Perhaps you got downvoted because you resorted to the "Do you have" trope to insinuate that the other person is ignorant. This is a variant of "Did you even read the article", a form of incivility we specifically ask people to avoid here: https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html. We also ask people not to use uppercase for emphasis. If you edited those things out of your comment it would be much better.
Receivers have to be on the same page as the qb as to what is getting done and how they'll adjust based on coverage.
Running backs usually don't have to do a lot of thinking, they're more reactive, initial responsibilities and steps set but changes quickly as the play develops.
Thats not to say anything about the above except that FB is in many ways the most "team" of team sports with vastly different body types, roles and responsibilities at play. If you can't make an analogy related to business work within a gridiron (american) football context, you probably can't make it work :)
The comment you're replying to says this specifically.
> Mr. Offensive lineman - I smash whoever is in front of me. If the play is to the left, I smash left.
This is an oversimplification and if this is all the offensive lineman does, he'll be rapidly out of a job. The linemen are constantly adjusting to deal with the defense. They'll hold to avoid a big sack. They'll leap on the ball when there's a fumble. They'll block someone else if needed. It's not smash left and done.
> It would be like a PM coming by every 5 minutes and telling you that you should use a Dictionary to store the current data, and then on the next problem you should maybe look into an ArrayList.
I think it would be a lot more like management saying "we need you to build product X" and then expecting the QB to deliver. The QB isn't just running plays by rote.
That's a very oversimplification of american football. For a basic example even the "dumb" offensive lineman has to play differently whether it's a run or a pass. A more complicated play like a screen will require a lot of coordination with his other teammates to perform correctly. American football is actually a pretty good analogy for a the typical development team and the different roles an offense has. You have people in the trenches, people doing flashy stuff and a field general trying to tie it all together.
His analogy is limited (as all analogies are, at some level), but it works for its intended purpose, IMO.
Like a leaky bucket.
Edit: Some analogies are nearly perfect. Maybe he just needs to find a better one.
Because most american people I know in football, know their EXACT role. Mr. Offensive lineman - I smash whoever is in front of me. If the play is to the left, I smash left. If the play is to the right, I smash right. They know nothing about defense. They know nothing about receiver routes. They don't care. They stand up and smash people.
The QUARTERBACK knows a bunch. But he also has a headset on, with 3 people feeding him tips for each play. It would be like a PM coming by every 5 minutes and telling you that you should use a Dictionary to store the current data, and then on the next problem you should maybe look into an ArrayList.
Basically.. football is a terrible analogy to software development.