Yes, describing things in an overheated, sensationalistic way has a more powerful effect than describing them in an accurate way. Congratulations on figuring that out.
By the way, referring to a business as a Ponzi scheme is prima facie defamatory. I don't think you have much to worry about, since I doubt Facebook will bother to sue you on the basis of a blog post, but you might write differently if you were more conscious of the fact that you're accusing someone of a crime.
Everyone who uses Facebook knows it doesn't solicit, or give, money to/from its audience. There is zero question that Facebook is literally a ponzi scheme any more than it is literally a piece of shit.
The amount of comments here who say that the analogy is libel and which attack the author on this without responding to the points made saddens me.
I doubt Facebook, even if they didn't like the article, would wish to draw attention to the analogy contained therein.
By the way, I never called the author's accusation libelous. I called it defamatory, which it clearly is.
Libel is written defamation, as opposed to slander which is for transitory statements.
I disagree that it's clearly defamation.
Facebook does, in fact, solicit funds -- from advertisers, and from users who want to send virtual gifts to their friends.
but you expected proof that FB was literally a ponzi scheme in the article?
No, I expected some argument to that effect.
Libel is written defamation, as opposed to slander which is for transitory statements.
No, defamation is one of the conditions for libel, but there are others: falsity and malicious intent being the most important.
I disagree that it's clearly defamation.
Allegations of criminal conduct are among the clearest categories of defamation.
Shrug indeed.
Me again> So you know FB doesn't solicit funds or provide them?
You> Facebook does, in fact, solicit funds -- from advertisers...
You're not listening to me. So I won't listen to you.
What's more, I wrote that Facebook solicits funds "from advertisers, and from users who want to send virtual gifts to their friends." You chose to leave that last part out.
It's up to you whether you listen to me or not.
That's sustainable. Facebook is probably going to make their own payment platform mandatory for apps, and they rake 30%. They could quite easily grow to a couple billion in revenue if nobody new ever advertised there again.
Also, local advertising does much better there than most stuff. Better than on Google in some instances.
Why not just say, "I'm super ignorant. Sorry about this post."
A lot of companies have made statements that in retrospect, and maybe even at the time, can be seen as pure hubris.
You could say something cliched like, facebook: web bubble 2.0. Another cliche, facebook management: irrationally exuberant?
Or you could reference companies that failed: facebook: the Global Crossing of our social network.
There are a great number of ways for a company to fail. Many of them do not involve being a fraudulent investment scheme.
"Yet, their value and growth continues because they can use that money to grow their user-base more and assert profitability (in this sense it's not quite entirely a ponzi scheme, but there is no closer idea). It's possible that they do not even realize that they are like a Ponzi scheme."
Moreover, I recognize that Facebook isn't necessarily doing this on purpose (whereas in a real ponzi scheme a competent accountant has to scheme willfully).
Nevertheless, I hope you agree that the positive feedback, the bubble effects, and the deceptive illusion of growth all have analogs to Facebook (if you assume the premise, of course).
I think you are right that I should have used "like a" Ponzi scheme throughout the post, but the writing and the point would have lost a lot of its effect in explaining that. The metaphor is better than the simile.
My main motivation was to make people think about the reality of Facebooks revenue. It may be less solid than social proof makes it seem.