News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How We Make Money at Stack Overflow by lucb1e on Tuesday November 15, 2016 @11:39AM (#12959570)
StackOverflow is an extremely valuable resource for all programmers. I've not seen the option anywhere, but a yearly donation would definitely be something I'd do for a substantial amount (substantial to me as a student, so it's not the moon but not a beer either).
Re:How We Make Money at Stack Overflow by subhobroto on Tuesday November 15, 2016 @11:49AM (#12959699)
My following suggestion is a very unpopular one, but it is this:

If you are a student, use the money you would have donated to StackOverflow to purchase a book or a tool that will help you to learn better and become an expert.

If you are an expert, contribute your time to StackOverflow (instead of money).

Money is easy to get compared to content. What helps StackOverflow grow is quality content.

I am also interested how they approach the subject of money:

> How much money we make is a direct proxy for how much we are helping our users. We focus on maximizing how we help users in order to make a great business. Very few companies have done this successfully, and we take great pride in the fact that we’re one of them.

Personally, I would love to see how this works out and I wish them well. Hopefully they can prove this model works well. Users need this model to work well for other businesses to adopt.

Re:How We Make Money at Stack Overflow by user837387 on Tuesday November 15, 2016 @01:10PM (#12960523)
>>book or a tool that will help you to learn better and become

I've tried that before, many times. Unfortunately when you are trying to do real work those books are many times useless. Example, I kept trying to build a newtonian physics simulator so I got a Statics and Dynamics mechanical engineering book. The book was a text book for Mechanical engineering students and yet the examples they teach you are for toy problems. I could not generalize them to real world scenarios. To actually build the physics simulator I had to scour the internet until I found something that actually explained what I needed in an easy to understand manner [1]. And that still was not enough. I still had to use more online sources to find out all the other pieces, like the separating axes theorem for collision detection.

So no, I would not rely on books anymore, at least not exclusively since they often do not provide a full picture. One last thing, books seem to be getting progressively worse in my experience. All of this is anecdotal of course.

[1]http://chrishecker.com/Rigid_Body_Dynamics

Re:How We Make Money at Stack Overflow by Bartweiss on Tuesday November 15, 2016 @01:51PM (#12960994)
As an aside, buying a print reference book frequently feels counterproductive.

Even if I'm going to get a formal reference text, instead of online resources, I probably want a digital copy. Otherwise, I find myself going "I wish I could do text search for this thing..." and wondering why I didn't get the version that actually allows that. When I read for pleasure I enjoy the physicality of books; when I read for technical reference I demand the interface of a computer.

Re:How We Make Money at Stack Overflow by johncolanduoni on Tuesday November 15, 2016 @05:13PM (#12962781)
For books without ebooks from the manufacturer but for which I can find an illicit PDF or djvu, I usually buy the print one and read the digital version.
Re:How We Make Money at Stack Overflow by lucb1e on Tuesday November 15, 2016 @01:28PM (#12960745)
I have the same experience with books. I don't buy non-fiction for learning purposes* because it never worked. I tried with an IPv6 book which I read a few chapters of; I tried with another book or two that I don't even remember; I was gifted two books, one about making games and the other about programming paradigms, neither of which I ever read more than a few pages of... and yet I'm perfectly proficient by just playing around in spare time and looking up stuff I need and stuff I run into.

* I do buy non-fiction for amusement and casual interests though, like Predictably Irrational.

Re:How We Make Money at Stack Overflow by tikhonj on Tuesday November 15, 2016 @01:31PM (#12960779)
I've contributed a fair amount to Stack Overflow, but it's actually pretty hard in the niches I care about. Not because the questions are hard, but because people answer them so quickly: it's hard to find a question I can answer that hasn't been addressed well. That's a great problem for Stack Overflow to have, of course, but I do wonder if there's some easy way to monitor specific tags without having to constantly refresh the page...
Re:How We Make Money at Stack Overflow by isxek on Tuesday November 15, 2016 @09:46PM (#12964142)
There is, if you use an RSS reader. There are feeds associated with each tag. Try clicking any tag, and you should see a link where you can get an RSS feed of all the new questions that come in for that tag.

