Re:We’re Scientists, Moms, And We Avoid Non-GMO Products
by mbastress on Monday November 07, 2016 @01:24PM
(#12893459)
Similarly, I live in VT and have small food producers and farmers all around me. These products are also available in grocery stores, but when you can qualitatively observe the differences between the land and growing practices of GMO farmers and organic farmers, the choices are not presented in such a flat way as when lined up on a shelf.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:We’re Scientists, Moms, And We Avoid Non-GMO Products
by weberc2 on Monday November 07, 2016 @02:20PM
(#12894045)
I doubt the general public is qualified to decide which practices are better than others. For example, I grew up on a farm, but I couldn't tell you if free-range eggs are safer or healthier than eggs from caged birds. Nor could I tell you if chemical-free produce is safer than organic. Nor could I tell you if antibiotic-free meat is safer or healthier than "regular" meat. I can tell you what I've heard from my pro-GMO family and my anti-GMO friends, but without diving deeply into the studies and counter studies, it would be hard to draw an informed conclusion.
Re:We’re Scientists, Moms, And We Avoid Non-GMO Products
by chefkoch on Monday November 07, 2016 @02:32PM
(#12894172)
Isn't there a moral aspect of this?
Shouldn't you treat the animal you are "consuming" as good as possible?
Re:We’re Scientists, Moms, And We Avoid Non-GMO Products
by weberc2 on Monday November 07, 2016 @06:36PM
(#12896295)
Probably, but even here I doubt the public is qualified to make this call. The canonical example is a sow pen which has just enough room for a sow to lay down while she nurses her piglets; this is actually better for the animals because it prevents the sow (~800 lbs) from crushing her piglets (~5 lbs); however, laypeople see an animal rights violation.
Re:We’re Scientists, Moms, And We Avoid Non-GMO Products
by Dylan16807 on Tuesday November 08, 2016 @01:37AM
(#12898177)
Sure. But remember the main topic here is plants, and there are no moral considerations there.
Re:We’re Scientists, Moms, And We Avoid Non-GMO Products
by akvadrako on Tuesday November 08, 2016 @04:07AM
(#12898728)
What, you don't think plants have feelings?
https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2016/sep/12/peter-wo...
I can imagine you have more sympathy for animals than plants since they are more like us, but I suspect bias if you use that as a basis for morality.