News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:SimCity Player Spends 3 years on optimal city design by hugh3 on Thursday April 22, 2010 @05:39PM (#1286548)
A grid of subway stations with a stop at every block? Sounds rather expensive.

Besides, all attempts to build "perfect" cities in real life have resulted in dull and lifeless places. A certain amount of chaos is necessary to keep cities liveable.

Re:SimCity Player Spends 3 years on optimal city design by mixmax on Thursday April 22, 2010 @06:10PM (#1286641)
This is exactly Jane Jacobs thesis in the greatly influential book "The Death and Life of Great American Cities"

What Jacobs found is that communities thrive when there's a certain amount of chaos and layered complexity that arises from people interacting withe each other and the environment. That's why places such as Greenwich village and many old European cities seem so vibrant and full of life - they're not centrally planned, they've had time to mature and people have had the possibility to interact with the environment and each other in the chaotic neighborhood.

Re:SimCity Player Spends 3 years on optimal city design by Gormo on Friday April 23, 2010 @02:38PM (#1289082)
I think it's a pretty straightforward phenomenon: "chaos" = emergence and evolution. Prescriptive design = stagnation.

No intentionally-designed system has ever scaled to match the nuance of emergent complexity.

Re:SimCity Player Spends 3 years on optimal city design by dantheman on Thursday April 22, 2010 @05:50PM (#1286578)
Agreed, simcity uses a static model. So the rules can be deduced. In reality we don't actually know what the rules are and they are much more dynamic -- i.e. the introduction of the internet, the car, the cell phone, etc. These have impacts on cities, and what people expect from them.
Re:SimCity Player Spends 3 years on optimal city design by blhack on Thursday April 22, 2010 @06:47PM (#1286722)
Nature (including what humans decide to do) is very good at iterative optimization. When people do something and it works, they tend to continue doing that.

The reason that overly-planned cities (I live in one: Phoenix) don't work is that it's impossible to out-think millions of people all working to optimize your city in parallel all the time.

Obviously you need some urban planning to assist with things that regular citizens don't understand (utilities), but for the most part, if you let people be, they will build a city on their own.

Re:SimCity Player Spends 3 years on optimal city design by ido on Friday April 23, 2010 @06:05AM (#1287700)
I think your conclusion (only do the minimum planning you absolutely can't live without) is too extreme in the other direction (compare Huston with Portland or Vancouver).

I don't know what the ideal level of urban planing and regulation is, but I think it's probably somewhere in the middle of the road.

Re:SimCity Player Spends 3 years on optimal city design by brianobush on Thursday April 22, 2010 @05:53PM (#1286590)
what if the subways weren't subways we know of today, but rather conveyor belt like roads. might be feasible if in a more automated future.
Re:SimCity Player Spends 3 years on optimal city design by rlpb on Thursday April 22, 2010 @09:55PM (#1287001)
This is stuff of science fiction. I remembered Arthur C. Clarke for having written this, but apparently H. G. Wells was first: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Moving_walkway#Science_fiction
Re:SimCity Player Spends 3 years on optimal city design by ovi256 on Friday April 23, 2010 @05:42AM (#1287670)
Jules Verne did it before that, in the Floating Island if I remember correctly. Which is a parody of 19 century USA, by the way.
Re:SimCity Player Spends 3 years on optimal city design by ErrantX on Friday April 23, 2010 @04:56AM (#1287618)
I recommend reading Wells' "When the Sleeper Wakes" - the description of "future" technology is fascinating (particularly the moving walkways)
Re:SimCity Player Spends 3 years on optimal city design by hugh3 on Thursday April 22, 2010 @06:13PM (#1286646)
Heck, it's feasible now, but the power consumption and maintenance costs would be fairly insane compared to the plain old cars-and-roads solution. (How often do you see an escalator broken down? Pretty damn often.)
Re:SimCity Player Spends 3 years on optimal city design by pyre on Thursday April 22, 2010 @10:41PM (#1287087)
You see more stopped escalators because the escalator is the equivalent of combining the train and the track into the same thing. Tracks don't require the level of maintenance that trains do. Trains can be taken off of the tracks for maintenance, so you don't see the entire system break down when maintenance is done.

I use the rail system in Portland for transportation, and I can say that they fairly regularly have issues with trains on the tracks, or taking down sections of track for maintenance over a weekend.

Re:SimCity Player Spends 3 years on optimal city design by rbritton on Thursday April 22, 2010 @06:33PM (#1286688)
The vast majority of the stopped escalators I've seen are because some idiot thought it'd be fun to hit the stop button.
Re:SimCity Player Spends 3 years on optimal city design by coderdude on Thursday April 22, 2010 @06:46PM (#1286716)
How were you able to verify this?
Re:SimCity Player Spends 3 years on optimal city design by chaosmachine on Thursday April 22, 2010 @07:07PM (#1286752)
Perhaps he's the one pushing the button.
Re:SimCity Player Spends 3 years on optimal city design by Gormo on Friday April 23, 2010 @02:42PM (#1289093)
...as long as it's not built by the same people who implemented it at DFW. That place is hell to navigate.