News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:IAMA founder of NewsTilt, a YC startup trying to reinvent... by blehn on Tuesday April 27, 2010 @01:41PM (#1298964)
The problem with aggregating comments is that it degrades the quality of discussion, and therefore, the community. There's no depth, no flow. Backtype does the aggregation thing, but I find it just looks like noise.

Maybe there's a better way, but I've yet to see something better than the type of 5-10 level deep conversations that happen on reddit/HN.

Re:IAMA founder of NewsTilt, a YC startup trying to reinvent... by Volscio on Tuesday April 27, 2010 @03:10PM (#1299306)
I agree with you. But maybe the aggregation isn't for more conversation (people like to do that within their trusted communities), but to enable better filtering. That is, you could have a rough total count of interest in a topic. Then you could label comments different things like "funny", "anecdote", "primary source", "trolling", etc. So if I just want to read the funniest comments, I could. If I wanted to get more context from on the ground, I could select "primary source" or whatever. Not sure why this isn't done already...I'm sure enough random commenters would categorize comments on their own to make it useful.