When someone develops cheap, plentiful, clean energy at scale, oil will be made redundant. The free market is all about innovation and achieving a competitive advantage.
Maybe you should check your cold war mindset whereby pointing out a limitation of the free market necessarily gets a response about the USSR. As though that were literally the only possible alternative.
To recap:
ori_b: How to disincentivize fossil fuel use? [a current policy goal]
briandear: The free market! All we need is magical energy tech that doesn't exist yet and makes oil obsolete overnight, haha.
me: The free market actually doesn't solve the externality problem.
you: The USSR wasn't perfect either!
We've seen it time and time again; the free market is prone to the same short-sightedness as the rest of the human race. It will continue advancing in exactly the same way until it is either forced to change or eats itself whole, except instead of a depression we will face extinction.
I freely admit for myself - it seems rather a cold and .. Vulcan way of looking at it, but what other choice is there?
It's humanity that is short-sighted ( because of time pressure in decision processes causing things like hyperbolic discounting )and free markets reflect that, as would any thinking other than purest central planning.
We're back to "no straight thing was ever constructed from the crooked timber of humanity." Trying to ... sawmill it straight has a pretty poor track record.
Meanwhile, the hydrocarbon industry sowed the wind by drinking the zero-coupon bond Kool-Aid and will reap the whirlwind.
I'm not sure there's anything more worthless than purely theorical econ, if you assume perfectly spherical cows in a vacuum all economic systems will end up at the same point and it doesn't really matter which one you pick.
> We're back to "no straight thing was ever constructed from the crooked timber of humanity." Trying to ... sawmill it straight has a pretty poor track record.
And yet that's the entire point of political and economic system, if you unmoor the system from the "crooked timber of humanity" it has no application.
It's important to understand the limitations of such things.
This is why I was happy last year when gas taxes were raised and the money fed back to cut taxes and help reduce ticket prices.
The free market cares nothing about externalities unless it's forced to.
> When someone develops cheap, plentiful, clean energy at scale, oil will be made redundant.
Case in point. And you're ignoring oil companies fighting tooth and nail to avoid that situation.
> The free market is all about innovation and achieving a competitive advantage.
The free market is about making money. An excellent to do that is to suppress innovation so that your product remains relevant.
Until then, the money coming in from taxation is going to be used somewhere, and it seems a shame to use it somewhere that doesn't benefit anyone.