by wallace_f on Sunday November 27, 2016 @07:48PM (#13052641)
Nice ad hominen attack, good on ya' for that

I'm not discussing this with you further.

You've shown yourself to be insulting. You've shown yourself to argue for a case that the Syrian war is caused by climate change. You read a post where someone took an inflammatory meme out of context, and tries to make sense out of a situation where climate change could lead to nuclear war:

> "Guns don't kill people! People kill people!"

> Having climate change around sure makes it easier for people to work themselves into positions where they have to use the nukes.

And you defended it by insulting my intelligence. I am really not impressed.

Re:An expert’s view on unusually warm Arctic temperatures by anigbrowl on Sunday November 27, 2016 @06:52PM (#13052381)
I don't think my comment was ignorant at all. It might be that I just have a longer memory than you. In reality the US government gave a guarded but cautious welcome to Bashar Assad when he succeeded his father and carried himself like a reformist for a few years. But when poor harvests - among other factors - led to protests against the Syrian government, said government responded in a very repressive fashion, which in turn stirred up more opposition.

Clearly you think many other factors are more important, but if you think I'm 'dangerously ignorant' for considering food security as a factor then I'm not going to take your input very seriously.

Re:An expert’s view on unusually warm Arctic temperatures by Udik on Monday November 28, 2016 @02:30AM (#13053978)
Well, the US government was in excellent terms with Saddam Hussein, when he waged against Iran a war that killed between half a million and a million people.

Then invaded the country and had Saddam captured and killed on a false pretense, causing other 40 thousand deaths and plunging the country into civil war.

In Chile backed the coup of a bloodthirsty dictator that had thousands of opponents killed and tens of thousands tortured.

Is backing right now Saudi Arabia, one of the states with the worst human rights record on Earth, in the military repression of the Houtis rebellion in Yemen.

As for Syria, according to Wikipedia:

"The Assad government opposed the United States' invasion and occupation of Iraq. The Bush administration then began to destabilize the regime by increasing sectarian tensions, showcasing and publicising Syrian repression of Kurdish and Sunni groups, and financing political dissidents." And "the main Syrian opposition body – the Syrian coalition – receives political, logistic and military support from the United States, Britain and France. Some Syrian rebels get training from the CIA at bases in Qatar, Jordan and Saudi Arabia. Under the aegis of operation Timber Sycamore and other clandestine activities, CIA operatives and U.S. special operations troops have trained and armed nearly 10,000 rebel fighters at a cost of $1 billion a year since 2012."

Thus promoting and fuelling a civil war that has costed so far between 300 and 400 thousand deaths.

So climate change, yeah.

Re:An expert’s view on unusually warm Arctic temperatures by wallace_f on Saturday November 26, 2016 @10:52PM (#13047598)
>A nuclear exchange would put us in Mad Max territory pretty quickly if you ask me. It's one of a number of unlikely but far from impossible scenarios that we should consider.

Climate change does not and can not create nuclear war. People create nuclear war.

Re:An expert’s view on unusually warm Arctic temperatures by Smaug123 on Sunday November 27, 2016 @05:24AM (#13048568)
"Guns don't kill people! People kill people!"

Having climate change around sure makes it easier for people to work themselves into positions where they have to use the nukes.

Re:An expert’s view on unusually warm Arctic temperatures by wallace_f on Sunday November 27, 2016 @06:05PM (#13052158)
Dear god please tell me this is a joke.
Re:An expert’s view on unusually warm Arctic temperatures by anigbrowl on Sunday November 27, 2016 @06:42PM (#13052332)
I don't see why. You are ignoring the fact that many people simply don't share your value calculus, and that that group might include people who have control over nuclear weapons.

It's a mistake to assume everyone else has the same priorities and basic values that you do; their actions might seem illogical to you but actually be logical courses of actions if you knew what their starting premises were.

Re:An expert’s view on unusually warm Arctic temperatures by wallace_f on Monday November 28, 2016 @01:49AM (#13053860)
Oh give me a break. You are the very person going around insulting other's intelligence in this topic, telling people that disagree with you that you 'have a better memory than them,' or they 'have bad reading comprehension.'

Go ahead, keep justifying nuclear weapons on the basis of your presuppositions, whatever they are. The truth is given your reputation here, I'm not keen to give you the time of day to let my imagination run wild about what you are supposing if nuclear war is your answer.

I really don't appreciate these posts of yours.