News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Show HN: Mest – Place to talk with those you disagree with by austincheney on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @11:54AM (#12911898)
A two party system is a large part of this problem. One group validates itself by demonizing the only other player in town. It's toxic and it energizes the most self-serving of us.
Re:Show HN: Mest – Place to talk with those you disagree with by pmarreck on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @01:13PM (#12912925)
The two-party system is a direct consequence of the winner-takes-all, first-past-the-post voting system.

If you want more than 2 polarizing parties to emerge, you have to use an alternative voting system which allows ranking, such as IRV, and thus encourages third parties instead of disincentivizing them (due to spoiler effect).

Re:Show HN: Mest – Place to talk with those you disagree with by r3dk1ng on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @05:56PM (#12915662)
Thank you for mentioning Instant Runoff Voting. I've been trying to get anyone IRL to have any interest in it at all. Even the third party nerds weren't interested even though it'd benefit them.
Re:Show HN: Mest – Place to talk with those you disagree with by Houshalter on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @06:46PM (#12916117)
IRV is better but not perfect. If third parties actually start to become viable, then they would start to steal first votes away from the moderate parties. Eventually they would steal enough votes to cause them to be eliminated. So you are still better off selecting the two major parties as your first vote, even if you don't really like them. If you have full tactical voting, it ends up exactly the same as plurality voting. And you get only 2 viable parties.

The best system seems to be approval voting. You just are allowed to vote multiple times if you want. And the candidate with the most votes wins like normal. See http://rangevoting.org

Re:Show HN: Mest – Place to talk with those you disagree with by vacri on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @10:48PM (#12917558)
We have IRV where we live. The major parties are still major parties, and the minor parties are thriving. The past couple of elected governments have had to make coalitions between major and minor parties to form government.

Your concerns just don't play out.

Re:Show HN: Mest – Place to talk with those you disagree with by Houshalter on Thursday November 10, 2016 @08:46AM (#12920273)
That sounds more like STV. IRV is only for single winner elections. You can't get coalitions or anything like that from single winner elections. The 2 major parties would still dominate any single winner election under IRV.

The problem with IRV is demonstrated in more detail here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7Q7rzqJ0YS8

I think it's still better than FPTP, and it does let third parties at least get some attention. But there are other, better, systems. IRV has been adopted in a few places in the US, and then abandoned shortly after. I think systems like approval voting have a better chance of catching on.

Re:Show HN: Mest – Place to talk with those you disagree with by aninhumer on Thursday November 10, 2016 @09:19AM (#12920516)
> You can't get coalitions or anything like that from single winner elections.

But you can get more third party candidates winning (in single winner districts), leading to coalitions within parliament, which is probably what the parent means.

Re:Show HN: Mest – Place to talk with those you disagree with by pitaj on Thursday November 10, 2016 @06:56AM (#12919654)
> If third parties actually start to become viable, then they would start to steal first votes away from the moderate parties.

Unless I misunderstand IRV, there is no "vote stealing" due to your vote automatically dropping off to your next-preferred candidate.

> Eventually they would steal enough votes to cause them to be eliminated.

I assume by "them" you're referring to a (previous) major party. In that case, I don't see an issue at all. This will simply mean that the voters get better options and the top two parties will be pulled more towards the median at threat of being surpassed by a third party.

> And you get only 2 viable parties.

This either contradicts the first point or is completely meaningless. Of course there will be two top parties by definition for any specific election. However, IRV allows voters who align themselves more with a particular third party to show their support for that party without possibly spoiling their next favorite candidate and resulting in one they oppose winning.

I looked at your link, and I'm unconvinced by this argument that IRV is no better than FPTP:

> A lot of voters will, in an election like Bush v Gore v Nader 2000, exaggerate their good and bad opinions of Bush and Gore by artificially ranking them first and last, even if they truly feel the third-party candidate Nader is best or worst. They will do this in order to give their vote the "maximum possible impact" so it is not "wasted". Once they make this decision, in IRV, Nader automatically has to go in the middle slot, they have no choice about him. If all voters behave this way, then automatically the winner will be either Bush or Gore. Nader can never win an IRV election with this kind of strategic voters.

This seems to assume that voters will not understand how the system works. What reason would voters have to rank Gore over Nader when there is no risk of spoiling anything and having the candidate farthest from them win? It's not like the ranks are worth more or anything. I can't think of any situation where putting Gore over Nader would result in "maximum possible impact" compared to the opposite ranking. This whole argument just seems very silly and misleading.

