Pakistan and India have gone to war no fewer than 4 times since their independence not 7 decades ago. It was considered basically a miracle that the 2008 terrorist attacks in Mumbai didn't spark a war, and the tensions between the two countries remain the most likely potential nuclear war. That gets you Karachi, Mumbai, Delhi (Kolkata is on the wrong side of the country).
Cairo, Istanbul, and Tehran could become war zones in a future Middle Eastern conflict, although the Israeli-Palestinian conflict does seem to have declined in importance to the Arab region as a whole. The risk of a World War III involving China or Russia is probably understated--especially given Putin's responses to the increasing failure of the Russian economy since the 2008 financial crisis.
It is also worth pointing out that many of the megacities that people are concerned about don't exist yet--the number of megacities is expected to grow, predominantly in Africa, a region not known for stability of governments. You might say that solid middle-class countries would help to stabilize the governments, but the Syrian and Libyan civil wars really ought to be clear signs of the fallacy of that belief.
In many respects, though, the main point of a military is not to fight wars--it's to figure out how to, and be prepared to, fight the next war. Acting as if wars won't happen won't guarantee you peace--indeed, WWII, the bloodiest war in history, was so bloody precisely because its principal actors refused to believe that is was going to happen.
Most of their navy can't even get from their west coast to their east coast, never mind supporting an invasion of Tokyo, over 300 miles of water.
Neither the Libyan nor Syrian civil war was caused by a failure of the middle class or institutions. In both cases the wars were fomented by external state actors who sought geopolitical advantages at the expense of these nations. In any case your sample size of 2 is insufficient to prove anything
If a war broke out in Tehran no prizes for guessing which nation would start it.
Historically, wars have happened because the balance of powers of nations becomes ambiguous. Thanks to natural human over-confidence, each believes they could win it, and so they go to war even though in reality everyone loses. The U.S. has been the undisputed global power since WW2, but there's a ticking demographics time-bomb that's pretty apparent in your list of cities.
Imagine 1% of that 10 million joined an insurgency. That is 100,000 people. I think this is a distinct enough possibility for a military to prepare for. In fact, the US already works on both ends. Supporting insurgencies in Libya and Syria while helping fight them in Iraq, Yemen, and Afghanistan. These aren't mega cities but the possibility still remains.
> For what plausible reason
> would you invade and occupy
> a city with a population of
> over 10 million?
Of your list, what, 50% have been occupied in the last 100 years?1920 Tokyo: 3.7 million[1]
1950 Shanghai: 6.2 million[2]
1971 Mumbai: 5.9 million[3]
1921 Greater London: 7.5 million[4]; Inner London: 4.9 million
Terms like Metro-area and Megalopois are different stories...
[0]https://www1.nyc.gov/site/planning/data-maps/nyc-population/...
[1]http://www.metro.tokyo.jp/ENGLISH/ABOUT/HISTORY/history03.ht...
[2]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Demographics_of_Shanghai
Surely this is a failure of imagination, rather than a complete impossibility?
In the last few years we have seen:
The US Airforce providing aircover for Iranian militias.[1]
Turkey shoot down a Russian fighter/bomber over Syria[2] and then become close (?) allies[3]
The Philippines win a ruling against Chinese actions in the South China sea[4], then decide to ally with China and accept Chinese ambitions in the South China sea[5], and then return to their original position (maybe?)[6]
The world's most populous Islamic nation has a Christian governor of its capital city[7].
The UK voted to exit the EU, but no one is quite sure how it will happen
And Donald Trump won the US election.
So yeah.. I have no idea why the US would want to invade and occupy a 10M+ population city. But it is entirely possible something like that could happen.
[1] https://warisboring.com/american-coalition-is-providing-clos...
[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2015_Russian_Sukhoi_Su-24_shoo...
[3] http://www.bbc.com/news/world-europe-37045724
[4] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Philippines_v._China
[5] http://www.aljazeera.com/news/2016/10/philippines-duterte-ch...
[6] http://www.forbes.com/sites/panosmourdoukoutas/2016/11/13/ro...
I agree that the MIC is a toxic influence on policy, but lets not let that blind ourselves to conducting healthy analysis on what warfare might look like in the future.
Considering the level of corruption from top to bottom in Rio, do they really bring "law and order"?
I'm sure they have scenarios where an armed sectarian revolt in 2040 Los Angeles-San Diego needs to be suppressed by force. The region is potentially vulnerable and critical for food security.
And, for that matter, what about NYC and LA? Another round of civil war in the US is unlikely but not impossible, and the military wouldn't want to be caught on the hop.
Pakistan has nukes. Please don't invade countries with nukes. And if there's one thing that Syria has taught us, or at least should have: urban fighting ultimately destroys cities leaving a near-empty ruinous shell and creates huge numbers of refugees which are both an economic burden and political dynamite that sees ultra right-wing leaders and policies voted in.
A city is a city because it's where a vast amount of people live. You're bringing deadly conflict to people's doorsteps and creating tomorrow's terrorist. This is fundamental, not something that can be solved with technology or hip new ways of thinking.
For what plausible reason would you invade and occupy a city with a population of over 10 million? Here is a list of cities with a population of 10 million or more, please tell me for what good reason any one of them should they be invaded:
Tokyo, Shanghai, Jakarta, Karachi, Seoul, New York City, Mumbai, Manila, Mexico City, Delhi, Beijing, São Paulo, Lagos, Wuhan, Kyoto-Osaka-Kobe, Guangzhou, Chongqing, Cairo, Los Angeles, Chengdu, Dhaka, Moscow, Tianjin, Bangkok, Istanbul, Kolkata, Rio de Janeiro, London, Buenos Aires, Tehran, Kinshasa, Paris, Shenzhen, Harbin, Rhine-Ruhr, Lahore
Maybe invest as much time and money thinking about peace as you do on war and you might not need to bankrupt your country to fight another one. The US's military industrial complex is the ultimate case of when all you have is a hammer, everything looks like a nail.