I'd be grateful if you can quote what parts can be read in a way that I didn't intend them to be, and I'll either choose less ambiguous expressions or omit the thought entirely, seeing how hard it is to communicate precisely.
* A repetition of the trope that sexual culture is to blame for the impact of rape. Rape isn't sex, and prudishness what forced this woman to kill herself. Misogyny was. The issue in the culture we're describing --- and in its echoes in our own culture --- is the power dynamic between men and women, in which women are seen as having an obligation to somehow temper the sexual impulses of men they come into contact with, or else avoid men altogether.
* A diversion from what is a Handmaid's Tale-grade story about the victimization of women to the entirely unrelated topic of whether men suffer unduly from accusations of rape. That's particularly galling given the specifics of this story.
Whether you intended to or not, your comment --- which as Michele notes is at the top of the thread --- had the clear effect of minimizing the tragedy and injustice depicted in this story. I think we should be ashamed of this whole HN thread, which is dominated more by whether the BBC's reporting was unfair to a 400 billion dollar social networking company than by any kind of reflection about what happened to the subject of the story.
I don't know you at all, and I make no claims about what your intent actually was. I'm happy to assume that this was all unintentional. I'm writing about your comment, not about you.
I admit that I'm less prepared to comment in a minefield topic like this than I had thought, as my comment has been easily, and rightfully so, misinterpreted. I'm sorry about that and grateful you do not assume too much. Knowing the etymology of 'victim', it would never cross my mind to do so.
I agree with your explanation how rape and subsequent shaming and general mistreatment is being facilitated, and I think the root cause is our conflicted and unhealthy approach to sexuality. I don't think it would reach the same effect if sexuality was a mundane topic, so that abuse can be treated as a crime rather than, as you say, presented as disobedience by those in positions of power and widespread misogyny in general. If it wasn't a taboo topic, victims would probably be more inclined to come forward and falsely accused but acquitted wouldn't be shunned as easily. That's the gist of my theory, if I look at it like a programmer, a logician. How true that is in the real world I don't know, and I'm sorry for not phrasing it as an open question to begin with.
Basically I tried and failed to paint a complete picture how society prefers to mark abuse victims as well as falsely accused perpetrators as personae non grata rather than find solutions to the problem. Tragically, society fails so much that it causes and is responsible for suicides. I blame society only, and theorize that our inexcusably wrong approach to sexuality facilitates it.
Neither was I trying to say that her death is an inevitable outcome or that men are somehow led to commit those heinous crimes. Thinking men have no choice and have to be protected is why some wives have to wear veils. It's wrong, at least 2300 years late in human society, and nothing I stand behind. Seeing how my comment has been interpreted that way convinced me that I'm unprepared to debate this topic in an international plaintext forum among people who don't know each other personally. Sorry.
Any insensitivity I may have expressed in the comment is because I'm a technically minded person first, thinking in terms of logic, and looking for the root cause of a segfault (societal flaw). I guess I'll stay with technical topics where there's a closed world with rules I can look up.
This thread, and your comment in particular, provided me with a more complete picture than I had this morning. Thanks for pointing out the flaws and incomplete parts of my thoughts. I believe in constructive criticism and open debate, so asking someone "did you really mean .... or what is it you're trying to say?" is my preferred approach rather than making assumptions, so thanks. Also, yes, if we knew each other personally, you'd have been more likely to correct me, knowing what kind of person I am. Thank you for not reducing me to a utf-8 blob on HN.
http://micheleincalifornia.blogspot.com/2015/11/not-really-r...
Let me try to rephrase: I'm not saying this was the case in this incident, but the fairly unique classification rules of the society in question may increase the chances of such an outcome and be another reason to rethink the rules.
Your sentiment is vile and dehumanizing. It's carefully veiled and couched so as to make it appear to be a cousin of a feninist appeal for sex workers rights, with the safety of these victims in mind. But even casual inspection of your intent reveals that you believe that unless sated by a sex industry, rape is inevitable and we shouldn't blame the monsters who commit it.
I am sure you will protest this and cite the weight of history. Men's rights advocates usually do. And I'll happily point out that progressivism and the slow progress of women's rights against all odds and a nearly endless series of arguments like yours is also a pressure of history. One that many of us are working to further.
Don't take it personally. It might help to disengage for a bit and let people say whatever dumb stuff they are going to say. You are not required to reply to every single comment. Sometimes it is more effective to be a bit selective about what you reply to.
Best.
Edit: You have the top comment. So some people are silently agreeing with you by upvoting you.
The ingenuity with which people continue to reframe every story about rape around "what drove men to do it" and to reinforce the message that such actions are a pressure from a society that is in fact biased against men's sexual needs is amazing.
Edit: Your comments are delicious irony given how often I get accused of being a feminist on this forum and accused of writing feminist blogposts merely for being openly female and giving my personal opinions here.
