News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Reddit’s CEO edited comments that criticized him by yladiz on Thursday November 24, 2016 @04:39AM (#13029323)
Without being in the loop of the pizzagate drama, it's really hard to see this as "okay" (the actions that Spez took). I can understand frustration and wanting to edit comments as payback to people that have wronged you, but this is a pretty dangerous action by an administrator. If he wanted to close the thread(s) or disallow posting on the_donald, sure, it's a visible action and I could understand that. I could even understand removing comments he finds offensive (even if it's not right, I can understand it and it's a visible action). But surreptitiously editing a comment is not okay, because while this is a relatively minor use of that power it's not unthinkable that other admins with that power might use it for less minor things.
Re:Reddit’s CEO edited comments that criticized him by Mithaldu on Thursday November 24, 2016 @06:38AM (#13029801)
Here's the problem: thedonald is a subreddit full of both real trump supporters, AND trolls who're acting surreptitiously to rile up the real supporters and piss off everyone else; which is also spilling over and affecting other parts of reddit, including /all.

The problem for the reddit admins is how to control and contain it and punish the trolls without affecting real people, or being overly censurous.

So for someone who's basically being sniped at by hundreds of guerilla warriors who can make thousands of other people dance as their puppets, it's not surprising they'd reach for a similar tool in frustration when attacked directly, wrongly and frivolously.

Re:Reddit’s CEO edited comments that criticized him by tdkl on Thursday November 24, 2016 @07:18AM (#13029936)
They shouldn't though, if they want to be credible and the site they own/market. Now this is lost.
Re:Reddit’s CEO edited comments that criticized him by slowmotiony on Thursday November 24, 2016 @08:23AM (#13030193)
Was reddit ever really credible?
Re:Reddit’s CEO edited comments that criticized him by tdkl on Thursday November 24, 2016 @09:37AM (#13030498)
They made sure in the media they are.
Re:Reddit’s CEO edited comments that criticized him by Mithaldu on Thursday November 24, 2016 @07:49AM (#13030039)
imo he's gained credibility
Re:Reddit’s CEO edited comments that criticized him by admax88q on Thursday November 24, 2016 @08:58AM (#13030325)
"I don't care what he did so long as it was against those I disagree with."
Re:Reddit’s CEO edited comments that criticized him by Mithaldu on Thursday November 24, 2016 @09:14AM (#13030386)
You're thinking too shallow. :)

It took people harrassing him personally, and at scale, for him to snap. And even then he did not ban anyone, but did what amounts to a prank. And even then he did not hide it, but owned it and apologized.

At every turn of this he showed himself to be a greater man than most of us.

Re:Reddit’s CEO edited comments that criticized him by admax88q on Thursday November 24, 2016 @10:30AM (#13030788)
Banning them would have been better.

Silently editing their comments shows that reddit has very poor data management practices. It shouldn't be possible for the CEO to edit content like that.

Re:Reddit’s CEO edited comments that criticized him by Mithaldu on Thursday November 24, 2016 @10:38AM (#13030830)
There's no forum where the people running it don't have trivially easy access to do what he did. The point is that he has clearly shown what kind of thing it takes to push him that far, and it's clearly not done trivially.

E: I'm trying to say, your perspective is off. Reddit is an internet humor place. Just because it's big enough to have a CEO doesn't mean it's suddenly run with all the seriousness and as tight as a bank.

Re:Reddit’s CEO edited comments that criticized him by samstave on Thursday November 24, 2016 @02:03PM (#13032115)
Thats a fair comment, but my point about calling this a prank being absolute BS still stands...
[dead]
Re:Reddit’s CEO edited comments that criticized him by samstave on Thursday November 24, 2016 @03:07PM (#13032458)
I dont mind that you reply to multi-with-one....

Sure, I am agitated - but given that if anyone who has ever worked for me on any system who had root access to a publicly used (by many millions of people) changed content from the ACTUAL USERBASE based on their ego being hurt, they would be fired on the spot. A statement would be made saying that we are assessing our data-access policies and auditing who has access to what.

You state I am "over reacting" but are you not aware that the entire premise of credibility in data driven companies is based on access to data? Have you ever been through ANY audits ever?

