News for hackers. Stuff that matters.

Ask YC: Would it make sense to build a social news site using bounce rate instead of voting?

From http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bounce_Rate:

"The Bounce Rate for a single page is the number of visitors who enter the site at a page and leave within the specified timeout period without viewing another page, divided by the total number of visitors who entered the site at that page."

You could approximate this in a social news site by seeing what fraction of users quickly return after checking out a link.

Given that most users don't vote at all, perhaps something like this would be desirable?

( 23 comments | 11 points | on HN )
Re:Ask YC: Would it make sense to build a social news site ... by mixmax on Monday March 03, 2008 @02:24PM (#128239)
What about if you open up every article you find potentially interesting in a new tab, and stay on the page?

This is how I use YC news, and I don't think im alone.

Re:Ask YC: Would it make sense to build a social news site ... by dkokelley on Monday March 03, 2008 @03:13PM (#128282)
I agree. I don't like how the links open over HN, so I always open the outgoing links in new tabs.

Feature request: Could the links to outside sites open in new tabs/windows by default, so that we don't navigate away from HN when we actually use this site?

Re:Ask YC: Would it make sense to build a social news site ... by joshwa on Monday March 03, 2008 @03:41PM (#128307)

  // ==UserScript==
  // @name				 news.yc open in new tab
  // @namespace		 http://joshwand.com/
  // @description	 opens links on news.yc's list pages in new tabs/windows
  // @include			 http://news.ycombinator.com/
  // @include			 http://news.ycombinator.com/news
  // @include			 http://news.ycombinator.com/newest
  // @include			 http://news.ycombinator.com/x?*

  // ==/UserScript==

  var a, links, thisdomain;
  thisdomain = window.location.host;

  links = document.getElementsByTagName('a');
  for (var i = 0; i < links.length; i++) {
      a = links[i];
      if (a.host && (a.host != thisdomain || String(a).match(/item\?id=/))) {
          a.target = "_blank";
      }
  }
Re:Ask YC: Would it make sense to build a social news site ... by some on Monday March 03, 2008 @05:14PM (#128364)
I would prefer the loop this way:

  for each(a in links) 
   if (a.host && (a.host!=thisdomain || String(a).match(/item\?id=/)))
    a.target = "_blank";
Re:Ask YC: Would it make sense to build a social news site ... by joshwa on Tuesday March 04, 2008 @12:41AM (#128643)
What can I say, I don't actually know JS. I just cargo-culted this from another similar script.
Re:Ask YC: Would it make sense to build a social news site ... by bkrausz on Tuesday March 04, 2008 @12:27AM (#128633)
Given the nature of browsers that would be counterproductive: one can easily setup browsers to open new tabs with the middle mouse button, but there's no way to stop new tabs/windows from being opened as such.
Re:Ask YC: Would it make sense to build a social news site ... by iamwil on Monday March 03, 2008 @03:25PM (#128293)
Given the way I surf hacker news, I'd get annoyed with that. I only open up new tabs when it takes a long time to load.
Re:Ask YC: Would it make sense to build a social news site ... by kingnothing on Monday March 03, 2008 @07:06PM (#128440)
You could just use your middle mouse button to click the links; that will open them in a new tab.
Re:Ask YC: Would it make sense to build a social news site ... by dkokelley on Tuesday March 04, 2008 @02:53AM (#128693)
That's what I currently do. But I have to actively evaluate the links. Is it a discussion/poll, or will this take me somewhere else?
Re:Ask YC: Would it make sense to build a social news site ... by pchristensen on Monday March 03, 2008 @03:43PM (#128309)
Yep, I open tons of tabs from the main screen, then I might not even look at it for 15, 30 minutes, then scan it for 10 seconds and kill it. 30 min + 10 sec doesn't indicate interest in my case.
Re:Ask YC: Would it make sense to build a social news site ... by Readmore on Monday March 03, 2008 @02:31PM (#128245)
My site klipboardz.com ups the vote on each story for any registered user that reads it, then a user can down vote it if they didn't like it. I assume that if you care enough to read a link then it should get an up-vote.
Re:Ask YC: Would it make sense to build a social news site ... by brk on Monday March 03, 2008 @04:20PM (#128332)
That seems a little bit illogical. Why does clicking a link equal up-votes? If you really want to factor in link clicks, then maybe a counter of the times the link has been clicked displayed alongside the votes would be interesting.

