News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Most Digital Photocopiers Save Every Page Ever Scanned by sili on Wednesday April 21, 2010 @01:23PM (#1282735)
Can someone explain the need for a copier to do that? Which engineer in his right mind thought that this would be a good idea without some routine clean up procedure?
Re:Most Digital Photocopiers Save Every Page Ever Scanned by Kadin on Wednesday April 21, 2010 @01:46PM (#1282810)
It says in the article that he had to use forensic / recovery software to extract the images from the drive. That suggests to me that they were deleted, just not overwritten.

It's just like "deleting" a file off of your desktop PC; it's unlinked, but the data is still physically present on the drive platters until it happens to be overwritten, unless you make a special effort to overwrite it -- and most applications don't do that.

I'm not sure that it's really a flaw in the copier design, because they're not intentionally retaining the images any more than your PC is intentionally designed to retain Word documents that you "delete" without overwriting.

The problem is that many users are unaware that a modern photocopier even contains a hard drive ... they are probably oblivious of the fact that modern copiers have little in common with the traditional photostatic machines they grew up with, except that they're faster and don't smell as much. Manufacturers need to better educate buyers (or lessees) about the machines they're using, and perhaps make hard drives more accessible so that when they're sold, they can have the drives removed and destroyed first.

Re:Most Digital Photocopiers Save Every Page Ever Scanned by ErrantX on Wednesday April 21, 2010 @02:04PM (#1282861)
I've done a few recoveries from Photocopiers in the past - pretty much what everyone has suggested is correct.

Once you get the HDD out it's easily treated like any other drive. Most of the documents will be deleted (there is often a buffer of non-deleted documents) but recovering them is pretty trivial. Some of the newer ones do actually scrub data at intervals now.

Re:Most Digital Photocopiers Save Every Page Ever Scanned by nkassis on Wednesday April 21, 2010 @10:30PM (#1283914)
Do these copiers (multifunction right?) include a function for this? I would hope that these copiers include a wipe drive button.
Re:Most Digital Photocopiers Save Every Page Ever Scanned by Frazzydee on Wednesday April 21, 2010 @01:46PM (#1282808)
The headline of the HN article is a bit misleading.

"using a forensic software program available for free on the Internet, he ran a scan - downloading tens of thousands of documents in less than 12 hours."

Since he had to use special software to extract the files, it looks like the software deletes the files, but not securely. Basically, it uses 'rm' instead of 'scrub'.

As explained below, storing scanned pages temporarily is good when photocopying (or faxing) multiple pages.

Also, the creator of the software mentioned (securely wipes photocopier harddrives) is a very smart marketer. The article is basically an advertisement for his software, "INFOSWEEP," and he's the one who showed the journalist this vulnerability in the first place.

Re:Most Digital Photocopiers Save Every Page Ever Scanned by oiuytfgvbhjnk on Wednesday April 21, 2010 @02:13PM (#1282888)
You need it to do multiple copies, double sided copies, collated etc. All the major maker's built-in software does overwrites of the data to various levels of security. Otherwise the government wouldn't buy them.

They also have fairly small drives - the companies are out to make money - so at somewhere like kinkos your job would be overwritten multiple times by the end of the day. It's only an issue if the system fails and the drive needs to be replaced - but anywhere operating under any sort of security regs would destroy the drive before it went off site.

We used to destroy them along with any waste explosive/munitions. Then health and safety stopped us and we had to buy a super monster shredder - which is a lot scarier than explosives but it can shred drives/entire files/interns etc.

Re:Most Digital Photocopiers Save Every Page Ever Scanned by billybob on Wednesday April 21, 2010 @02:50PM (#1283006)
Those are good points and legitimate use cases. But if they have small hard drives, how did the guy in the story recover "tens of thousands of documents" from 3 copiers? Why would a copier need to be able to store that many pages?

I mean, OK, hard drives are cheap, so maybe copier manufacturers just said "eh, even if they run huge jobs, they can come back and repeat them later. Only costs us a couple more bucks." But dang - they gotta address this.

