Kosovo and Bangladesh were widely recognised as valid seceded nations due to previous oppression; Rhodesia and Biafra were not and suffered fatal international sanctions as a result.
But there was no rule of law behind this, in each they were sponsored or opposed by a powerful nation which had an interest in the outcome. It's who you have as friends that determines whether the seceder or the supranation is 'right'.
It has been tried before, and there's a pretty big precedent for what happens. That precedent is civil war. How is California seceding going to be any different from the southern states?
That's not peaceful. Or at least, not any more peaceful than nuclear deterrent is.
Who did the states that broke away from parent states secede from? Not from the US.
Secession from the US may well require war. If not that, it's going to require following a recognized constitutional process (which I'm pretty sure there isn't one). Barring that, it's at least going to require congressional approval, not vetoed by the President. Good luck getting that.
California passing a referendum? Yeah, that and $6 will get you coffee at Starbucks.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Philippine_Declaration_of_Inde...
> The Philippine Revolutionary Government did not recognize the treaty or American sovereignty, and subsequently fought and lost a conflict with United States originally referred to by the Americans as the "Philippine Insurrection" but now generally and officially called the Philippine–American War, which ended when Emilio Aguinaldo was captured by U.S. forces, and issued a statement acknowledging and accepting the sovereignty of the United States over the Philippines.
So maybe not the example you're looking for.
Why do I need a US example? Because the examples of one state seceding from another happened with the blessing, and even the instigation, of the Federal government. More: The new state remained within the US. That's quite different from a state trying to leave the US (in particular, it's different in how the Federal government would respond).
It's happened elsewhere? Well, it shouldn't be news that the US doesn't really care how it's done elsewhere...
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Treaty_of_Manila_(1946)
The lesson from history is that peaceful secession's work better than violent ones. Do you really think the rest of the world will turn a blind eye to the US holding Cascadia hostage?
"Holding Cascadia hostage"? Overdramitize much? "Denying the legitimacy of the secession process" is probably closer to it.
Because here is what happens when states try to secede in the US: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/American_Civil_War
Not only that, but I have a vague recollection of this being tried before. Exactly what makes secessionists think they can build an army large enough to beat the US military? Oh, ok. They want to vote themselves out of the union. Guess what, it doesn't work that way. And the second the US military comes by to put us all back in our place, the people crowing for secession are going to run with their tails between their legs. Also, how are we going to build a militia with all of our strict gun laws??
If our economy is so much bigger and worth more representation than everyone else's, let's quit whining and start flexing that muscle more...many regulations we enact here have the ability to force companies across the nation to adopt them.
We have the amount of representation we have because of the US constitution. If that's a problem, either change the constitution or find other ways to exert power. Secession is going to be a lot more expensive in the long run.