Re:Why is electricity so hard to understand? (1989)
by tim333 on Tuesday November 08, 2016 @09:33AM
(#12900494)
Also Maxwell's equations only give you part of it - for the question of why an atom's electrons don't just fall into the nucleus you need QM. And then you get into the self energy of the electron which is not explained by any present physics (http://www.feynmanlectures.caltech.edu/II_28.html).
So you can't just do the math because we don't have all the math.
Re:Why is electricity so hard to understand? (1989)
by johncolanduoni on Tuesday November 08, 2016 @10:27AM
(#12900956)
For electrical phenomena (baring very very small scale, semiconductors) Maxwell's equations give you a huge amount of insight, especially the macroscopic variant. You can see things like plasmons and polaritons (though obviously not their quantization).
You won't really run into the atom stuff until you try to do something like calculate dielectric constants analytically, though self-energy is definitely a pretty easy trap to fall in even for macroscopic stuff.
Re:Why is electricity so hard to understand? (1989)
by bronlund on Tuesday November 08, 2016 @09:48AM
(#12900637)
You have a good point, but still, it's easier to explain to children stuff that makes sense.
I teach my children that we live in a sea of energy and that you can feel it when you move. It makes much more sense to them than trying explain inertia.
I tell them that of you rotate something, it will make an energy vortex making stuff seem heavier - and I show them with a gyroscope.
Then I explain that electrons are just like little gyroscopes, but of only energy. And it all makes sense to them. They don't think it's hard at all.
Re:Why is electricity so hard to understand? (1989)
by JoeAltmaier on Tuesday November 08, 2016 @09:52AM
(#12900663)
Hm. Children can learn the right terminology for things. Those words don't seem any easier to swallow than 'inertia' and 'charge' to me.
Re:Why is electricity so hard to understand? (1989)
by pjc50 on Tuesday November 08, 2016 @09:51AM
(#12900652)
Those are excellent metaphors which I've never heard anywhere else.
Re:Why is electricity so hard to understand? (1989)
by matthewmcg on Tuesday November 08, 2016 @09:55AM
(#12900684)
They're reminiscent of Feynman's anecdote about his father explaining inertia:
Re:Why is electricity so hard to understand? (1989)
by phee on Tuesday November 08, 2016 @11:58AM
(#12901842)
"That - he said - nobody knows". It's kind of different from "we live in a sea of energy". I honestly think inertia is a lot easier to grasp than energy. It's a phenomenon you can experiment, describe and name, energy is more abstract.
It's useful to be able to explain things to laypeople and the not mathematically inclined, which means tightening up the metaphors.