News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:SpaceX plans worldwide satellite Internet with low latenc... by matt_wulfeck on Thursday November 17, 2016 @07:50PM (#12983342)
[deleted]
Re:SpaceX plans worldwide satellite Internet with low latenc... by trsohmers on Thursday November 17, 2016 @08:00PM (#12983384)
These satellites are orbiting at around ~900 miles up, which is about a 10ms round trip ping. I average around 75ms ping on my T Mobile LTE connection, which I think will be in line with SpaceX's offering.

The altitude of the ISS is only ~250 miles above sea level, while the distance from SF to LA is ~400.

Re:SpaceX plans worldwide satellite Internet with low latenc... by candiodari on Thursday November 17, 2016 @08:00PM (#12983382)
Specs for minimum ping of some internet technologies:

2G (100–400 Kbit/s) 300–1000 ms

3G (0.5–5 Mbit/s) 100–500 ms

4G (1–50 Mbit/s) < 100 ms

ADSL+PPP (0.1-200 Mbit/s) 40 ms

Cable (2 Mbit/s - 1 Gbit/s) 80 ms

Fibre (1 Gbit/s - 100 Gbit/s) 5 ms

Note that this latency is just the transmission delay, it does not send your data more than a few hundred meters (technically up to 200km for fibre, but usually the actual distance sent is still hundreds of meters).

After that, you should consider that your data is probably being sent at least to the capital of your state, or some other large city, before there is any routing (meaning a packet to your neighbor gets sent to this large city and back). This distance tends to be more than the distance to LEO and back (but of course, your wouldn't be sending it straight up to LEO but at an angle, so the number of satellites makes a large difference. At 4000, it won't be a huge angle).

So this can still beat every technology except perhaps FTTH, which is hugely expensive and not widely spread at all. Furthermore, it can beat every mobile last mile technology.

Re:SpaceX plans worldwide satellite Internet with low latenc... by ricardobeat on Thursday November 17, 2016 @08:07PM (#12983432)
Where are those numbers from? I get a consistent 12ms ping with my cable internet (200Mbps) to local cloud servers, and have seen as low as 1-4ms on fiber.
Re:SpaceX plans worldwide satellite Internet with low latenc... by Benjamin_Dobell on Thursday November 17, 2016 @08:26PM (#12983553)
Yeah, I'm pretty sure they're made up, and they lack context.

40ms for ADSL... From where to where are you pinging?

Gamers will regularly achieve ~20ms pings to other gamers on the same continent. Where as pinging around the other side of world (under-sea cables) is going to add approximately 150-200 ms.

Also FTTH vs. ADSL vs. Cable really shouldn't make much difference with regards to ping (they're all fibre for the majority of the distance). The main reason FTTH (or even FTTN) networks tend to have a quicker ping is because they usually have newer/faster routing hardware running on them.

Re:SpaceX plans worldwide satellite Internet with low latenc... by candiodari on Thursday November 17, 2016 @08:55PM (#12983682)
You should try Australia. Undersea cables definitely adds more than 150-200ms (but I guess you mean the Atlantic) to everything here.
Re:SpaceX plans worldwide satellite Internet with low latenc... by Benjamin_Dobell on Thursday November 17, 2016 @11:11PM (#12984272)
I have tried Australia... it's where I live ;)

~150ms is how much time it takes for my packets to travel the ocean from Australia to USA.

The UK in total is around 350ms (including lots of land routing). That's mostly due to non-optimal routing, it shouldn't be quite that slow.

Re:SpaceX plans worldwide satellite Internet with low latenc... by pugz on Thursday November 17, 2016 @10:41PM (#12984110)
He _did_ say on the same continent. 150-200ms within Australia would be considered pretty slow.
Re:SpaceX plans worldwide satellite Internet with low latenc... by dfischer on Thursday November 17, 2016 @07:54PM (#12983356)
In the article it says that it's because of the current deployment of satellites being at 22k miles high. Tesla plans to launch the satellites at a range of 715-823 miles which will reduce the latency to 25-35ms.
Re:SpaceX plans worldwide satellite Internet with low latenc... by stigi on Thursday November 17, 2016 @08:02PM (#12983397)
tiny lol at "Tesla plans to launch the satellites..." Guess I'm not the only one who makes this mistake from time to time :)
Re:SpaceX plans worldwide satellite Internet with low latenc... by dfischer on Friday November 18, 2016 @03:23PM (#12989787)
I had to re-read it like 5 times to know what I did wrong. LOL.
Re:SpaceX plans worldwide satellite Internet with low latenc... by cryptoz on Thursday November 17, 2016 @07:55PM (#12983357)
There is a lot less distance between Low Earth Orbit and New York City than there is between New York City and Los Angeles.
Re:SpaceX plans worldwide satellite Internet with low latenc... by monk_e_boy on Thursday November 17, 2016 @08:07PM (#12983433)
Some of us are in the arse end of the UK, so our packets are going across the atlantic and back again.
Re:SpaceX plans worldwide satellite Internet with low latenc... by whatupdave on Thursday November 17, 2016 @07:54PM (#12983355)
the article states that they'll be ~800 miles up, so about 8ms there and back
Re:SpaceX plans worldwide satellite Internet with low latenc... by felixfurtak on Thursday November 17, 2016 @08:09PM (#12983446)
It only has fiber to compete with, and light only travels at 2/3 speed in fiber compared to free space.
Re:SpaceX plans worldwide satellite Internet with low latenc... by ChuckMcM on Thursday November 17, 2016 @08:27PM (#12983557)
It certainly higher latency than loitering solar powered aircraft or balloons above 60,000 feet.
[dead]
Re:SpaceX plans worldwide satellite Internet with low latenc... by ahh on Thursday November 17, 2016 @07:59PM (#12983380)
The answer is in the article, sure (OP: much lower altitude satellites, so much lower RTTs), but that was an incredibly rude way to say so.

Please don't do that.

Re:SpaceX plans worldwide satellite Internet with low latenc... by jpambrun on Friday November 18, 2016 @08:50AM (#12986696)
I understand that I easily get annoyed, but it is the first topic of the article.

I mean.. why even bother to comment if you don't even read the first few paragraphs?