> "Vendors pushing high-level synthesis have a decades long track record of overpromising and under-delivering."
Abstraction is important, but in hardware detail matters. In software you can afford to have a less efficient language if it results in faster development. This is absolutely not true of hardware.
High-level synthesis has usually held out misleading promises of portability; that you might be able to get some complex application working written by (cheaper, easier to hire) software developers, then just drop it straight onto a chip. That's simply not true because the constraints are different.
Chisel looks extremely promising, as it addresses a lot of what I'd say were Verilog pain points:
Algebraic construction and wiring
Abstract data types and interfaces
Bulk connections
Hierarchical + object oriented + functional constructionSystemVerilog has all sorts of nice object-oriented features, but you can't use any of them for synthesizable code as you're dependent on the tool vendors supporting useful, yet complex things (e.g., classes, inheritance). Chisel avoids this whole problem by giving you access to extremely useful programming features (e.g., classes, functional programming) while still maintaining compatibility with whatever your ASIC/FPGA toolflow is.
Sure you have to specify things at the gate level, but you have the power to build abstractions on top of that (and indeed most of the ones other HDLs would provide are already there).
But companies won't adopt Chisel because the tools they have now just work. So Chisel is of academic interest, and little else.