News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A $900B Oil Treasure Lies Beneath West Texas Desert by fanzhang on Sunday November 20, 2016 @01:22AM (#12997573)
In a theoretical world, finding potential resources is always good. You have the option to extract from it, or ban extraction from it -- which is no worse than not finding it in the first place.

Put another way, shouldn't news of any new option be good?

It's interesting then that there's such negativity, or at least ambiguity, in this thread. Is it because we've grown more pessimistic at the irresponsibility of society?

Re:A $900B Oil Treasure Lies Beneath West Texas Desert by mzw_mzw on Sunday November 20, 2016 @01:34AM (#12997601)
It's interesting, but it's not surprising. There's a hive-mind on HN when it comes to anything associated with oil. The most ludicrous, unscientific, repeatedly debunked theories about environmental damage from fracking are uncritically believed, conspiracy theories about "oil barons" and Mideast wars are the order of the day, and of course you can't go five minutes without someone happily reminding us all that soon God, er, global warming will punish us sinners.
Re:A $900B Oil Treasure Lies Beneath West Texas Desert by joelthelion on Sunday November 20, 2016 @02:53AM (#12997814)
The world is on the verge of disastrous climate change. This fact is well established. Why exactly are we supposed to rejoice at the news of more fossil fuel reserves?
Re:A $900B Oil Treasure Lies Beneath West Texas Desert by mzw_mzw on Sunday November 20, 2016 @11:52AM (#12999726)
The rejoicing one tends to hear around this place is from the apocalypse mongers, gleefully trading stories about how global warming will kill us all in exactly the same tones as fundamentalist Christians in the 1980s spinning lurid tales about the sinners being tortured in Hell. Seriously, the parallels are uncanny.
Re:A $900B Oil Treasure Lies Beneath West Texas Desert by dublinclontarf on Sunday November 20, 2016 @09:54AM (#12999102)
I was under the impression that we were well past the point of no return regarding climate change.
Re:A $900B Oil Treasure Lies Beneath West Texas Desert by joelthelion on Sunday November 20, 2016 @11:51AM (#12999722)
Are you implying that our actions make no difference? There are vital differences between +2°C and a +8°C global warming.
Re:A $900B Oil Treasure Lies Beneath West Texas Desert by briandear on Sunday November 20, 2016 @04:18AM (#12998040)
We've been on the verge of something since the beginning of time. In the meantime society has to function and society runs on oil.
Re:A $900B Oil Treasure Lies Beneath West Texas Desert by TeMPOraL on Sunday November 20, 2016 @06:08AM (#12998265)
We have viable alternatives to running on oil and there are people actively pushing to switch the society to other energy sources. It can be done, it has to be done if we want our grandchildren to have a livable conditions on this planet.

The thing we need is for people to stop countering the change out of their short-term interest in lining their own pockets.

Re:A $900B Oil Treasure Lies Beneath West Texas Desert by emp_zealoth on Sunday November 20, 2016 @11:47AM (#12999695)
There are no viable alternatives to oil apart from coal and nuclear, sorry

Not until we have an order-of-magnitude breakthrough in battery tech or some new form of storage

Germany raised it's electricity price almost 3 times since it started it's riddiculous renewable energy bs and they still are only ~25% renewables (And they offshored their heavy, energy intensive industry that just packed up and moved to China, to happily pollute even more than before)

Re:A $900B Oil Treasure Lies Beneath West Texas Desert by TeMPOraL on Sunday November 20, 2016 @02:50PM (#13000763)
> nuclear

There you have it. This is a viable alternative that's safe, and green.

Germany did exactly the wrong thing IMO. They should've expanded their nuclear capacity instead of shutting off perfectly good plans and starting to pollute the world (proxying through China, as you say).

Re:A $900B Oil Treasure Lies Beneath West Texas Desert by Retric on Sunday November 20, 2016 @07:16AM (#12998486)
Oil is a finite resource, this does not mean we will suddenly use it all up. Instead the cost of extraction will continue to rise until alternatives displace oil. Getting ahead of that transistion has a lot of value just look at companies like Kodak who missed shifts like these.
Re:A $900B Oil Treasure Lies Beneath West Texas Desert by clackanon on Sunday November 20, 2016 @03:11AM (#12997858)
You believe in popular AGW theory. Not everyone does. Not everyone takes it as fact that global warming is what folks say it is. There's enough spin and inconsistency in the scientific community that not even they agree on it. Let's assume for sake of discussion that warming is happening. Okay. I'll do my best to live responsibly. Am I going to buy in to all the Chicken Little melodrama? Nope.

Also, I thinking there's enough good momentum towards use of alt energy resources, that we're going the right direction.

