Re:Spotify excessively writing to drive
by test1235 on Thursday November 10, 2016 @03:54AM
(#12918788)
The first reply on the top of that page is a classic
"Isn't installing Spotify in a regular HDD an option?"
Just completely ignore the problem and find a way to let you pretend it doesn't exist.
Re:Spotify excessively writing to drive
by raimue on Thursday November 10, 2016 @04:41AM
(#12919010)
I think that often happens on support forums, because the power user volunteers trying to help others are too enthusiastic about the product. They have a deep bond to the product, that is strengthened by getting the (mental) reward of being recognized as an expert by answering a lot of questions on support forums. Therefore they will continue to use the product, even if it requires them to change their habits or to apply (costly) workarounds. Of course their answers will be written with this sentiment, so their suggestions might completely ignore the problem.
Re:Spotify excessively writing to drive
by maccard on Thursday November 10, 2016 @04:31AM
(#12918959)
After reading this thread, I'm actually going to do just that. Not that I agree with the solution but it solves my issue at least
EDIT: Just tried to do so, and the spotify installer doesn't let you choose where to install.
Re:Spotify excessively writing to drive
by test1235 on Thursday November 10, 2016 @06:16AM
(#12919454)
A typical response here would be, "Have you tried just switching out your main hard drive to a non-SSD and making that the default install location? Good luck!"
Re:Spotify excessively writing to drive
by cosmie on Thursday November 10, 2016 @04:10PM
(#12924384)
Go to Preferences -> Advanced Settings -> Change Cache Location
It's the VACUUM'ing of the SQLite database in that folder that's the problem. Moving that destination to your other drive should hopefully move the IO with it (I don't have a second drive to test with)
Also, they fixed this a couple months ago it seems. Page 22 of the comments in OP link.
Re:Spotify excessively writing to drive
by maccard on Thursday November 10, 2016 @02:27PM
(#12923396)
I checked with some of my colleagues in work. My machine had 220GB written in 2 days. Another colleague had 300GB.
Re:Spotify excessively writing to drive
by mschulze on Thursday November 10, 2016 @06:43AM
(#12919582)
You can set the location of the cache in advanced settings IIRC.
It is not the cache that causes the heavy IO. It is the SQLite DB at
AppData\Local\Spotify\mercury.db
AppData\Local\Spotify\mercury.db-wal
See http://blog.scaleprocess.net/spotify-heavy-io-problem/
Besides that, a lot of times setting a diff location for your cache does NOT move the cache. I had to use a symlink.
Re:Spotify excessively writing to drive
by mikeash on Thursday November 10, 2016 @10:38AM
(#12921254)
Thanks for pointing that out. Even ignoring the excessive writes, it'll be nice to have the cache take up space on my vast spinny drive rather than on my somewhat tight SSD.
Re:Spotify excessively writing to drive
by cosmie on Thursday November 10, 2016 @04:13PM
(#12924407)
The folder isn't as large as the IO usage makes it out to be. The entire PersistentCache directory is only ~104MB on my drive, even with >300GB written in the last few days
Good to know. I assumed it would not be dozens of GBs, but I assumed it might be one or two.
For a service I love dearly and have been using for 8 years, both their client applications and their support thereof has always been astoundingly lacking.
I've reported numerous bugs, and they almost always go unanswered for years, while some community elevated user will respond in a well-meaning but non-relevant answer, suggesting some run-of-the-mill IT tech solution, without any insight into the actual problem nor the Spotify tech.
I have rarely ever seen a Spotify rep taking client bugs seriously. Which is a shame.
But on that note: Has anyone tried Tomahawk? Or any other alternative client? I've been meaning to try something else but haven't gotten around to it.