EDIT: Hmmmm. I guess I just forgot how freaking big hard drives ARE these days. Discussion below about how a "small" 20GB drive could store so many documents at such-and-such size... oh yeah. It's startling to remember how gigantic 20GB sounded 10 years ago.

Re:Most Digital Photocopiers Save Every Page Ever Scanned by randrews on Wednesday April 21, 2010 @02:21PM (#1282915)
Why would you need nonvolatile storage for that? Why not just store it in RAM temporarily?
Re:Most Digital Photocopiers Save Every Page Ever Scanned by tedunangst on Wednesday April 21, 2010 @02:58PM (#1283025)
A hard drive could be cheaper than the amount of RAM required to store 20 pages of uncompressed scans.
Re:Most Digital Photocopiers Save Every Page Ever Scanned by randrews on Wednesday April 21, 2010 @04:01PM (#1283145)
If it's only 20 pages, I'd actually guess not. HDD + controller, for a minimum of (say) a 20 gig drive (I couldn't find any smaller ones), I'd guess would be a lot more than the extra hundred megs (tops) in the RAM that it already needs to have anyway. So it only makes sense to have a drive if you want to store a LOT more images than 20.

Maybe it needs a drive anyway for some other reason (like the software that runs it lives there instead of on a CF card or something), so it ends up being cheaper and easier that way?

Re:Most Digital Photocopiers Save Every Page Ever Scanned by Daniel_Newby on Wednesday April 21, 2010 @06:13PM (#1283361)
100 megs? A single letter-size sheet is 30 megs at 600 ppi.
Re:Most Digital Photocopiers Save Every Page Ever Scanned by randrews on Wednesday April 21, 2010 @06:39PM (#1283417)
Okay, so 600 megs. An extra gig of RAM has to be cheaper than a hard drive + controller you wouldn't otherwise need, right?
Re:Most Digital Photocopiers Save Every Page Ever Scanned by Daniel_Newby on Wednesday April 21, 2010 @09:11PM (#1283748)
Many people occasionally copy/print multi-hundred page documents. That runs to many gigs of RAM, $30 just for the DRAM chips. And then you need to design what amounts to a custom PC motherboard to talk to them. The price could easily run to $75, not counting the enormous engineering costs.

Or you buy a $40 ATA drive and connect it to your embedded processor's built-in interface.

Re:Most Digital Photocopiers Save Every Page Ever Scanned by mortenjorck on Wednesday April 21, 2010 @01:51PM (#1282821)
This, actually, was the first thing that came to mind:

http://www.eff.org/issues/printers

Re:Most Digital Photocopiers Save Every Page Ever Scanned by smokinn on Wednesday April 21, 2010 @01:58PM (#1282844)
That was really interesting but the EFF really should put a date somewhere on that page. A "last updated" or something because right now I have no clue when they wrote that and whether they're still investigating it.
Re:Most Digital Photocopiers Save Every Page Ever Scanned by _delirium on Wednesday April 21, 2010 @01:32PM (#1282764)
Short-term storage is useful for things like being able to make 5 photocopies of a document--- old copiers would have to literally run the copier across the document 5 times to do so. Now they're more like scanner->printer, so they scan once and print 5 times. They don't delete it immediately after the job either, because many copiers support convenience features like "ok, 2 more copies of that last document please". It does seem like they could delete once N more documents have been printed in between, though.
Re:Most Digital Photocopiers Save Every Page Ever Scanned by scott_s on Wednesday April 21, 2010 @01:40PM (#1282792)
Reading the story, it sounds like they are removed from the file system, but not securely erased.
Re:Most Digital Photocopiers Save Every Page Ever Scanned by ars on Wednesday April 21, 2010 @11:08PM (#1283994)
Not "more like" - they actually are scanners and laser printers. With some special paper handling for the printer.
Re:Most Digital Photocopiers Save Every Page Ever Scanned by sigstoat on Wednesday April 21, 2010 @01:33PM (#1282771)
i'd quite curious about this, myself.

the answer is also necessary to figure out how many images are probably being stored. if the copier is just keeping them for debugging reasons (which would explain why nobody knows they're there), then they could very well be highly compressed 72dpi images.