News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Judge blocks Obama overtime rule, putting it in jeopardy by Gustomaximus on Wednesday November 23, 2016 @11:55PM (#13028226)
I can understand it for higher earners. You are well compensated, typically better conditions and have employment options should the enviroment become toxic.

For lower pays absolutely. If an employers agrees to X contracted hours/rate and then demands X+ hours because they know you cant say no, this is essentially theft. And to not pass this as rule essentially mandates it as OK. I hope this gets sorted. I suspect this judge and any future politicians/judges involved will come under a heap of scrutiny/pressure over this. It is simply too clearly unjust not to pass it. It would follow a person for the rest of their career and they would know it.

Re:Judge blocks Obama overtime rule, putting it in jeopardy by meddlepal on Thursday November 24, 2016 @12:17AM (#13028326)
It's a federal judge. There isn't much career progression beyond that because they're appointed for life.

So, no, it won't follow them. This is also why we have lifetime appointments so judge's make legally correct rulings rather than politically appealing ones.

Re:Judge blocks Obama overtime rule, putting it in jeopardy by Gustomaximus on Thursday November 24, 2016 @07:39AM (#13029991)
> There isn't much career progression beyond that because they're appointed for life.

Progression: Supreme court judge. Chief justice. Maybe not many steps but huge ones. Also it would follow them as for both their remaining tenure and legacy, something they would be distinctly aware of and care about.

> This is also why we have lifetime appointments so judge's make legally correct rulings rather than politically appealing one

That's the theory but there is a reason each side wants to be in power during a supreme court position change. It is because political views shift their interpretation of the law.

Re:Judge blocks Obama overtime rule, putting it in jeopardy by hyperliner on Thursday November 24, 2016 @01:29AM (#13028618)
It is not the role of the judiciary to define what is just of unjust: they just need to make a ruling based on the law. There is really no difference if someone is paid $20k or $90k: you always must discount that rate if you are not an hourly employee. It is not theft: it is at-will employment and nobody is being forced to take it.

Also, the ruling is only being postponed:

--- “Due to the approaching effective date of the Final Rule, the Court’s ability to render a meaningful decision on the merits is in jeopardy,” he wrote. “A preliminary injunction preserves the status quo while the Court determines the department’s authority to make the Final Rule as well as the Final Rule’s validity. ---

If the law was clear, then there would be no difference between whether the decision is done during the current or future administration. It seems that there is enough ambiguity that the course of action varies depending on who is in power, which appears to indicate to me that the overtime rule by Obama's administrations was on weak grounds regardless.

Re:Judge blocks Obama overtime rule, putting it in jeopardy by coldtea on Thursday November 24, 2016 @03:00AM (#13028947)
>It is not theft: it is at-will employment and nobody is being forced to take it.

That's a strange view of how the world works. But of course if one has never been forced to take a shitty job because they just have no options, one can hold such a view more easily.

Re:Judge blocks Obama overtime rule, putting it in jeopardy by vinceguidry on Thursday November 24, 2016 @12:10PM (#13031343)
I've had plenty of shitty jobs in my day, it was always a choice for me to take them and I was always glad to have them. I used to pull twelve hour shifts on a production line. Did that job for three weeks to save up to move across the country.

You always have options. You can always make a plan. If the plan fails, you learn from it and make a better one. But I tell you what, I'd rather have a shit job as an option rather than no job as an option.

Re:Judge blocks Obama overtime rule, putting it in jeopardy by coldtea on Saturday November 26, 2016 @01:33AM (#13042096)
>But I tell you what, I'd rather have a shit job as an option rather than no job as an option.

That's always the case with any kind of blackmail.

Re:Judge blocks Obama overtime rule, putting it in jeopardy by arkem on Thursday November 24, 2016 @11:33AM (#13031151)
I don't think it's very charitable to imply that the parent only holds their opinion due to their assumed economic status.
Re:Judge blocks Obama overtime rule, putting it in jeopardy by llukas on Thursday November 24, 2016 @02:38AM (#13028876)
"it is at-will employment and nobody is being forced to take it."

Or you're free to starve, right?

Re:Judge blocks Obama overtime rule, putting it in jeopardy by matt_wulfeck on Thursday November 24, 2016 @11:46AM (#13031229)
Yes you are free to starve if you choose so and keeping everyone fed is not the prerogative of a small business. That reality may sound harsh and unfair to you but it doesn't make it untrue.

Either way my experience with crappy jobs suggest that it's hard to work more hours because of overtime pay rules. You have to simply work two jobs, which is what many people at places like McDonalds do to make ends meet. All of these rules have unintended side effects.

Re:Judge blocks Obama overtime rule, putting it in jeopardy by wwweston on Thursday November 24, 2016 @12:34PM (#13031511)
> Yes you are free to starve if you choose so and keeping everyone fed is not the prerogative of a small business.

"Keeping everyone fed" is an... interesting transmutation of the point you're responding to, which is more or less about whether businesses have any ethical obligations towards whatever employees they have (not "everyone") regardless of what market conditions will bear, and certainly stops well short of the idea that small businesses must generally solve hunger.

If the job market is poor enough for a given employee that they don't have any other prospects, should that give an employer license to demand more of their time at the same pay rate? Or perhaps any smaller pay rate? Demand they do things which are health hazards? Coerce into doing illegal things? Demand sexual favors?

> Either way my experience with crappy jobs suggest that it's hard to work more hours because of overtime pay rules. You have to simply work two jobs, which is what many people at places like McDonalds do to make ends meet.

