News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How Green Is That Grocery Bag Ban? (2014) [pdf] by londons_explore on Saturday November 12, 2016 @12:42PM (#12939004)
This research is valuable, but the quality of this paper seems rather lacklustre. Do research well or don't do it at all. Don't publish an un-peer-reviewed paper with the phrase "is parroted by" in it.

The scope is too wide considering the research it draws from - pick a sub-topic like "plastic bag restrictions effect on tonnage of plastic recovered from street surfaces".

Drawing a chart of "number of bag bans"? Really? We could make that down to one if we just outlawed it nationwide. It isn't a sensible thing to measure.

I really want to see this research done well, but sadly this isn't it.

Re:How Green Is That Grocery Bag Ban? (2014) [pdf] by bo1024 on Saturday November 12, 2016 @02:05PM (#12939556)
This paper is awful from a scientific standpoint. Rather than sticking to facts, it's full of opinionated judgements, logical fallacies, and poor use of statistics to back up claims.

A lot of it is devoted to caricaturing arguments for plastic bag bans and "debunking" them. For example,

> Are Plastic Bags Killing Millions of Marine Animals?

It's also full of logical fallacies. For instance,

> By any measure, plastic bags constitute a small proportion of all litter. So, it would be foolish to focus any strategy intended to reduce litter primarily on plastic bags.

Apparently this is meant to imply that no effort at all should be spent on reducing plastic bag litter.

For instance if you look at Section 2.3 and the bottom of page 18, it cites reports that Americans throw away 100 billion plastic bags per year, then says "A look at the data, however, reveals a very different picture." It goes on to give data that in no way contradicts that figure, but instead focuses the argument on how small a fraction of the mass in landfills comes from plastic bags.

The abstract gives 6 claims, e.g. #1 is "The bans, fees and taxes on shopping bags have a minuscule impact on litter." But the paper is not organized so as to actually go through a demonstrate these claims. You cannot figure out from the introduction or Table of Contents where in the paper one of these claims will be demonstrated, if anywhere.

The support is disappointing due to goalpost-moving, e.g. the main supporting evidence for #1 is that plastic bags only make up a small percent of litter, therefore nothing we could possibly do involving plastic bags can have a large impact on litter.

I could go on, but it's not worth any more time. I'll just close by mentioning that the authors reveal themselves at the end of the abstract, when they write

> Those people who are genuinely concerned about reducing litter and other environmental problems should focus their efforts on solutions that have been proven to work.

Pretty clearly the authors are not including themselves in the list of people who are genuinely concerned about reducing litter or "other environmental problems".

Re:How Green Is That Grocery Bag Ban? (2014) [pdf] by CalChris on Saturday November 12, 2016 @01:44PM (#12939409)
The Reason Foundation is funded by the Koch Family Foundations and David Koch sits on its board of directors. Koch Industries includes plastics manufacturing.

http://reason.org/trustees_and_officers/ http://www.sourcewatch.org/index.php/Koch_Family_Foundations

There is no disclosure of these facts in this report.

Re:How Green Is That Grocery Bag Ban? (2014) [pdf] by wool_gather on Saturday November 12, 2016 @02:08PM (#12939576)
I recognize the importance of skepticism about sources of information, but why would a paper like this need to specifically "disclose" one of the board members of its publishing organization?
Re:How Green Is That Grocery Bag Ban? (2014) [pdf] by oxide on Saturday November 12, 2016 @02:15PM (#12939619)
It seems like a conflict of interest, IMO.

This is very much a political topic. When you take into context where the funding came from, the "research" presented in this abysmal paper looks a lot more like a wolf in sheep's clothing.

Re:How Green Is That Grocery Bag Ban? (2014) [pdf] by azinman2 on Saturday November 12, 2016 @02:36PM (#12939728)
Especially since the Koch brothers use their money to sway policies.... and effectively at that.
Re:How Green Is That Grocery Bag Ban? (2014) [pdf] by rhizome on Saturday November 12, 2016 @02:37PM (#12939736)
Everything can be made a political topic. What is the wolf you're seeing?
Re:How Green Is That Grocery Bag Ban? (2014) [pdf] by DavidAdams on Saturday November 12, 2016 @02:45PM (#12939789)
Because journalists and academics have a longstanding tradition of disclosing potential conflicts of interest, and therefore readers and scholars expect it. To do otherwise displays at best amateurism and at worst a deliberate attempt to hide bias.