News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Not Even In South Park? by niekmaas on Monday April 26, 2010 @03:25PM (#1295681)
So it seems that by making a death threat getting what you want is possible in the western world today. If you don't want SP to make fun of your religious leader? Just make a few death threats and they will censor the episode. And on top of that all other shows are afraid to touch the topic too.

By what will happen is, for instance, Paris Hilton activists will start making death threats to the SP creators? Will Comedy Central start censoring all references to Paris Hilton too?

Probably nothing will happen since Paris Hilton activists haven't killed anyone yet.

So in fact you can conclude that terrism does work to get what you want in the world today.

Re:Not Even In South Park? by laut on Monday April 26, 2010 @03:37PM (#1295717)
In the US, not in all of the western world. In Denmark, Norway, Sweden, Holland etc. the media printed/reprinted the cartoons.

In USA, the land of the free, home of the brave, the big mainstream media seem to censor themselves because of threats of violence.

"They who can give up essential liberty to obtain a little temporary safety, deserve neither liberty nor safety." - Benjamin Franklin

Re:Not Even In South Park? by jaf656s on Monday April 26, 2010 @03:51PM (#1295771)
"They who can give up essential liberty to obtain a little temporary safety, deserve neither liberty nor safety." - Benjamin Franklin

The rights of media companies to print those cartoons in the US are not in question, they still have them. They CHOSE not to run the cartoons. Huge difference.

EDIT: I think my point needs further clarification. It is that they did not give up liberty to gain safety. They chose not to exercise their liberty on a controversial topic. Whether personal safety from death threats was involved in the decision is irrelevant, they can still make the decision. The option to exercise a right is the important part, not the act of exercising the right itself.

Re:Not Even In South Park? by netcan on Monday April 26, 2010 @04:54PM (#1295996)
Can I suggest you reread your statement and think about it again?

Liberty is not only possible to infringe on via government involvement. If someone made a decision to avoid violence against him/her, that is not a free choice. What difference does it make if they are avoiding imprisonment by a state or private violence?

Re:Not Even In South Park? by jaf656s on Monday April 26, 2010 @06:47PM (#1296490)
I still stand by my statement, or at least the intent of my statement.

To say that someone who chooses not to exercise a right, for any reason, doesn't deserve liberty is wrong. They are not giving up the ability to exercise that right for safety, they are choosing not to exercise it for safety. This is the distinction I wanted to make.

Whether personal safety is involved is irrelevant to whether they deserve liberty for choosing not to exercise a right.

Is this more clear?

Re:Not Even In South Park? by netcan on Tuesday April 27, 2010 @02:27AM (#1297413)
That is clearer and (to me) less objectionable.

But I still don't think you are fully understanding the reasoning behind the BF quote. My understanding of "give up essential liberty to obtain a little temporary safety" is failure to struggle, even slightly, for the sake of a principle. The right, which you (I assume) are claiming is inalienable and therefore we can't say they "deserve neither liberty nor safety," is the right to liberty.

You repeat "choose" not to excercise a right as if a choice for the sake of safety is like a choice for the sake of good manners. But, it's not the same. A choice for the sake of safety is not a free choice. Hence, "give up (essential) liberty."

What BF is basically saying is that liberty is a right that must be asserted, in order to be deserved

Re:Not Even In South Park? by jaf656s on Tuesday April 27, 2010 @11:35AM (#1298536)
I think I see what you are saying. It is my belief that if you feel that something is just, and in your rights to do, that you should do it. I also believe that you still deserve those rights if you choose not to. Perhaps I am more lenient than BF.

If you choose to give up the right to do something for yourself and others (which is my interpretation of essential liberty) because it will make you safer in the face of a perceived threat or otherwise, then you don't value your liberty and freedoms, and don't deserve them.

Do you have to exercise, or assert, a right to deserve it? I don't think that you do, but I think that you do have to protect others' right to exercise it, whether you agree with how they exercise that right or not.

I would like to add I enjoy this discussion. You are making me think this through more thoroughly than I would have otherwise.

Re:Not Even In South Park? by netcan on Thursday April 29, 2010 @02:08AM (#1303720)
That is, I think, the widely held view. I somehow think that BF would not have advocated actual stripping of their rights. More of a social statement, such an act diminishes his respect for them. I think that the motive behind it is probably the fact that practically, these rights must be asserted by enough people in order to exist in a society. Shirking this responsibility is contributing to the demise of these rights.

The only thing I still disagree with you on is your use of the word 'choice.' You wouldn't say that you 'choose' to drive on the right side of the road, pay taxes or get a stamp on your passport when you visit countries, would you?

I think you need to make a distinction between a choice that if free and a "choice" that isn't. Even if you don't use different words this is important because otherwise you can't really have any usable explanation of what is infringing on one's freedom.

Re:Not Even In South Park? by pbhjpbhj on Monday April 26, 2010 @08:20PM (#1296720)
>They are not giving up the ability to exercise that right for safety, they are choosing not to exercise it for safety.

To make a hypothetical analogue: You're saying that if I threaten you with death if you leave your house then if you choose not to leave the house so as to live you aren't giving up your right to leave the house only choosing not to exercise that right.

In other words you're saying threatening to kill someone doesn't restrict their rights it just means that if they want to exercise them they'll die. You then appear to be using that as a basis for saying that it's OK to threaten death to someone?

I think you misunderstand the notion of restricting someone rights.

Re:Not Even In South Park? by jaf656s on Tuesday April 27, 2010 @10:38AM (#1298329)
No. I was saying that if you threaten me with death if I leave my house, and I choose to stay in my house for personal safety, that this act doesn't undermine the fact that I DESERVE liberty.

I think restricting others rights by any means (violent or not) is very, very wrong.

Re:Not Even In South Park? by borism on Monday April 26, 2010 @04:17PM (#1295856)
huge difference from companies' and journalists' point of view - maybe.

no difference whatsoever from consumer point of view.

Re:Not Even In South Park? by philwelch on Monday April 26, 2010 @04:39PM (#1295932)
Oh, please. The set of western countries which are not-(Denmark, Norway, Sweden, Netherlands, unnamed etc.) is not simply (USA).
Re:Not Even In South Park? by chaosmachine on Monday April 26, 2010 @04:04PM (#1295817)
Death threats aren't enough. You need death threats plus a history of fanatics willing to back them up.
Re:Not Even In South Park? by jrockway on Monday April 26, 2010 @04:39PM (#1295935)
So in fact you can conclude that terrorism does work to get what you want in the world today.

It doesn't work for white people though -- that guy who flew his plane into the IRS building didn't get what he wanted, and neither did the Unabomber or Timothy McVeigh.

It seems that we are more afraid of different-looking people than we are of being blown up.

Re:Not Even In South Park? by kilowatt on Monday April 26, 2010 @05:24PM (#1296152)
That's a poor comparison. Presumably a small army of white guys pissed off enough by taxation to kamikaze themselves into public buildings does not exist. (Although, see the insurgence of the militia movement, and Palin's "don't retreat, just reload!" rhetoric...)
Re:Not Even In South Park? by astine on Monday April 26, 2010 @07:00PM (#1296529)
I dunno, back when the Klan was in force, people were pretty scared of it.

McVeigh and Kaczynski were one-off wackos, neither of whom managed to make any demands before being caught.

Re:Not Even In South Park? by philwelch on Monday April 26, 2010 @06:12PM (#1296348)
The Unabomber got his essay published. I think he's willing to take that as a win.