I don't think labor operations of a McDonald's have much to do with overtime, since the situation you're describing generally means the workers in question have trouble getting to full time. But yes, it probably does have something to do with employers trying to avoid bearing the cost of full-time employees, along with trying to optimize labor supply to indicated demand by buying smaller slices of worker time and pushing the cost of coordinating that worker's time on to the worker.

> All of these rules have unintended side effects.

Sure, and debating which ones are worthwhile and effective which ones aren't is great. As it turns out, not having many of these rules also has unintended side effects, which we've had a chance to see in action in the past.

Re:Judge blocks Obama overtime rule, putting it in jeopardy by thinkmassive on Thursday November 24, 2016 @12:10AM (#13028295)
> I can understand it for higher earners

What's the cutoff that determines when someone is classified as a higher earner?

Re:Judge blocks Obama overtime rule, putting it in jeopardy by abduhl on Thursday November 24, 2016 @12:17AM (#13028323)
4. The employee’s hourly rate of pay, or annual salary if paid on salaried basis, meets a minimum threshold amount set by California’s Division of Labor Statistics and Research (DLSR). For 2015, the DLSR set the amounts at $41.27 per hour or annual salary of not less than $85,981.40 for full time employment, and paid not less than $7,165.12 per month.
Re:Judge blocks Obama overtime rule, putting it in jeopardy by cowl on Thursday November 24, 2016 @02:49AM (#13028909)
There should be no cutoff. it's either paid for all (as it should be) or for none. How can you say that some people have less rights because they earn more?
Re:Judge blocks Obama overtime rule, putting it in jeopardy by edblarney on Thursday November 24, 2016 @04:24AM (#13029247)
"How can you say that some people have less rights because they earn more?"

It's not that they have 'less rights' - it's that the expectations of the job are different. You're a CEO, you're going to have to 'work a ton of hours' for your massive paycheque, it just goes with the job. You don't want it - stay VP or Director, or manager.

CEO's, doctors etc. are not commodities.

For hourly unskilled workers, 'labour' etc - there always have to be protections. Without them - we head back to 19th century oppression.

I understand that's it's nuanced, and I agree that 'some salary' is a really, really crude way to define it ... but something needs to be there, or else you get 1/3 of Americans working 80 hours a week for de-facto $4/hour.

Make no mistake - the 'free market wage' for 1/3 of Americans who's skills are commoditized, but who nevertheless to 'valuable work' is basically 1% above 'survival'. Well below poverty. You could argue the 'free market' decides how much value they actually provide, but I would argue that the rate is entirely a function of relative power disparity between the two parties (employee v. big corp) and nothing more. It's why 'minimum wage' laws exist in most places. 'Free markets' work when actors have agency, and some power ... when actors don't have some degree of power-parity, 99% of the surpluses go into the hands of one side of the equation.

Re:Judge blocks Obama overtime rule, putting it in jeopardy by schrodinger on Thursday November 24, 2016 @09:12AM (#13030379)
I think another consideration is higher earning jobs typically have more of a gray area around what constitutes work. E.g. It's clear that a cashier isn't working anymore when they clock out. But as a developer, I certainly have times when I come up with an idea at home and start working on it, an idea in the shower, etc.
Re:Judge blocks Obama overtime rule, putting it in jeopardy by coldtea on Thursday November 24, 2016 @02:56AM (#13028938)
>How can you say that some people have less rights because they earn more?

The same way we say that people must have less stuff, including health care, college for their kids, etc., because they earn less.

Re:Judge blocks Obama overtime rule, putting it in jeopardy by oddlyaromatic on Thursday November 24, 2016 @07:55AM (#13030061)
You got a good long answer, but more simply: An expected level of occasional 40+ hour weeks is often baked into to the salary at a higher level. When I switched to a salaried manager position, my new rate of pay was better than my old hourly, including the overtime I used to work. Now I know the check that will come every two weeks is the same, if I can do my work in under 40 hours nobody cares. It is much better for me to focus on my job and not worry about the exact number of hours I work.
Re:Judge blocks Obama overtime rule, putting it in jeopardy by hga on Thursday November 24, 2016 @08:03AM (#13030087)
And having been exempt salaried but working in D.C. for a dozen years where so much is done by government accounting rules, it's a total pain in the posterior to make sure your Official worked hours add up to exactly 40. One of the few nice things about working for Lucent in its dreadful calendar year 2001 was that I could just focus on getting the job done

The only time I ever liked doing that was when it was a tool to keep a company owner from cheating the salesmen by charging them too much for the labor we put into building the systems we'd together, almost always, sold to someone (and that company eventually died, you can't keep cheating all your salaried employees and expect to survive, we all walked away with 4-5 figures of bonuses or commissions formally owed to us).

Re:Judge blocks Obama overtime rule, putting it in jeopardy by dennisgorelik on Thursday November 24, 2016 @04:46PM (#13032983)
Higher earners are smart enough to figure out that rules that penalize employers for overtime - effectively hurt workers. So higher earners protect their rights to have job and overtime by blocking that overtime rule at their level.

Lower earners (collectively) are not able to figure out the unintended consequences and happily support that populist rule.

Re:Judge blocks Obama overtime rule, putting it in jeopardy by ianai on Thursday November 24, 2016 @12:07AM (#13028279)
Your first sentence is the justification for paying people less than 40k year and expecting 80 hours of work out of them. It doesn't hold up.