News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Soylent Thinks It Found What Was Making People Sick: Algae by amelius on Monday November 07, 2016 @02:32PM (#12894170)
> You can say the same thing about the food in any restaurant.

But Soylent is supposed to be consumable on a daily basis, so long-term effects are important. Remember the documentary Super Size Me, which tested long term effects of food from a certain fast-food restaurant? [1]

[1] http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0390521

Re:Soylent Thinks It Found What Was Making People Sick: Algae by nilkn on Monday November 07, 2016 @05:27PM (#12895806)
I imagine that's why the company is still tweaking the formula based on results. It's not like they picked a formula years ago and have refused to iterate.

I have to agree with the above poster. I don't understand the hate directed at Soylent, and I don't understand what folks expect them to do. The company is very transparent as well, which is exactly what you'd hope for a company trying to develop a product like this. In many cases, the folks who say the problem Soylent is tackling is borderline impossible are the same ones who expect them to find a perfect formula right out of the gate and see any stumbling blocks as vindication that the whole effort is doomed. These expectations seem grossly at odds to me.

For what it's worth, many people absolutely do eat restaurant food on a daily or nearly daily basis. In the past year of eating a mixture of food from restaurants, home-cooked meals, and Soylent, I've only ever gotten sick (severely so, at that) from restaurant food.

Also, as for that documentary, he just lived off fast food for a month, right? That's hardly long-term. Plenty of folks have effectively repeated exactly the same experiment with Soylent many times over at this point. He also didn't just eat fast food, but intentionally overconsumed (hence the title of the documentary), which is quite contrary to the purpose of Soylent (given that each bottle is just 400 kcal).

Re:Soylent Thinks It Found What Was Making People Sick: Algae by hueving on Monday November 07, 2016 @03:17PM (#12894625)
That documentary tested overeating well outside the bounds of any sane nutritional guidelines. It's sad that people don't have the critical thinking skills required to realize the same thing would happen if you ate those levels of calories at any restaurant or even at home.
Re:Soylent Thinks It Found What Was Making People Sick: Algae by dnautics on Monday November 07, 2016 @03:48PM (#12894900)
wasn't there a counter-documentary where someone ate from mcdonalds every day and also followed a fairly strict exercise regimen and wound up being way fitter than when he started?
Re:Soylent Thinks It Found What Was Making People Sick: Algae by endophage on Monday November 07, 2016 @04:12PM (#12895164)
Yep, it was called "Fat Head." The exercise regime wasn't even that strict, it was basically continuing the regular walking the documentarian already did. However, the food intake was strictly limited to 1800 calories and less then 100g of carbs per day. The goal being to show fast food isn't inherently unhealthy, it was the quantity (as already noted above) being eaten in Super Size Me that was unhealthy. In that regard, Fat Head succeeded as the documentarian's health metrics all improved (lot weight, lower blood pressure, better cholesterol measurements).
Re:Soylent Thinks It Found What Was Making People Sick: Algae by glandium on Monday November 07, 2016 @05:26PM (#12895800)
Note that the premise of "Super Size Me" was to get the "Super Size" menu whenever asked by the Mc Donald's counter clerk, leading to overconsumption.
Re:Soylent Thinks It Found What Was Making People Sick: Algae by dogma1138 on Monday November 07, 2016 @05:37PM (#12895880)
Yes, but the overall point remains if you overeat you'll get fat regardless of what it is.

You can actually get a balanced daily diet out of mcdonalds if you ask for unsalted fries and get one of their salads once in a while.

Honestly sodium aside the only thing you need to do not to over eat at MC is to get water instead of soda and just regular sized burger.

It will be around 600-700 cals per meal with fries which means you can eat 3 of those a day and maintain weight or even lose some depending on your age, sex, bodymass and daily regiment.

Re:Soylent Thinks It Found What Was Making People Sick: Algae by jghn on Monday November 07, 2016 @04:18PM (#12895222)
As others mentioned, there was.

I did this myself around the same time as Super Size Me for a handful of reasons, none of which were to prove a point. I had good results from it. Would I have been even better off if I wasn't eating fast food for every meal? Probably. But I certainly wasn't worse off for eating that way and it scratched the itches which led me to that path in the first place.

Re:Soylent Thinks It Found What Was Making People Sick: Algae by tiglionabbit on Monday November 07, 2016 @04:09PM (#12895124)
Re:Soylent Thinks It Found What Was Making People Sick: Algae by darawk on Monday November 07, 2016 @02:39PM (#12894238)
Ya, I agree. Long-term effects are important. But AFAIK there's no indication of any long-term harm from Soylent. There's only an indication that a particular batch may have been contaminated.

This suggests not that they were careless in choosing their formulation or research, but that there was an error in the manufacturing process. This is something that can happen to any company, and has many times. Should they fix it? Yes. But I don't think they should be held to a higher standard here than anyone else.

Re:Soylent Thinks It Found What Was Making People Sick: Algae by M_Grey on Monday November 07, 2016 @04:24PM (#12895280)
There's no indication of long-term anything from Soylent, just people screaming that it must be bad, or people screaming that it's the future. It's mostly a ton of anecdote, and no reason to believe that it's particularly harmful, or particularly healthy in the long-term.

My feeling? You want to beta-test that with your health, I won't stop you, but I won't join you either.

Re:Soylent Thinks It Found What Was Making People Sick: Algae by WillPostForFood on Monday November 07, 2016 @07:40PM (#12896636)
All diet choices amount to beta testing with your health. There is no (known) correct way to eat, so we choose the best we can based culture/health class/news stories/diet gurus/doctors. It is very hard to make the case that eating Soylent (never tried it myself), is meaningfully different from choosing to go macrobiotic, or paleo, or following the food pyramid.
Re:Soylent Thinks It Found What Was Making People Sick: Algae by M_Grey on Monday November 07, 2016 @07:58PM (#12896728)
How about just... eating food? I know, I know... so unpopular, but "Paleo, Macro..." all of that crap? Let it go. Outside of people trying to sell you shit, including books, the best advice you'll ever get is just to eat a relatively balanced diet, keep up fiber intake, and maintain a healthy weight. Whether you prefer or personally thrive more on meaty diets, or eating a lot of barley isn't really that hard to figure out.