But making me come back to down-vote a crappy story/link is really kind of irritating.

Re:Ask YC: Would it make sense to build a social news site ... by Readmore on Monday March 03, 2008 @05:00PM (#128351)
But if the headline, description, and picture were enough to get you to read the link then it should get a bump. Most people go read the story and never come back, even if they liked it, to up vote. I do that all the time here.
Re:Ask YC: Would it make sense to build a social news site ... by s3graham on Monday March 03, 2008 @03:53PM (#128322)
I think people like clicking on the arrows to make them feel like they're having a say, without actually having to put in (much) effort.

In all honesty, the churn is so high on most sites that the bias is heavily skewed towards "current", not "me" so it might not feel as "smart" without the arrows.

But hey, what do I know. Sounds interesting enough to try as a quick hack of news.arc at the very least.

Re:Ask YC: Would it make sense to build a social news site ... by pchristensen on Monday March 03, 2008 @02:11PM (#128230)
I think that that's an important piece of information that's rarely used. Like brlewis says, not perfect, but I think you could use it well.

I think it's more suitable for a single site rather than a link aggregator/social news, because once you follow a link on the site, how do you know when the user leaves that page?

Re:Ask YC: Would it make sense to build a social news site ... by amichail on Monday March 03, 2008 @02:12PM (#128234)
As an approximation, you could see what fraction of users quickly return to the social news site after visiting the link.
Re:Ask YC: Would it make sense to build a social news site ... by brk on Monday March 03, 2008 @04:24PM (#128335)
When you're viewing a story from here, how often do you click anything else on the site? I don't click other links very often, even if I really enjoyed or benefited from the linked article. So, in the end you'll get different numbers, but they'd be no more complete or accurate than what you already have.

This idea would only seem to encourage more sites to spread a simple article across too many pages so that they could better count and track the visitors. But then as a referrer, you still couldn't do much to get access to those numbers.

Re:Ask YC: Would it make sense to build a social news site ... by nreece on Monday March 03, 2008 @09:58PM (#128539)
A good way to handle article voting is to have the voting panel (with the up & down arrows) as a window frame on top of the article webpage.

That way article voting is fairer (i.e. only users who click the article link from the news site to read the article get to see the voting panel). Secondly this approach also makes it easier for voters to rate the article instantly without having to go back & forth to the news site.

Re:Ask YC: Would it make sense to build a social news site ... by DarrenStuart on Monday March 03, 2008 @07:30PM (#128452)
I think a better way would be to develop a site that used a file to track views.

IE Each story has a unique image and that is inserted into the foot of the article. You could then count the uniques on that.

Re:Ask YC: Would it make sense to build a social news site ... by fleaflicker on Monday March 03, 2008 @10:06PM (#128542)
Google does this for ranking search results. It's not a new idea. I would be surprised if no social news site used it already.
Re:Ask YC: Would it make sense to build a social news site ... by brlewis on Monday March 03, 2008 @02:03PM (#128226)
No metric is perfect, but this one really sounds like it's worth a try.
Re:Ask YC: Would it make sense to build a social news site ... by fallentimes on Monday March 03, 2008 @03:45PM (#128310)
I think the amount and frequency of comments should play a role as well. Even if a user doesn't particularly like a link (as evidenced by a down vote) if the article is generating comments and discussion (vs. a preset benchmark) it shows that it's at least interesting and notable in some way.
Re:Ask YC: Would it make sense to build a social news site ... by gaika on Monday March 03, 2008 @07:41PM (#128456)
jaanix does it already, takes into account everything: views, clicks, ratings, tags.