I am going to make a simple foundational audit question to you:

"Who has access to the financial information of the company"

"Well, our VP of IT, the CFO, the CEO are the only three"

So... this CEO of reddit has been known to abuse his power in his own companies product to edit the contents of that product (userbase comments with interests in various topics which is a sellable marketing package)....

So... whos to say if he reacts like this that he wont edit the financials/user-base counts/whatever he has access to if he isnt happy with the data?????

THIS IS A FUNDAMENTAL trust issue with him... to blow it off as a prank is abhorrent.

Does this not make sense?

Re:Reddit’s CEO edited comments that criticized him by Mithaldu on Thursday November 24, 2016 @03:25PM (#13032555)
reddit is not a bank, it is an internet humor forum where sometimes people also talk about the real world

he edited posts that said "fuck you" to him

you're overreacting

you can take this if you like, or disagree, i don't care to discuss it further

this is one of the least significant possible hills to make a stand and die on :v

Re:Reddit’s CEO edited comments that criticized him by dgreensp on Friday November 25, 2016 @08:07AM (#13036436)
While I expect this issue to blow over, you are right that defending the CEO's actions by saying he was "frustrated" or it was a prank or whatever else is ridiculous. Imagine the CEO of Google editing YouTube comments.

I don't know if these analogies are totally apt or not, though; it sounds like the CEO here is also a moderator of a forum and may have edit privileges by virtue of that; it's not like he's executing SQL queries to rewrite the comments in place, I assume, he's just abusing "editorial" powers in pretty much the worst way possible (quietly changing content to say the opposite).

Re:Reddit’s CEO edited comments that criticized him by admax88q on Saturday November 26, 2016 @10:51AM (#13044160)
> I assume, he's just abusing "editorial" powers in pretty much the worst way possible

The platform shouldn't provide editorial powers that allow you to edit others comments. Removal of comments and banning of users is sufficient. There's no legitimate need to have that functionality built it.

Re:Reddit’s CEO edited comments that criticized him by philh on Friday November 25, 2016 @08:33AM (#13036598)
> You're highly agitated and not thinking clearly it seems. Try and do whatever helps you calm down normally.

This was unnecessary and condescending, and there's no call for it.

Re:Reddit’s CEO edited comments that criticized him by Mithaldu on Friday November 25, 2016 @04:11PM (#13039858)
It was a simple fact and he admitted himself it was. Though, if you know of a more graceful way to communicate this, please let me know.
Re:Reddit’s CEO edited comments that criticized him by samstave on Thursday November 24, 2016 @02:02PM (#13032111)
>but did what amounts to a prank.

This is the stupidest comment I have read.

"Don't worry bro, I only shot you as a prank!"

"Don't worry bro, I only slept with your wife as a prank!"

This isa CEO of an incredibly far reaching site who was personally EDITING the posts of users on his site because his ego was hurt.

This is ridiculous!!!

Re:Reddit’s CEO edited comments that criticized him by SwellJoe on Thursday November 24, 2016 @02:42PM (#13032309)
"Don't worry bro, I only shot you as a prank!"

Have you ever heard of "false equivalence"?

Re:Reddit’s CEO edited comments that criticized him by samstave on Thursday November 24, 2016 @02:52PM (#13032368)
"I just committed a mass edit on posts on one of the largest public forums on the internet with 100's of millions of users who want to share their perspective and opinions - where that site I did these edits on is where I am CEO -- and I was upset, within the context of how my ego was hurt -- but it was just a prank"

"IT WAS A PRANK BRO"

You need to take some time to evaluate you're understanding of "false" equivalence.

/u/spez is falsely equating his actions with a "prank"

Re:Reddit’s CEO edited comments that criticized him by omilu on Thursday November 24, 2016 @11:32PM (#13034424)
>> And even then he did not hide it, but owned it and apologized.

Only after he got.

Re:Reddit’s CEO edited comments that criticized him by tdkl on Thursday November 24, 2016 @09:39AM (#13030509)
Lets hope Zuckerberg doesn't snap then, but I'm sure "dumb fucks"* will find an apology for that too.