It's been there for a long time. ;-)

Re:How We Make Money at Stack Overflow by lucb1e on Tuesday November 15, 2016 @01:36PM (#12960833)
Well if there is no work left to be done, so be it I guess? I don't think you should feel bad about that :)
Re:How We Make Money at Stack Overflow by lucb1e on Tuesday November 15, 2016 @01:25PM (#12960718)
> Money is easy to get compared to content. What helps StackOverflow grow is quality content.

I do, >10k rep on the security.stackexchange.com site. I just think it's an amazing platform that I'd like to support with hosting and development costs.

Re:How We Make Money at Stack Overflow by subhobroto on Tuesday November 15, 2016 @02:41PM (#12961449)
> I do, >10k rep on the security.stackexchange.com site

That's amazing! Thank you for your contributions. I meant to imply that donating money is usually the least fruitful way to contribute, in my experience. It should be your last resort; definitely not the first one.

Example: One way SO can really gain from your security expertise is for you to think about how anonymous answers can be supported. That will be far more valuable than $$$.

I posted about this here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12961447

I would love to read your opinions about this crazy idea!

Re:How We Make Money at Stack Overflow by Nition on Tuesday November 15, 2016 @06:54PM (#12963438)
I have to agree. This happens on forums as well. I've Google searched something before and found people discussing my problem on some random forum. Maybe I know something that might help, but its a hassle to create an account to post.

I bet that happens on Stack Overflow too. People who'll never bother to create an account find a page about a problem through Google and they have something valuable they'd add it if didn't prompt them to sign up first.

I wonder how much trouble it'd actually cause spam wise.

Re:How We Make Money at Stack Overflow by brazzledazzle on Wednesday November 16, 2016 @03:02AM (#12965258)
I suspect there would be a lot of challenges with it but perhaps letting high rep users validate anonymous contributions would help with the spam. Reveal them only to authenticated users and you remove the incentive for SEO spam.
Re:How We Make Money at Stack Overflow by 0xmohit on Tuesday November 15, 2016 @02:38PM (#12961426)
Contributing is wonderful, but those internet points (reputation) screws it up. An edit would give you 2 points if you have a rep < 2000, and contributes towards badges anyways. People would make pointless edits to a post. See http://stackoverflow.com/posts/21023161/revisions for example. There is no change between the original answer and the latest revision after 3 edits.
Re:How We Make Money at Stack Overflow by slavik81 on Tuesday November 15, 2016 @03:51PM (#12962092)
That example is all on Emil Vikström, who unilaterally accepted a bad edit from Akshat (with minor corrections of his own) after two reviewers had already voted to reject. That's two edits. The third edit was undoing the bad change they accepted. The undo was also contentious, with 2 votes to reject and 3 to accept.

But, Akshat has only 18 points. Even if you're lucky enough to have worthless suggested edits accepted, it's not a very good way to earn points.

Re:How We Make Money at Stack Overflow by subhobroto on Tuesday November 15, 2016 @02:44PM (#12961493)
Excellent insight. I am hopeful SE will figure out a way to stop/reduce this arbitrage opportunity.
Re:How We Make Money at Stack Overflow by jaydles on Tuesday November 15, 2016 @11:58AM (#12959818)
We're humbled hearing from folks like you - your willingness to give back is what makes it all work. Keep your money. But here's how you CAN help, right now: Sign up if you haven't, create a developer story, and when you ARE job-hunting, try Jobs. We I think you'll find it to be the most developer-friendly offering on the planet.
Re:How We Make Money at Stack Overflow by tedmiston on Tuesday November 15, 2016 @12:52PM (#12960346)
Just an anecdote from my experience — I am really enjoying the new Stack Overflow Developer Story. Mine is at [1] for example. While I do appreciate jobs, I'm a full-time independent contractor and not looking for a traditional job right now (though I have seen quality offers through SO Jobs).

That said, Developer Story / CV has been instrumental for me and has become my canonical resume. I'm a huge fan.

If I could make one feature request... it would be a way to indicate conference attendance. It's something I give extra credibility to, for both employers as sponsors / presenters and employees as attendees / speakers / volunteers, as not everyone is willing to put in the effort to give back. [You can see on my CV that I've tried to incorporate this as an "other" at the bottom, but it feels a little out of place.]