You do this sort of thing a lot and it is much more about enhancing your ego than about enhancing the status of women, which you seem to be not terribly knowledgeable about how to do effectively.
But your gender identity means little to me nor will it soften my tone if you want to defend that argument. It is at its core an argument that deserves to be censured. It is another plank in the structure that blames victims of sexual assault.
But the reality is that there are studies suggesting that porn has reduced the incidence of rape and that conservative eras where good girls cannot put out have a great deal more prostitution. So, the essence of his position is not incorrect. It in no way justifies this heinous crime, but raking him over the coals over the deficiencies in his writing also in no way will improve his ability to express the idea effectively and appropriately.
Thank you for the apology. Rest assured I have no desire to have you "soften your tone" over my gender.
http://micheleincalifornia.blogspot.com/2014/01/oh-my-god-it...
I have a great deal of difficulty reading this position from your response above. But I will take you at your word. Thank you, I appreciate the time you spent further clarifying your point to me.
> It in no way justifies this heinous crime, but raking him over the coals over the deficiencies in his writing also in no way will improve his ability to express the idea effectively and appropriately.
I am not here to or improve anyone. I am here to coldly and meticulously point out misogyny and rape culture of Hacker News wherever I see it. I am not interested in correcting behavior beyond that. It's not my place or my desire to be anything other than to throw a bucket of cold water on every case of it I see.
If you feel a higher calling, I wish you good luck. I no longer care to attempt to carefully untangle if someone is an MRA or if they are just using arguments very much like an MRA uses.
You were quick to leap to conclusions about me and tar me. I see this as fundamentally problematic, regardless of your agenda, and quite counterproductive if you want to end rape culture.
Not that you are in any way required to take that point of view under advisement or act on it.
> I see this as fundamentally problematic, regardless of your agenda, and quite counterproductive if you want to end rape culture.
That is your opinion. I think shame has its place. We are on a curious website where we can actively call people names if we are discussing technology and it is considered par for the discourse. But once the space of "politics" (read as, "fundamental human rights") enters the equation then suddenly we must all suddenly respect everyone's right to any opinion no matter how oppressive or facile. I reject that notion.
I will not be able to respond to you anymore today. I am rate limited and I'm fairly sure this is my final post for the day.
Since I already allowed as how that was merely my point of view, it is redundant to tell me that is just my opinion.
I do not care about your assessment of how well I'm enhancing the status of women. I'm not an "ally", just a commenter with opinions. You can score me an "F" on the rest of it --- I take no offense.
PS:
For whatever it's worth, I simplied replied to the last comment on the thread --- I didn't single you out. But the thought did go through my mind that I should be relieved I was responding to you and not Dave, because Dave would flip the fuck out if I stepped in. :)
If I simply have not noticed it, I would be thrilled to pieces to see evidence that it occurs and I simply missed it. Because I am entirely unaware of it, but painfully aware of the negative effect that the shunning of women by top ranked members has here.
Thank you for the comment though.
I'm married to (and business partners with) a woman in a competitive part of tech. I do not need to be convinced that this kind of stuff happens to women, or that I might be contributing to it myself by some stupid habit of expression. To whatever extent I've done that in the past: I'm sorry!
I actually do worry about point-scoring with comments about misogyny, by the way, so much so that right after I wrote my comment towards the top of the thread, I sanity checked it with Erin, who has taken me to task before for appropriating her anger at how women are treated in our industry and scoring RT's and likes with it. She said this particular case --- and that comment at the top of the thread --- were so bad that I was in the clear this time.
If you see me doing that somewhere else on HN, you'll be doing me a favor to point it out, and I'll do my best to listen and respond civilly.
I am about to log off, possibly for essentially the rest of the evening.
Have a good discussion, probably without me from here on out.
It's weird that we only ever see people complaining about this form of it. Predictable, but weird.
I won't go into how there used to be societies which in some regards were more open and safer than today's, or how the treatment by a part of some religious communities goes against those religions' core beliefs.
Empowering people to defend themselves and deal with abuse in a dignified way is very important, and we first need to stop blaming victims as "promiscuous" or "having asked for it". This isn't very different from how we treat people who went to prison.
EDIT: We also need to find a good way to investigate accusations without automatically assuming that, for instance, alleged male perpetrators are by default considered (not found, to be clear) guilty, or that wives do not abuse their husbands. The described societal defects are partly to blame, as are underequipped/unskilled law enforcement or judicial departments. If someone can lose their job and family because anybody merely publicly accuses them of a sex crime or adultery, then it's clear we have a problem on the other end of the spectrum. To me, both are caused by related societal flaws and will take a long time to correct. Another way this surfaces is that people tend to worry more about a government official's personal life than their positive/negative acts in office.