*his words, not mine

Re:Reddit’s CEO edited comments that criticized him by Mithaldu on Thursday November 24, 2016 @09:57AM (#13030606)
As long as he follows up in the same mature manner, it'll be unfortunate, but forgivable. :)

Also, calling someone a dumbfuck and pretending you didn't just do that because it's "just a quote" is not the greatest a look a person can aim for. ;)

Re:Reddit’s CEO edited comments that criticized him by admax88q on Thursday November 24, 2016 @10:33AM (#13030803)
I'm not even sure who he's quoting as calling "dumb fucks"
Re:Reddit’s CEO edited comments that criticized him by nostrademons on Thursday November 24, 2016 @04:32PM (#13032906)
Mark Zuckerburg, referring to Facebook users.

http://www.businessinsider.com/embarrassing-and-damaging-zuc...

Re:Reddit’s CEO edited comments that criticized him by admax88q on Thursday November 24, 2016 @10:33AM (#13030807)
> *his words, not mine

Who's words?

Re:Reddit’s CEO edited comments that criticized him by burning_stubble on Thursday November 24, 2016 @01:20PM (#13031828)
Re:Reddit’s CEO edited comments that criticized him by siidooloo on Thursday November 24, 2016 @10:16AM (#13030700)
The people he did this to were jabbing him in the eye with a sharp stick because reddit took action against them for falsley accusing people of being pedophiles.

His action was wrong. But it was provoked.

Re:Reddit’s CEO edited comments that criticized him by admax88q on Thursday November 24, 2016 @10:32AM (#13030794)
That was my point with comments like "imo he's gained credibility"

There are other comments celebrating what he did because it was again /r/the_donald "trolls."

Lot's of people don't care what actions you take so long as its against a group/individual that they don't like. That is short sighted thinking IMO.

Re:Reddit’s CEO edited comments that criticized him by SwellJoe on Thursday November 24, 2016 @02:51PM (#13032364)
I think the distinction is behavior, not "people they don't like". Witch hunts are against the guidelines of reddit; that's not a secret. Whether you support Trump or not isn't relevant, if you're on a witch hunt. Likewise, posting personal information has, from almost the very beginning of reddit, been the one cardinal sin. The sin that'll get you banned or a subreddit closed down.

That's what spez was responding to. He did it in a terribly immature way that I could never condone (unless it were really funny, like this, in which case, I think it's hilarious). But, it was not a random "I don't like this group" situation, and to frame it that way is to manipulate the narrative. The behavior in question was a witch hunt, and against reddit rules; the witch hunt started because a subreddit was banned for posting (tons of!) personal information and launching a witch hunt against a random restaurant and bar and its owners. Again, that's clearly against reddit rules. Those rules are reasonable, and if someone doesn't like them, they should take their shit elsewhere.

It's not about not liking The_Donald. Nobody likes The_Donald, but reddit has always been more than fair in dealing with all of their bullshit; the vote brigades (against reddit rules), the orchestrated abuse of other subs and moderators and users, etc. Large swaths of them probably should have been banned months ago. But, Steve has always been slow to ban. Probably to a fault. When you fail to ban folks like this you breed a community of people like this, who feel entitled to be abusive without response.

Re:Reddit’s CEO edited comments that criticized him by samstave on Thursday November 24, 2016 @01:59PM (#13032101)
You're describing a seemingly natural human reaction. However - the CEO shouldn't be reacting like this - he needs a PR team to spin it however he wants to spin it - but he shouldnt single-handedly, with one action, literally destroy any semblance of credibility the 8th largest site in the US even has.

FB was allowing employees to simply READ any comments/posts/PMs between users and recall what a shitstorm that was... but now imagine if Zuck was personally freaking editing posts about him? (or if he had a team of ppl doing it for him and then admitting to it/bragging about it on corp comms???)

/u/spez may have truly done a really big hit to reddits future.

Can we get @DANG's opinion?

Re:Reddit’s CEO edited comments that criticized him by mcphage on Thursday November 24, 2016 @04:04PM (#13032747)
> /u/spez may have truly done a really big hit to reddits future.

Oh man, if Reddit takes a stand and says "we're not going to treat trolls and non-trolls the same anymore", I would feel a ton better about spending time there.

Re:Reddit’s CEO edited comments that criticized him by meowface on Thursday November 24, 2016 @04:53PM (#13033015)
How does one define a troll vs. a non-troll?

You also have to consider that, as incredibly ridiculous and batshit crazy as it is, a high percentage of the /r/pizzagate people 100% believe it's true and that they're uncovering a massive criminal ring.