You don't need to chug slurry 24/7, or eschew all carbs to achieve it. Avoid too much of any one thing, avoid too much processed crap (not because it's inherently bad, but because it's usually loaded with salt and sugar), and learn to cook. It's hardly a science, but you have large historical samples of people living that way, compared to a couple years of someone telling you that you can spend the rest of your days drinking the latest gray sludge.

Re:Soylent Thinks It Found What Was Making People Sick: Algae by WillPostForFood on Monday November 07, 2016 @08:23PM (#12896850)
There is no such thing as just "eating food" - you are making diet choices, consciously and/or subconsciously in everything you choose to eat. Your comment is loaded with all sorts of diet judgement (fiber good, salt bad, balanced good, processed bad). We could find out barley causes cancer, or even though you thrive on a meaty diet, it causes heart disease. Or diet doesn't matter and it is all genetic or micro-biome. There is no diet that isn't beta testing.
Re:Soylent Thinks It Found What Was Making People Sick: Algae by M_Grey on Monday November 07, 2016 @09:45PM (#12897185)
The odds of finding out that something like barley and chicken are especially carcinogenic are a lot less than the odds that Soylent or Paleo or some other fad is frankly unhealthy.

Ignore the bulk of nutrition "research" which is after all, crap, and focus on the few things that are relatively sound. High fiber, healthy weight, good blood levels, get your nutrients. It's not that hard.

Re:Soylent Thinks It Found What Was Making People Sick: Algae by brandon272 on Monday November 07, 2016 @11:31PM (#12897663)
Couldn't it be argued that it's "relatively sound" that as long as you get a good balance of calories and macro and micro nutrients, which is exactly what Soylent provides, that you are on a good path?

FWIW, on the topic of healthy weight, the Soylent forum has many anecdotes of people who have used the product to lose (or gain!) weight because it allows them to easily count calories without having to spend time scanning products into MyFitnessPal every day and weighing all of their food.

Re:Soylent Thinks It Found What Was Making People Sick: Algae by WillPostForFood on Tuesday November 08, 2016 @12:27AM (#12897899)
The idea of "healthy weight, good blood levels, get your nutrients" is the goal of every diet I am aware of. But as for what goes in your mouth to achieve it, there is a plethora of conflicting ideas. I totally agree that the bulk of nutrition research is crap, which is why I put a barley and chicken diet, vegan diet, paleo diet, and Soylent diet in the same "beta testing" category.
Re:Soylent Thinks It Found What Was Making People Sick: Algae by Frondo on Tuesday November 08, 2016 @01:19AM (#12898101)
My favorite two pieces of food advice both come from Michael Pollan:

"Eat food, not too much, mostly plants."

And:

"Don't eat anything your great-grandmother wouldn't recognize as food."

Re:Soylent Thinks It Found What Was Making People Sick: Algae by cthalupa on Tuesday November 08, 2016 @02:39AM (#12898380)
I hate the second quote. My great-gradmother wouldn't recognize all sorts of delicious cuisine from other culture's as food.

A better one might be "Don't eat anything someone's great-grandmother wouldn't recognize as food"

Re:Soylent Thinks It Found What Was Making People Sick: Algae by JohnnyConatus on Monday November 07, 2016 @03:49PM (#12894916)
The main point of that documentary was to make the creator famous by doing click-bait style journalism in long-form.
Re:Soylent Thinks It Found What Was Making People Sick: Algae by surge on Monday November 07, 2016 @06:23PM (#12896198)
Super Size Me was ridiculous, I bought into it too, but he was going out of his way to eat unhealthy at McDonald's. Even McDonald's puts nutritional information out there and doesn't recommend the daily intake of calories that guy was making.
Re:Soylent Thinks It Found What Was Making People Sick: Algae by EdHominem on Tuesday November 08, 2016 @12:32PM (#12902188)
The point is that they do recommend it, just not in the tiny print. 99% of what they say is "eat more", 1% is "with care".

The advertising shows combinations of items, the staff offer upsizing for a deal, etc. Their business model clearly takes advantage of upselling and impulse buys.

SSM is a story about what happens to someone who doesn't know any better and just goes to the convenient restaurant, eating the standard portions they sell. It's best viewed with that other documentary, about the guy who got skinny eating at McDs (and exercising!). It's not (strictly) the food that does it, but the portions and lifestyle it encourages.

Re:Soylent Thinks It Found What Was Making People Sick: Algae by miranda_rights on Monday November 07, 2016 @03:06PM (#12894522)
I'm not sure I'd consider 30 days to be "long term", but I do agree that long-term effects are important. I think deficiencies in important micronutrients take longer to have detectable effects and are harder to debug, in general though. It's why I am intrigued by Soylent but try to get my nutrients by just having a variety of foods in my diet.
Re:Soylent Thinks It Found What Was Making People Sick: Algae by philfrasty on Monday November 07, 2016 @02:53PM (#12894385)
„...long-term effects...“

Slightly OT: in regard to „long-term“ effects of food/diet, I am curious what you consider long-term? Is long-term a defined timeframe? Is it 1 year, 10 years, 1000 years (multiple generations)?

Re:Soylent Thinks It Found What Was Making People Sick: Algae by frugalmail on Monday November 07, 2016 @03:30PM (#12894738)
That's more entertainment than a real documentary.