When you buy hard disks ONLY buy from Amazon or Newegg directly - never buy from a 3rd party seller on their site. Especially for hard disks there is too much fraud, and for a hard disk especially the risk of data loss makes it just too risky (unlike other items).
Agreed. A few times I've purchased third-party disks and found (via SMART data) that the drives were well used despite not being sold as such.
I don't read this as 'which drive to buy' but more as 'which drive not to buy'.
Disclaimer: I work at Backblaze. I know you didn't mean that as an absolute, but I just want to point out 100% of drives fail. It's my OCD that makes me point this out. We have NEVER found a drive that lasted forever. There are two types of drives: 1) those that have already failed, and 2) those that are about to fail. For any data you would be annoyed to lose, you need three copies in three locations with three separate vendors (three different pieces of software that don't share any lines of code).
Also, not sure there are three pieces of storage software that I trust and are readily available to me.
We found this, as well. And we stopped trying to get the HGST drives after we got a bad batch from a seller on Amazon.
https://www.backblaze.com/blog/hard-drive-reliability-update...
For example when I search for HGST HMS5C4040ALE640 on Amazon I get a dealer selling old out of warrantee drives as new.
https://www.amazon.com/HGST-MegaScale-HMS5C4040ALE640-Coolsp...
I get similar results with many of the other drives listed and with other websites such as NewEgg.