Re:A $900B Oil Treasure Lies Beneath West Texas Desert by goodcanadian on Sunday November 20, 2016 @06:28AM (#12998307)
There's enough spin and inconsistency in the scientific community that not even they agree on it.

The scientific consensus is that global warming is real. Climate change is happening now. The debate is about the details: how much warming there will be, how fast, and what the effects will be. This is a normal part of science, and how it's supposed to work. Regardless of the details, at this point, it is pretty clear by now that we are screwed even if we aren't quite sure how badly.

As far as I can tell, the only spin comes from idiot politicians invested in the status quo.

Re:A $900B Oil Treasure Lies Beneath West Texas Desert by yread on Sunday November 20, 2016 @03:16AM (#12997872)
You made a comment on HACKER news to "discuss" how scientific community doesn't agree on AGW?
Re:A $900B Oil Treasure Lies Beneath West Texas Desert by madaxe_again on Sunday November 20, 2016 @03:45AM (#12997941)
This is hacker news. Here, climate change is a conspiracy theory, automation will never destroy any jobs or require any change in how we live, and unregulated capitalism is the solution to everything. Oh, and we're pretty stoked about our new NRX, oh, sorry, alt-right president!

What, you thought this community was better? That smart people are smart?

Sorry - smart people are stupid too - their mistakes are just bigger. Who do you think designed the nazi war machine, idiots? Was Speer a dullard?

No. intelligent people believe just as much stupid crap as the next man. They choose to ignore their education in favour of emotion.

Yarr, down she goes. Creatures which dwell under rocks dislike the light.

Re:A $900B Oil Treasure Lies Beneath West Texas Desert by edem on Sunday November 20, 2016 @04:02AM (#12997991)
Care to elaborate about debunked theories? I'd like to see proof/refutation about those theories. The main problem is not necessarily how you extract it but how you use it. If you burn it you contribute to global warming. If you burn the forest which was present before the extraction you also contribute to global warming.
Re:A $900B Oil Treasure Lies Beneath West Texas Desert by mdpopescu on Sunday November 20, 2016 @01:57AM (#12997682)
"The world is ending, give us money." I don't know if Christianity started it, but at least since Malthus others have figured out it's a good scam.

I am wondering if anyone will mention "peak oil" here too :)

Re:A $900B Oil Treasure Lies Beneath West Texas Desert by guelo on Sunday November 20, 2016 @02:24AM (#12997758)
People concerned about climate change are not asking for money.
Re:A $900B Oil Treasure Lies Beneath West Texas Desert by reitanqild on Sunday November 20, 2016 @02:48AM (#12997804)
Around here it seems they always are:

Just now goverment is about to be thrown because (at least from my somewhat biased understanding) they insist that any extra income from climate taxes on fuel are distributed back to the population in the form of tax breaks or cheaper train tickets :-/

Re:A $900B Oil Treasure Lies Beneath West Texas Desert by ori_b on Sunday November 20, 2016 @02:57AM (#12997823)
If there was a way to cut the burning of fossil fuels dramatically that didn't involve taxing it, or being too heavy handed dictating what to put on the markets, I'd be happy to see it put into action. In fact, I'd prefer it, because tax revenue from environmental damage gives government a perverse incentive to allow companies to continue with environmental damage.

Until then, the money coming in from taxation is going to be used somewhere, and it seems a shame to use it somewhere that doesn't benefit anyone.

Re:A $900B Oil Treasure Lies Beneath West Texas Desert by briandear on Sunday November 20, 2016 @04:25AM (#12998050)
There is a way: it's called the free market. We didn't tax horses to force the innovation of cars and airplanes. Taxation didn't lead to telephones and computers.

When someone develops cheap, plentiful, clean energy at scale, oil will be made redundant. The free market is all about innovation and achieving a competitive advantage.

Re:A $900B Oil Treasure Lies Beneath West Texas Desert by inimino on Sunday November 20, 2016 @04:46AM (#12998087)
So how does the free market solve the problem of incentivizing people to not destroy the commons? Oh, that's right, it doesn't.
Re:A $900B Oil Treasure Lies Beneath West Texas Desert by nec4b on Sunday November 20, 2016 @01:46PM (#13000367)
Maybe you should check the environment of former socialist republics (e.g. Soviet Union), since you somehow believe that collectivist systems take better care of the commons.
Re:A $900B Oil Treasure Lies Beneath West Texas Desert by inimino on Sunday November 20, 2016 @08:39PM (#13002432)
Did I say that? No.

Maybe you should check your cold war mindset whereby pointing out a limitation of the free market necessarily gets a response about the USSR. As though that were literally the only possible alternative.

