It's funny that people are raging at the midwest because it's been, for the past few decades, quite blue. Hillary just assumed that they were With Her (even though she clearly wasn't With Them) and now they are at fault for not giving her the votes she felt she was owed.
Even if manufacturing and coal mining where to increase ten fold, there would be no new jobs for people without a long education, due to automation.
People are tired of bombing campaigns, corporate welfare, and feeling like they don't have a say or don't have control over their government. These states Hillary lost: Pennsylvania, Ohio, Michigan, Wisconsin, she lost because they didn't feel like she was going to do anything different than her predecessor. And it's true. She wouldn't have.
All I hear from that side of the debate is that somehow the government should restore prosperity to these regions. Why aren't these people moving to do something for themselves if they want change?
If all you can imagine your state being good for is low-skilled labor there is nothing the government can do long term to protect that. Protectionism might bring some "jobs" back but it will come at a long term cost of reducing the USA's competitiveness in the global market (this is exactly why globalisation is a thing).
Personally I think policy in Middle America needs to embrace the state of the world (putting aside petty coast vs interior bullshit) and think about what they can do to compete on a global scale. Then maybe their lives would be better.
In regard to the competitiveness of the USA. I'm not schooled well enough in economics to completely understand everything that is going on, or without speaking about specifics argue for or against your point, but if we need to maintain "competitiveness", and the resulting insanely high profits and income inequality across the board, how are we going to ensure that this fortune is spread throughout the country and not concentrated in the hands of the few? If we can't do that, then we also can't begrudge the poor and those left behind by globalization the change to elect people that will enact policies that will benefit them, even if it's to the detriment of people who, quite frankly, don't care about them because they're just a bunch of poor dumb hicks, or poor black people in the ghetto.
Please keep in mind I'm just open for discussion and expressing a view. I respect what you have to say here, and my goal isn't to cause an argument but to listen to what you have to say, ask questions, and state my opinion as well. :)
i'm not interested in arguing about whether that belief is well founded or self-consistent, or whether their vision of a hands-off gov't is sustainable (i'd argue that neither is sound, but they're not so obviously wrong as to be equivalent to asking for a handout)
Meanwhile, Trump was saying things like "remember when the cars were made in Flint and you couldn't drink the water in Mexico? Now they make the cars in Mexico and you can't drink the water in flint."
Hillary failed to relate to voters. She lost the majority of women and working class, who should be the reliable democratic base. She was the image of robotic boredom and I voted for her. Tim Kaine was a waste of a VP spot and a snub to Bernie. Debbie Wasserman Schultz and Donna Brazile made Hillary look completely untrustworthy. Hillary arrogantly expected Obama's coalition to fall in line behind her without offering them anything to rally behind other than again Trump, which clearly wasn't enough.
Democrats have to own this failure and ask themselves what they could have done better.
If Hillary was playing to win she should have nominated a true-blue progressive and especially one that could have harness some of the OWS/99% energy (without actually formally supporting either).
Her campaign was about Her. Problem is, many many folks are just busy surviving and didn't see themselves with "Her".
However I also believe that there is some truth to most explanations for this election in the HN threads and various op-eds. There's too many factors to reduce it to just one party/group to blame.
http://m.washingtontimes.com/news/2016/oct/8/hillary-clinton...
The DNC is full of incompetent hacks whom were arrogant enough to have allowed this to happen. She dismissed half the country as deplorable, visited Virginia and told the miners there she's shutting the coal plants down. Wore 15 thousand dollar pantsuits to events on poverty. Its not surprising that she lost its surprising that she got as many votes as she did.
I really question this. It keeps getting said, but looking at the numbers from Wisconsin/Michigan/PA trump did get mroe votes, but really Hillary had a massive drop. He had 1300 more votes in Wisconsin than Romney, Hillary had 250k less than Obama.
So is it really angry white americans who trump stole in droves from the democrats... or a democratic candidate who couldn't get people to show up.
The rest of those red states are pretty much just the states that always vote red + florida (and florida does what florida does).
Obama campaigned on change, people voted for him because they believed him. Many of them were white. Now, when those same people refuse to vote or vote for Trump. They are nothing but racists. The media and democratic party narrative doesn't hold water.
http://www.politico.com/story/2016/11/donald-trump-transitio...
You didn't think the US Government could be run entirely by outsiders did you ?
What we got is mathematically 4 realities. Both slander campaigns could be more or less true, in which the two most hated candidates in the world was really poor candidates for the two biggest parties in the united states. Both slander campaigns could be wrong, in which the voters where tricked by two political parties which should have known better to not bet a political election on slander. The two remaining options that only one slander campaign is wrong, is really only believed within the bubbles. It is very unlikely that anyone will be converted who already aren't.
Some people read the damaging emails. Other people only read the emails about Hillary getting a creme brulee because that's what her talking points focused on.
There was a lot in there that was very damaging and she refused to address pretty much all of it.
The quotes are out of context, making them seem much worse than when you actually read the surrounding paragraphs. Good try by author of the site to make these seem interesting but to be honest her emails seem entirely pedestrian and boring.
So take #2 as an example:
The open borders thing is pretty much slam dunk evidence that she wanted the TPP.
Trump alluded to this in his last advert about "elites".
Did she try to deny this? No, not really. She only came out against the TPP (weakly) after Sanders campaign hammered her on it and once the email was out in the open she lost all credibility on that.
This was a particularly important issue to the rust belt, where she lost heavily.
Even if you aren't, she was likely aware of all of this which is why she tried to conceal the paid speech where she said it.
Sure TPP is bad news but I really don't see why her being weakly in support of it followed by weakly against it is really that damaging/interesting.
Same goes with a bunch of the others. The one on her "paying" people to disrupt rallies is a bunch of garbage. She received what looks like a newsletter from something called MoveOn, perhaps she even donated money to it. This thing seems to organise people to to protest against things they find reprehensible (which is apparently Trump to these people). The site tries to make it out that she directly paid people to go and start a riot. In reality it looks like she may have donated money to this thing.
Either way it's still entirely uninteresting, boring, run of the mill stuff.
If there was really damaging emails I am sure they would be at #1.
She's been trying to be the Democratic nominee for decades, there was a reason she lost every time until now...and her opponent was openly socialist.
That too is part of the bubble. Or the two bubbles, perhaps. Completely different views of what reality is like. In one reality, Hillary is a crook, global warming a hoax, liberals evil, racism not an issue, and Trump a great business man and family man without any scandals. In the other bubble, it's the other way around.