Re:2017 Chevrolet Bolt EV
by wlesieutre on Monday October 31, 2016 @12:03PM
(#12838037)
Hasn't been my experience, but I've never had a car nav system, just attempted to use other people's. Could be a learning curve issue since I'm used to my phone UI and not the cars'.
People downvoting honkhonkpants, please don't. You may disagree with him, but it's a well thought out discussion.
Theoretically the car nav has access to inertial/distance sensors which help a ton in tunnels/weak GPS spots. But I bet few cars have this. It would sure be nice to have this exported to phones somehow. (Heck, have the whole OBD feed exposed. One can dream...)
Re:2017 Chevrolet Bolt EV
by wlesieutre on Monday October 31, 2016 @12:24PM
(#12838290)
I imagine a car's sensors could be more accurate than a phone's because they're in a fixed orientation. Plus it can tell if you're turning the wheel and should have the same distance info that the odometer gets.
The OBD-II data should include odometer readings. I assume phones could at least get that via bluetooth dongles, but I'm not aware of any nav apps that do.
Re:2017 Chevrolet Bolt EV
by bostonpete on Monday October 31, 2016 @01:10PM
(#12838719)
> In my experience the only thing Google Maps navigation has going for it is superior data.
Well, I think most people would include price as something going for it as well.
Plus, data is huge. I have a nav package in my car but never use it because it can't route me around accidents/construction like Waze does. Driving in rush hour traffic on a construction-laden road every day, this has proven invaluable...
Those may be fair criticisms, but the only way you're likely going to get what you're asking for (Google's data with a UI as good as your car's) is through a more open and competitive model. On your phone, you probably have literally dozens of choices for GPS apps, but in your car you have one. And the one in your car will never get appreciably better, you're stuck with it.
Re:2017 Chevrolet Bolt EV
by greglindahl on Monday October 31, 2016 @01:54PM
(#12839200)
As much as I hate bringing Tesla into every EV thread, Tesla's nav uses Google data, and they've reved the UI for all car owners back to the first Model S shipped.
With CarPlay and Google Auto you can get some of these features. What I'd really like to see is a way for a phone to get access to the car's odometer, that is how car navigation systems continue to work in tunnels (by using dead reckoning).
Re:2017 Chevrolet Bolt EV
by greglindahl on Monday October 31, 2016 @01:54PM
(#12839211)
There are plenty of ODB2 bluetooth dongles out there... I've never seen one hooked up to a nav system, though.
After a road trip that showed me just how bad Apple Maps and Google Maps are, I switched to a third-party GPS app, and it combines the great UI and mapping directions (like you say, exquisite lane guidance[0]) but with the pros of a mobile phone (easier search/input and up-to-date maps and POI info)
[0] https://c2.staticflickr.com/4/3855/14390588297_f2743d8f05_b....
Just to address the tunnels issue, Waze is beginning to install beacons to improve guidance while underground.
http://www.foxnews.com/auto/2016/09/23/waze-sets-out-to-elim...
Disclaimer: I work for Google but not in the Waze team
Re:2017 Chevrolet Bolt EV
by eanzenberg on Monday October 31, 2016 @08:12PM
(#12842200)
Re: tunnels, with apple maps, I've never had an issue in tunnels. In Boston, going under the city on the 93, it predicts where I am in the route probably using the speed I was at when I entered the tunnel. I think the big dig is > 3 mi long tunnel.
In my experience the only thing Google Maps navigation has going for it is superior data. I really wish I could have my car's UI with Google's data.