News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A Better Alternative to Small Houses by aidenn0 on Monday November 21, 2016 @03:46AM (#13004030)
What does "you can afford" mean? By definition you can't be bankrupted by nonrecourse debt.

On the other hand, I have a fairly significant fraction of my net worth tied up in my home, and a fair amount of equity at this point, so it would be fairly painful to lose it.

That being said, in hindsight I am almost certainly financially in a better position than had I been renting for the past 5 years (I say "almost" because appraisals aren't worth the paper they are printed on as far as I'm concerned; I don't know a single person in this town who has bought or sold a house within 10% of the appraised value in the past decade).

It seems like poor advice to not consider a home as an investment; investments come with risks, as well as opportunity costs. Particularly for smaller units, I've known places where renting was so much cheaper than buying that it should be considered a luxury to buy, and yet people just buy once they have a down-payment without considering the financial repercussions.

Maybe you really mean one must understand that a home is not a risk-free investment, in which case we are in agreement.

Re:A Better Alternative to Small Houses by metaphor on Monday November 21, 2016 @05:14AM (#13004339)
It sounds like you're somehow equating you can afford with does not lead to bankruptcy.

It's a credit-driven world, and the damage done by defaulting on a mortgage can be quite massive. For a large chunk of the US population, losing your house almost certainly leads to losing your job[1], as seemingly backwards as that sounds.

Without going off on a pedantic tangent, I think the general notion behind treating a home as an investment is an overarching intent to sell for profit in the near future. Play space and risk considerations are very different for turning profit vs. laying down roots.

Consider home = sustainable commitment.

[1] http://edition.cnn.com/2010/BUSINESS/10/29/foreclosures.govt...

Re:A Better Alternative to Small Houses by jholman on Monday November 21, 2016 @06:01AM (#13004500)
You think that 24 individuals per year is "a large chunk of the US population"? That is confusing.
Re:A Better Alternative to Small Houses by metaphor on Monday November 21, 2016 @07:13AM (#13004760)
You've taken that out of context.

Try over 2 million employees between active duty and civilian workforce in the US Department of Defense[1] alone for which the discussion at hand is very much applicable.

The devil is in the details. You'll lose your job not because you defaulted on a mortgage, but because you failed to maintain a valid security clearance, which is predicated on--amongst other factors--an ability to faithfully satisfy debts.

What you read was a mere snippet of one study which reported 24 contractors in 2009 who appealed. What it doesn't touch upon is how many contractors simply accepted without appeal, and completely omits federal employees altogether.

Furthermore, security clearance reinvestigations are a lagging indicator, generally running on 5-15 year cycles depending on clearance level[2]. If defaulting on a mortgage doesn't bite immediately, it inevitably will when reinvestigation rolls around.

[1] http://www.defense.gov/About-DoD

[2] http://www.dss.mil/psmo-i/indus_psmo-i_updates.html

Re:A Better Alternative to Small Houses by jholman on Monday November 21, 2016 @07:24PM (#13010562)
Your points about it being only 24 individuals are fair.

But even 2 million individuals is not "a large chunk of the US population" -- being less than 1% -- and that's assuming that all employees of the US DoD need to maintain a valid security clearance (which I'll just grant you for the sake of argument, although it seems unlikely to me).

Re:A Better Alternative to Small Houses by Swizec on Monday November 21, 2016 @04:50AM (#13004250)
> yet people just buy once they have a down-payment without considering the financial repercussions.

My desired location is in an anomalous realestate market. Mortgage for the place I live in would cost me about $6k/month, rent is about $3.5k/month. Even if that wasn't the case, do I really want an illiquid investment that ties me down with a loan for 30 years when there are so many other investments I could make?

Just considering a downpayment of, say, $200k ... for that kinda money I could take 2 or 3 years off work and build a business that makes much more than that. Riskier investment, sure, but also a lot more profitable and more fun. Quicker returns too.

Dunno, the arguments for buying never made sense to me. Unless of course you have high leverage (can buy cash, but choose not to). Then it's a whole different game.

Re:A Better Alternative to Small Houses by metaphor on Monday November 21, 2016 @05:32AM (#13004416)
> My desired location is in an anomalous realestate market. > Just considering a downpayment of, say, $200k ... > Dunno, the arguments for buying never made sense to me.

Makes complete sense to me: cost of living for your desired location is outrageously expensive!

Re:A Better Alternative to Small Houses by Swizec on Monday November 21, 2016 @05:45AM (#13004460)
Eh cost of living is fine. Cost of buying an apartment, lulz.
Re:A Better Alternative to Small Houses by metaphor on Monday November 21, 2016 @09:08AM (#13005427)
For the sake of analysis, I tend to lump considerations of purchasing a home in with the cost of living, even if I am a bachelor and currently lease...call it posturing to make the traditional American dream a reality, if you will.

Completely OT but just realized you're that guy[1]. =)

[1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OAcOjTks9Ew

Re:A Better Alternative to Small Houses by Swizec on Monday November 21, 2016 @11:55AM (#13006849)
Hehe yep that's me. Buying never really appealed to me for reasons that go beyond the financial bit so I guess it never occurred to me that people consider it part of cost of living.

Call me "grew up at a time when getting loans sounded crazy and kinda still does"

Re:A Better Alternative to Small Houses by pjc50 on Monday November 21, 2016 @07:33AM (#13004858)
> My desired location is in an anomalous realestate market.

> the arguments for buying never made sense to me

Well, there you go. I live in a market that's anomalous in the other direction: there's exactly one four-bedroom house advertised for rent in the city at the moment, and its price is about 20% higher than the mortgage would be.

(Mortgage >> rent implies a really strange market where the landlords must be experiencing negative ROI?)

Re:A Better Alternative to Small Houses by ohwello on Monday November 21, 2016 @11:52AM (#13006816)
The statistic measuring this property is the price-to-rent ratio: https://smartasset.com/mortgage/price-to-rent-ratio-in-us-ci...

Landlords in California have a great reason not to sell - prop 13, a tax benefit for people and corporations who bought low.

Re:A Better Alternative to Small Houses by xyzzy123 on Monday November 21, 2016 @08:02AM (#13005028)
Not necessarily; remember that someone renting a place out might have bought at a much lower price than the house would sell for now.

Some people don't want to fully "mark to market" and are happy as long as the mortgage on their investment gets paid.

Re:A Better Alternative to Small Houses by michaelt on Monday November 21, 2016 @04:27AM (#13004165)

  What does "you can afford" mean?
Presumably that your monthly loan payments (and routine maintenance costs and bills) should be a small enough portion of your income that you can cover your day-to-day living expenses and still have a financial safety net.

You know, so you don't get into financial trouble because there's a gas price rise or your dog needs to go to the vet.