News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Donald Trump’s Contract with the American Voter [pdf] by olalonde on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @05:48PM (#12915581)
I can't tell if you're being sarcastic but in case you're not, the question is not whether it should be forbidden (e.g. by park rules) to "wash a fish at a faucet if it's not a fish-washing faucet, in a national forest" but whether there should be a law that makes such thing a federal crime.
Re:Donald Trump’s Contract with the American Voter [pdf] by mikeash on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @05:55PM (#12915656)
How can something be forbidden in a national forest other than making it a federal crime?
Re:Donald Trump’s Contract with the American Voter [pdf] by olalonde on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @06:07PM (#12915761)
Putting "Do not wash fish in faucet" signs up would probably go a long way. If the problem gets completely out of hand, make it a civil offense that carries a fine.
Re:Donald Trump’s Contract with the American Voter [pdf] by ubernostrum on Thursday November 10, 2016 @01:37AM (#12918215)
Here's the thing, though: federal lands are administered directly by the federal government. The only avenues they have for rule-making are Congressional statutes and agency regulations. There is nothing else available to them to achieve the goal of making and enforcing a rule, because that's how they're legally set up.

So to forbid washing fish at a faucet in a national park... you literally do have to make a federal law (or a regulation with the force of federal law).

This is also why they have their own law-enforcement agency (the United States Park Police): Congress was, for a very long time, reluctant to authorize a general federal police force, so many agencies have their own specific police force operating solely within that agency's jurisdiction. It also creates fun inter-jurisdictional issues since the U.S Capitol building has its own separate police force, but the Capitol building is on the National Mall, which is Park Police territory.

Re:Donald Trump’s Contract with the American Voter [pdf] by tptacek on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @06:25PM (#12915924)
According to 16 USC 551, a fine is indeed what you're likely to get for violating this regulation.

The issue here is that the statute authorizing criminal penalties covers a whole range of national park regulations, some of which clearly merit stiff penalties, and some of which are just about washing fish safely.

Re:Donald Trump’s Contract with the American Voter [pdf] by olalonde on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @06:48PM (#12916134)
But is it a "crime" (one that gets you a criminal record) as opposed to something like a parking ticket? This is what I thought we were arguing about but IANAL and might have misunderstood what OP meant.
Re:Donald Trump’s Contract with the American Voter [pdf] by rayiner on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @06:56PM (#12916197)
It's a misdemeanor and gets you a criminal record. But so does a speeding ticket in states like Maryland or Georgia where all moving violations are misdemeaors.