Re:Alien life could be so advanced it becomes indistinguisha...
by mbrock on Sunday November 20, 2016 @06:42AM
(#12998345)
What does your faith hinge on?
Re:Alien life could be so advanced it becomes indistinguisha...
by simonh on Monday November 21, 2016 @05:56AM
(#13004488)
Part of it is the personal appeal of the Christian message of community, service and selflessness. Part of it is a personal feeling of spirituality and connection to people and the universe. Part of it is certainly cultural, if I'd been born in a Muslim country to Muslim parents I don't see any reason why I'd be anything other than Muslim myself, but then I'm ok with that. Same goes for Judaism, or Hinduism. My faith is a completely subjective experience, I don't give it objective weight or feel any need or desire to push it on anyone else. In that sense I'm a secularist.
This process builds up a cumulative pile of evidence supporting the theory. On the other hand you construct a test of the theory that can disprove it. So far no such test has been found to disprove evolution.
It's true that we don't yet understand every single biological mechanism and every single facet of developmental biology and how they relate to natural selection. However that's not sufficient to 'disprove' evolutionary theory. To do that you'd need to actually prove that evolutionary theory could not explain them - not that it's unlikely it could explain them, but that it's impossible. As it happens the number of thing evolution has not explained is getting smaller as we find the connections and demonstrate them.
So on the one hand we have vast troves of experimental and observational results successfully explained by evolution and this trove is increasing rapidly. On the other hand, we have some mechanisms or results where it's not yet completely clear if or how evolution explains them, but this number is decreasing. Finally we have no tests that have disproven evolution. At this point this makes Evolution through natural selection one of the most practically successful and predictive theories science has ever produced, right up there with quantum mechanics.
Has it predicted and explained everything in its domain? No. but few theories have yet done that. Even quantum mechanics still has some odd edge cases that are tricky to figure out.
So the thing about 'proving' scientific theories is that it's morevlike 'proving' a piece of forged metal. You test it to see if it breaks. Science is really about usefulness. It's test show whether a theory is useful in solving some call of problems. Evolution through natural selection has so far passed every test it's been given in which a colclusuon has been reached. That's encouraging evidence that it will pass the others as well.
Meanwhile ID has nothing to show whatsoever. It's an intellectual dead end. Personally, I'm very glad my Christian faith doesn't hinge on it.