[1]: http://stackoverflow.com/cv/taylor

Re:How We Make Money at Stack Overflow by rla4 on Tuesday November 15, 2016 @01:13PM (#12960572)
I'm a dev in the Developer Story/CV team and we appreciate the love <3 The conference attendance item idea is great, discussing it internally with our team right now. Thank you!
Re:How We Make Money at Stack Overflow by lambda on Tuesday November 15, 2016 @12:10PM (#12959943)
Can vouch for it. I found my current job through SO Careers, and now that we're trying to hire more people, we're finding a good number of our better candidates coming through our SO Careers posting.
Re:How We Make Money at Stack Overflow by ohstopitu on Tuesday November 15, 2016 @01:30PM (#12960765)
I would like to suggest a feature request...

I would love to use developer stories but more importantly, would like to integrate my dev story with my website (as this would also keep the "recommended reading" section up to date as well). If there was some way to do this (we can discuss options) without using an iframe, I would LOVE to do so.

Just to mention...I want this on my website & stackoverflow. Updating recommended reading is of a lower priority than having it on my website in the first place.

Re:How We Make Money at Stack Overflow by Paul-ish on Tuesday November 15, 2016 @11:51AM (#12959739)
It is probably better that stack overflow can support itself. Donations would put them at the mercy of others whims. A donation model doesn't make sense when a company can sustain itself while still preserving its core values.
Re:How We Make Money at Stack Overflow by lucb1e on Tuesday November 15, 2016 @01:34PM (#12960808)
> Donations would put them at the mercy of others whims.

Yes, which is why I assume they didn't even bother putting up a donate button. The thing that convinced me to post anyway is that it's probably very clear to a lot of people that it is definitely worth supporting. Much more than the Archive project or the Tor project, this is something I know people use so much every day and get tremendous value from. That's why it might just work in this case, similar to Wikipedia.

It's also not exclusive, they can totally put up donations and try to attract some attention for it by posting it to their own ad system, and at the same time continue with all the current efforts.

Re:How We Make Money at Stack Overflow by tedmiston on Tuesday November 15, 2016 @12:46PM (#12960295)
I consider the time that I give to the community answering questions to the best way to help. While I have no idea how to value that in dollars, it's something I put an effort into regularly.
Re:How We Make Money at Stack Overflow by mehrdada on Tuesday November 15, 2016 @01:37PM (#12960849)
You can also buy a beer for folks who actually wrote an answer you used if you ever meet them IRL. I bet direct revenue from users would be negligible by the other revenue streams Stack Overflow Inc pursues.
Re:How We Make Money at Stack Overflow by edblarney on Tuesday November 15, 2016 @12:58PM (#12960404)
"a yearly donation would definitely be something I'd do for a substantial amount"

There's a word for this, it's called 'subscription' : )

They provide a service, you pay for it.

It's how most of the world works.

I think the underlying issue is price discrimination: how to get the large numbers of those unwilling/unable to pay some value, while providing value to the higher order users as well.

It's a paradox that people will pay more for a coffee than they will something that can help them substantially :)

Re:How We Make Money at Stack Overflow by lucb1e on Tuesday November 15, 2016 @01:31PM (#12960768)
> There's a word for this, it's called 'subscription' : )

I avoided that word because it's the wrong word.

A subscription implies I get something that normal users don't get. I don't want that. I hate services like Dropbox where the free users get benefits for installing it on their Android or from referrals (shitty stuff) and live off of the backs of paying users. Yet here I think it's much more akin to something like open source software, which is for the general good and is worth supporting for those who are able to afford it.

Edit: There is no need to downvote the person, though. To me he seems to be contributing to the conversation.

Re:How We Make Money at Stack Overflow by edblarney on Tuesday November 15, 2016 @02:36PM (#12961417)
"A subscription implies I get something that normal users don't get."

Fair enough - but there are very, very few value creating engines that can feasibly exist in such a context.

Wikipedia is one.

Stackoverflow probably could not.

Someone mentioned it creates 'billions' in value, well, that's probably not too far off.

There's nothing wrong with people paying for things.

But to your point - it would be nice to find a way to do intelligent price discrimination. Students, hobbyists get it free, other entities can pay. etc..

I don't think that would work for Stackoverflow either because there is an inherent 'open-ness' that it needs ... that said, again, there's nothing wrong with paying for things.