Re:Reddit’s CEO edited comments that criticized him by sangnoir on Thursday November 24, 2016 @07:51AM (#13030047)
> Here's the problem: thedonald is a subreddit full of both real trump supporters, AND trolls who're acting surreptitiously to rile up the real supporters and piss off everyone else

Shouldn't the mods clean up after the trolls who don't abide by the subreddit rules? If a post stays up for days, it is safe to assume the mods condone it whether it was posted by a 'troll' or a 'real person' - this goes for any subreddit.

Re:Reddit’s CEO edited comments that criticized him by Mithaldu on Thursday November 24, 2016 @07:59AM (#13030075)
There's a site that gives you a thing you can use to show deleted posts in reddit threads, called uneddit.com

Try it on thedonald.

Re:Reddit’s CEO edited comments that criticized him by sangnoir on Thursday November 24, 2016 @04:10PM (#13032785)
I don't quite follow the argument that you are making - are you saying they mods are overwhelmed? The whole point of having mod(erator)s is to moderate - subreddits are their own communities with the mods in charge. They are responsible for setting the ground rules and enforcing them, if you have a different understanding of how Reddit works, please let me know.
Re:Reddit’s CEO edited comments that criticized him by Mithaldu on Thursday November 24, 2016 @04:54PM (#13033017)
I'm saying that i personally don't think the mods there give a single damn about cleaning anything.
Re:Reddit’s CEO edited comments that criticized him by siidooloo on Thursday November 24, 2016 @10:13AM (#13030687)
If you try to clean up after the trolls they'll just shitpost at you even more. Short of nuking the entire subreddit there's nothing to do.
Re:Reddit’s CEO edited comments that criticized him by sangnoir on Thursday November 24, 2016 @04:05PM (#13032756)
so what is the point of having moderators?
Re:Reddit’s CEO edited comments that criticized him by samstave on Thursday November 24, 2016 @01:53PM (#13032069)
Regardless of anything - the CEO of reddit's personal reddit user-account SHOULD NOT have the ability (assuming he is using his reddit login creds (surely hes got 2FA etc..)) to modify comments like this....

Every black-hat should be trying to get access to /u/spez's account to see if they can pwn reddit as a whole. But I am hopeful that reddit has that account compartmentalization and security under control.

Re:Reddit’s CEO edited comments that criticized him by SwellJoe on Thursday November 24, 2016 @02:55PM (#13032385)
How would you propose that a root level administrator of a server, for a site running code he original wrote, be prevented from modifying the content of that site?
Re:Reddit’s CEO edited comments that criticized him by samstave on Thursday November 24, 2016 @03:18PM (#13032506)
That wasn't quite what I meant:

1. the actual reddit account /u/spez would presumably be just like any other account (meaning no god-mode, where he can edit shit) - that should be compartmentalized to system level accounts for cassandra, mysql etc... such that /u/spez cannot (via the web-account login) access an option to modify content thusly. The reason for this is to assume that /u/spez's account is prolly being attacked by brute force continuously.

2. we should assume that their DB practices, hosted on AWS, have both logging and alerts such that there should be a log of any DB statements submitted are logged.

3. that logged events stat who did what when

4. It's actually far more common to not have a CEO's account having root access to everything -- this is why you create a company. We are far more advanced than that. While Zuck may have "authority" to access any single system that FB has, I doubt he knows every single password - and that he would rely on his officers and teams to access/modify anything (given their current maturity level asa company)

I'd bet my life that if you put a gun to Tim Cook's head - he would not be able to login and gain access and them modify your icloud account.

Re:Reddit’s CEO edited comments that criticized him by SwellJoe on Thursday November 24, 2016 @03:31PM (#13032582)
1 - I don't think he used his /u/spez account on reddit to make this change. I think he hit the lower level parts of the system. I can't imagine he wanted to spend hours manually editing things.

2 - How do we know it wasn't logged? I assume it was.

3 - Same as above. I assume it would have been traceable had that been necessary. But, Steve posted about it. No need for spelunking in the logs.

4 - Tim Cook didn't/couldn't build iCloud from the ground up. Zuck hasn't been a primary coder on facebook in years, and nearly always had a lot of help. Steve built almost all of reddit in the beginning, and even now, seems to still be involved in the code.