To recap:

ori_b: How to disincentivize fossil fuel use? [a current policy goal]

briandear: The free market! All we need is magical energy tech that doesn't exist yet and makes oil obsolete overnight, haha.

me: The free market actually doesn't solve the externality problem.

you: The USSR wasn't perfect either!

Re:A $900B Oil Treasure Lies Beneath West Texas Desert by Floegipoky on Sunday November 20, 2016 @08:14AM (#12998684)
The free market is incapable of valuing the environment. How do you place a dollar amount on the survival of our species? Every gallon of petrol burned causes damage to the environment. How do you calculate the cost of that damage? How can the free market ever solve our problem if this very real cost is not reflected in the price of the product? Don't you think it's fishy that oil companies are now actually pushing for more taxes on fossil fuels? It's because they know that they'll get a bargain; the tax will always be lower than the value of the damage they're causing to our planet, and by the time everyone else realizes that it will be too late. They will be even more rich, and our species will be franticly scrambling to deal with the consequences of our inaction.

We've seen it time and time again; the free market is prone to the same short-sightedness as the rest of the human race. It will continue advancing in exactly the same way until it is either forced to change or eats itself whole, except instead of a depression we will face extinction.

Re:A $900B Oil Treasure Lies Beneath West Texas Desert by ArkyBeagle on Sunday November 20, 2016 @01:25PM (#13000240)
The work of Coase and Pigou both imply that the free market is perfectly capable of "valuing the environment" - these things just don't adhere well to states in which identity politics make reasoning about these things in a price way off limits.

I freely admit for myself - it seems rather a cold and .. Vulcan way of looking at it, but what other choice is there?

It's humanity that is short-sighted ( because of time pressure in decision processes causing things like hyperbolic discounting )and free markets reflect that, as would any thinking other than purest central planning.

We're back to "no straight thing was ever constructed from the crooked timber of humanity." Trying to ... sawmill it straight has a pretty poor track record.

Meanwhile, the hydrocarbon industry sowed the wind by drinking the zero-coupon bond Kool-Aid and will reap the whirlwind.

Re:A $900B Oil Treasure Lies Beneath West Texas Desert by masklinn on Sunday November 20, 2016 @02:07PM (#13000503)
> The work of Coase and Pigou both imply that the free market is perfectly capable of "valuing the environment" […] It's humanity that is short-sighted

I'm not sure there's anything more worthless than purely theorical econ, if you assume perfectly spherical cows in a vacuum all economic systems will end up at the same point and it doesn't really matter which one you pick.

> We're back to "no straight thing was ever constructed from the crooked timber of humanity." Trying to ... sawmill it straight has a pretty poor track record.

And yet that's the entire point of political and economic system, if you unmoor the system from the "crooked timber of humanity" it has no application.

Re:A $900B Oil Treasure Lies Beneath West Texas Desert by ArkyBeagle on Sunday November 20, 2016 @03:32PM (#13001013)
Systems which use the noises in people's heads to cancel each other out do better. That's Smith's point abut his scorn for "the Man Of System" - nobody is that smart.

It's important to understand the limitations of such things.

Re:A $900B Oil Treasure Lies Beneath West Texas Desert by reitanqild on Sunday November 20, 2016 @07:54AM (#12998615)
Didn't downvote you but I for one am totally happy with taxes being used to help speed up this process; that is as long as it isn't just used as an excuse for increasing the general tax burden.

This is why I was happy last year when gas taxes were raised and the money fed back to cut taxes and help reduce ticket prices.

Re:A $900B Oil Treasure Lies Beneath West Texas Desert by masklinn on Sunday November 20, 2016 @09:48AM (#12999073)
> There is a way: it's called the free market.

The free market cares nothing about externalities unless it's forced to.

> When someone develops cheap, plentiful, clean energy at scale, oil will be made redundant.

Case in point. And you're ignoring oil companies fighting tooth and nail to avoid that situation.

> The free market is all about innovation and achieving a competitive advantage.

The free market is about making money. An excellent to do that is to suppress innovation so that your product remains relevant.