Re:Show HN: Mest – Place to talk with those you disagree with by Houshalter on Thursday November 10, 2016 @08:38AM (#12920215)
There is a much better explanation in this video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7Q7rzqJ0YS8 As the third party becomes more and more popular, eventually they steal enough first votes away from the main party to cost both of them the election.

It's true that IRV limits the cost of vote stealing. But first votes still matter a huge amount in IRV, and you can only give one first vote. So there can always be some vote stealing. This is not a problem when third parties are really small and inconsequential. But if this actually worked to create viable third parties that had significant percent of the vote (the main goal of people that want such systems, otherwise there is no point), it would become a huge issue.

The link I posted shows that approval and range voting do vastly better in computer simulations of elections. Which is nice because approval voting is much simpler. And there is never a scenario where you shouldn't vote for your favorite candidate, under approval voting.

The last issue has been experimentally observed in Australia:

http://rangevoting.org/AusAboveTheLine07.html

People insincerely rank the competing party in last place, even though they don't really think they are the worst party. The major parties encourage this, and explain to their voters how to vote strategically.

More issues here: http://rangevoting.org/IrvExec.html

Re:Show HN: Mest – Place to talk with those you disagree with by aninhumer on Thursday November 10, 2016 @08:51AM (#12920317)
This is a shorter video from the same source as the other reply that deals specifically with IRV: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JtKAScORevQ

>Unless I misunderstand IRV, there is no "vote stealing" due to your vote automatically dropping off to your next-preferred candidate.

The problem is that they drop to your next preferred candidate who has not been eliminated.

If you're thinking about the problems that occur with plurality voting, it's easy to imagine your second choice will always be a popular "safe" choice, but if third parties get stronger (which is surely the point?) those safe choices can end up being eliminated before your second choice can help them.

Re:Show HN: Mest – Place to talk with those you disagree with by pitaj on Thursday November 10, 2016 @11:23PM (#12927782)
Okay. That video explained it well. Thanks.
Re:Show HN: Mest – Place to talk with those you disagree with by paublyrne on Thursday November 10, 2016 @03:25AM (#12918661)
There is no reason why a 'third' or non mainstream party would not be moderate also. You will get the full gamut.

Of course most countries that have this system end up with regular coalition governments which is sometimes one criticism of the system. But surely a coalition working together as part of a parliament with at least three groups is better than two groups at perennial loggerheads with each other.

This only seems to lead to ever greater tribalism and us and them politics.

Re:Show HN: Mest – Place to talk with those you disagree with by vanadium on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @05:08PM (#12915188)
...which just passed in Maine (ranked-choice voting).
Re:Show HN: Mest – Place to talk with those you disagree with by jkestner on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @11:29PM (#12917726)
Cool. The "laboratories of democracy" in action. Hope it turns out well and spreads.
Re:Show HN: Mest – Place to talk with those you disagree with by lucaspiller on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @12:05PM (#12912034)
Do they actually want different things though? In the UK it seems like all the politicians want the same - and all the people want the opposite.
Re:Show HN: Mest – Place to talk with those you disagree with by arethuza on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @12:15PM (#12912185)
What policies do the current Conservative government, Labour, SNP government in Scotland, Plaid Cymru in Wales and the various parties in NI have in common?

Quite a few of those parties want to break away from the UK - which is about is fundamental a disagreement as you can have!

Re:Show HN: Mest – Place to talk with those you disagree with by austincheney on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @01:54PM (#12913371)
They want to get elected. So, in that regard they want the same thing. What you say to get elected is largely irrelevant, particularly if you can suggest the opposing party is more evil.

The goal isn't to be a good candidate, qualified, or even ethical... its to get elected out of a contest of two people.

Who ever uses the media most wins. It doesn't even have to be favorable news coverage or even make sense. Who ever appears on the screen the most or gets their name mentioned the most wins. Again, its only a contest out of two people and the general population is easily energized by emotions.

Re:Show HN: Mest – Place to talk with those you disagree with by renaudg on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @01:29PM (#12913122)
What ? Interested to know what side you think "the people" is on.
Re:Show HN: Mest – Place to talk with those you disagree with by yoz-y on Wednesday November 09, 2016 @12:15PM (#12912179)
From outside it more seems like all politicians want one thing, and half of the population wants the opposite.