ABACUS was a synthetic CDO. The short side wanted to buy CDS on a set of underlying bonds. The long side wanted to issue the CDS.
The only relation it has to bonds is that ACA structured the transaction to behave similarly to a set of bonds. The synthetic CDO could not have existed if someone was not explicitly trying to short the underlying bonds.
As for ACA working with Paulson, yet somehow not knowing they were short, I'm having a hard time believing it. If it is true, how come the SEC isn't charging Paulson with fraud?
Regarding the mechanics of it, it also seems extremely unlikely. The purpose of their meeting is to negotiate with Paulson - to build the best CDO possible (to increase the changes of finding buyers) while still allowing Paulson to get the short they desire. I find it extremely unlikely that somehow, they didn't figure out that Paulson was short during this process.
I assume Paulson's not being charged because it wasn't Paulson who told ACA he was long, it was Goldman. As for why ACA couldn't figure out he was short on their own, I don't know. Maybe they'd already had a lot of experience with people doing this kind of thing and walking out the other end okay? Maybe they thought Paulson was smarter than they were, and if he were long on these things, than there must be something to it? Maybe they're just happy to keep cashing the 'trusted independent 3rd party' checks Goldman keeps sending their way?
In synthetic CDO's, precisely zero. Consumption goods are purchased for other reasons, however.
I assume Paulson's not being charged because it wasn't Paulson who told ACA he was long, it was Goldman. As for why ACA couldn't figure out he was short on their own, I don't know.
Paulson and ACA were in direct collaboration on the creation of the CDO. They talked to each other directly on many occasions. If Paulson deliberately pretended to be the long side, when they were really the short side, that sounds like clear cut fraud on their part. So why isn't the SEC going after Paulson?
In any case, I obviously don't have the ability to prove Paulson never said they were the long side. On the other hand, it's the job of the SEC to prove that a) ACA asked who the longside was and b) Goldman/Paulson lied about it. I see virtually no evidence of this.
In a subprime CDO it's far more important to know who is holding the mortgages. I'm assuming they are subprime CDOs as that was Paulson's bread and butter.
What special position does Paulson have that he can effectively convince people to stop paying their mortgages?
ACA made a bet that people would pay their mortgages, Paulson made a bet that they wouldn't. If the CDO market didn't collapse there would be no case brought.
If knowing who was on the other side was so important, why did ACA decline to ask?
If the SEC wants to find the responsible parties for the collapse why don't they look towards the Dept. of Treasury and the Federal Reserve?
And the ACA that ended up long was the parent company, "ACA Capital Holdings, Inc", not the management company, "ACA Management LLC", that worked with Paulson to put together the portfolio. I won't claim to know what the exact relationship between the two companies was, but the former didn't actually enter it's long position until 3 months after the latter signed off on the portfolio.
The direct shorts that everyone knew about were the people selling the underlying mortgages up the chain, and the reasons they were short were well understood by everyone involved (cash now vs. over 30 years, etc.).