Re:A $900B Oil Treasure Lies Beneath West Texas Desert by smsm42 on Sunday November 20, 2016 @03:11AM (#12997860)
Some of them definitely are. Like sellers of carbon credits, or multiple "green energy" projects relying solely or mainly on government (read: taxpayer financed) investment, or proponents of climate taxes, or even companies like Tesla who makes hundreds of millions per year selling "green car credits" to other car companies. There's a lot of money in the game by now, even if most regular folks don't get any of it.
Re:A $900B Oil Treasure Lies Beneath West Texas Desert by TeMPOraL on Sunday November 20, 2016 @06:12AM (#12998272)
Are they? Carbon credits are at least in principle meant to accomplish a reasonable goal. As for relying on taxpayer-financed investments, that's exactly what tax money is meant to be used for. I mean, damn it, Tesla is the golden standard of using government loans efficiently, for the betterment of society, and even paying them back in full ahead of schedule! And they get criticized for it. I guess some people don't care about reality if it doesn't fit into their ideologies... sigh
Re:A $900B Oil Treasure Lies Beneath West Texas Desert by smsm42 on Sunday November 20, 2016 @01:05PM (#13000139)
> Carbon credits are at least in principle meant to accomplish a reasonable goal.

The argument is not whether the goal is reasonable, but whether are money is play. With carbon credits, there certainly are, and a lot of it.

> As for relying on taxpayer-financed investments, that's exactly what tax money is meant to be used for.

Nope, it's exactly what tax money are not meant to be used for. Tax money should be used to protect the citizens, to provide for law enforcement, defense, common infrastructure, taking care of the poor and ill. High-risk venture investment is not what it should be used for. That's what private VCs are for. And if VCs wouldn't want to touch it with ten-foot pole, maybe there's a reason for that.

> Tesla is the golden standard of using government loans efficiently, for the betterment of society, and even paying them back in full ahead of schedule!

Exactly because they profited so much out of "green credits" mandate, effectively taxing owners of all other cars to their advantage. Getting hundreds of millions by government mandate is a pretty sweet deal, especially if their direct competitors have to pay it.

Re:A $900B Oil Treasure Lies Beneath West Texas Desert by guelo on Sunday November 20, 2016 @01:26PM (#13000248)
This whole line of reasoning is far fetched. "The world is ending, give us money", you're suggesting that climate change is a hoax perpetrated by green credit market participants? It's just twisting the obvious, that climate change comes from concerned scientists, to try to add some evil ulterior motive. All to shove reality into your preferred worldview that liberal masterminds are trying to ruin the world, or something.
Re:A $900B Oil Treasure Lies Beneath West Texas Desert by TeMPOraL on Sunday November 20, 2016 @02:55PM (#13000801)
> High-risk venture investment is not what it should be used for. That's what private VCs are for. And if VCs wouldn't want to touch it with ten-foot pole, maybe there's a reason for that.

VCs are glorified gamblers. I think you need to take a good look at how advanced science and technology has been done since there is science and technology; you'll quickly realize it always has direct or indirect government backing - because market itself doesn't exactly favour anything more long-term than your next quarterly report.

> effectively taxing owners of all other cars to their advantage

If that was true, I'd actually be pretty happy about it - about time someone made polluters pay for the externalities. But this isn't true, in fact it's government who decides that certain areas of technology (like green energy, green transportation) should be developed further, and offers loans and grants as a way of incentivizing companies to work in those areas.

Re:A $900B Oil Treasure Lies Beneath West Texas Desert by smsm42 on Wednesday November 23, 2016 @05:23PM (#13026262)
> VCs are glorified gamblers

So instead of gambling with the money from affluent people, given voluntarily, we should gamble with tax money, taken coercively from much poorer people, competing with budgets for welfare, hospitals, schools, etc. - and gamble with that. Brilliant.

> because market itself doesn't exactly favour anything more long-term than your next quarterly report.

It's bullcrap, easily disproven by existance of multiple companies with hundred-year histories. And existance of whole divisions in those companies doing long-term projects.

> If that was true,

What you mean "if"? That's a fact. Easily verifyable. Tesla sells credits to other auto-makers. It has been reported many times and widely known.

Re:A $900B Oil Treasure Lies Beneath West Texas Desert by inimino on Sunday November 20, 2016 @04:17AM (#12998038)
In a theoretical world, rational actors would never take the dominated option. We don't live in that world.

In our world, the one making the choice may not be the one adversely affected. There may be disagreement about the best action. There may be unavoidable risks.

Examples: thermonuclear war, global warming, predatory lending, biological weapons...

Consider a hypothetical doomsday device that could be developed in a garage. The "all options are a net good" principle is just not a very useful one in practice.

We've always been pessimistic about human nature. Advancing technology raises the stakes.

Re:A $900B Oil Treasure Lies Beneath West Texas Desert by guelo on Sunday November 20, 2016 @01:32AM (#12997598)
The option to ban extraction is not on the table at all. Wells start pumping immediately after a discovery is made. The election of Trump is a dawning realization to many of us that our civilization is incapable of stopping it's acceleration as we head over the climate change cliff.