Makes complete sense to me: cost of living for your desired location is outrageously expensive!
Completely OT but just realized you're that guy[1]. =)
Call me "grew up at a time when getting loans sounded crazy and kinda still does"
> the arguments for buying never made sense to me
Well, there you go. I live in a market that's anomalous in the other direction: there's exactly one four-bedroom house advertised for rent in the city at the moment, and its price is about 20% higher than the mortgage would be.
(Mortgage >> rent implies a really strange market where the landlords must be experiencing negative ROI?)
Landlords in California have a great reason not to sell - prop 13, a tax benefit for people and corporations who bought low.
Some people don't want to fully "mark to market" and are happy as long as the mortgage on their investment gets paid.
My desired location is in an anomalous realestate market. Mortgage for the place I live in would cost me about $6k/month, rent is about $3.5k/month. Even if that wasn't the case, do I really want an illiquid investment that ties me down with a loan for 30 years when there are so many other investments I could make?
Just considering a downpayment of, say, $200k ... for that kinda money I could take 2 or 3 years off work and build a business that makes much more than that. Riskier investment, sure, but also a lot more profitable and more fun. Quicker returns too.
Dunno, the arguments for buying never made sense to me. Unless of course you have high leverage (can buy cash, but choose not to). Then it's a whole different game.